This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Mary Hawking

  • LMC advises GP practices not to sign network contract

    Mary Hawking's comment 09 Jan 2020 3:26pm

    Read the BBO LMC analysis: its damning.
    It also makes a good point: why is this a *public* consultation on what is basically a specific GP T&C matter? Especially as the survey doesn't ask who you are..

  • Pulse 2019 review: Networks - collective working for bright future?

    Mary Hawking's comment 22 Dec 2019 11:30am

    "some remain positive, touting PCNs as a system change with as much potential to change lives as modern hospitals and heart transplants."
    Well, we have yet to see any "modern hospitals" - and the number of lives changed by heart transplants remains minute compared to the loss of lives associated with the pressures inflicted on the NHS since 2010 by - face it - the Conservative government - starting with the Health & Social Care Act 2012.
    It is unfortunate that NHS England (and all Secretaries of State for Health & Social Care) appear from their actions to believe that the answer to all the problems created is yet another redisorganisation involving unaccountable organisations without any guidelines/requirements for structure - and draconian penalties for the front line if there is any criticism or failure of enthusiastic support.
    Boris Johnson claims to be heading a new government: I had thought political parties had continuity when they changed Leaders? - so no doubt there will be more new plans along any minute now..

  • When a contract isn’t a contract

    Mary Hawking's comment 29 Oct 2019 11:39am

    When I was in practice, local Trust's IT was unable to cancel appointments - even when the patient had been rescheduled at their own request.
    This led to DNAs,GP calls/letters to patients upset patients ("I phoned the hospital & changed the appointment") upset consultants ("this patient somehow showed up in my clinic") & irritated GPs ("who on earth commissions an appointment system where you can't cancel or change appointments?!?").
    Have things improved since 2013?

  • Digital practice patients three times more likely to return to prior GP surgery

    Mary Hawking's comment 08 Jul 2019 11:10am

    The consultation - well worth reading & considering the implications for general practice and your local health communities
    closes 23rd August: you have time to comment

  • It’s not up to GPs to sort out national recruitment problems

    Mary Hawking's comment 04 Jul 2019 7:18am

    Remember Connecting for Health & NLOP (No Longer Our Problem: I can never remember the official meaning)?
    When things were not going according to plan, CfH passed responsibility for enforcement to SHAs - while not allowing any deviation from central diktats.
    Is history repeating itself?
    NLOP was hardly a success...

  • Practice asked to pay half a million in service charges for 'non-existent' services

    Mary Hawking's comment 03 Jul 2019 10:24am

    In 2013, basically, NHS England & government confiscated all the properties in which the local health economy - PCTs & predecessors - had invested & gifted them to a new, wholly owned company, with no accountability to anyone as far as I can see.
    Was this planned or a legislative/administrative blunder?
    As with Capita, something seems to have gone wrong somewhere (unless it was all part of a cunning plan) - or maybe a total success in helping to destabilise/abolish general practice.
    Too many "unintended consequences" might suggest that the original plans (if any) were not properly thought through.

  • NHS England: PCNs must succeed or face 'being salaried to other NHS providers'

    Mary Hawking's comment 01 Jul 2019 12:59pm

    How will Digital First affect all of this?
    This consultation on Digital First practices *is* important.. not that disagreeing (if possible) is likely to make any difference.
    I'm so glad to have retired!

  • New laws will make it easier for digital-first providers to set up new practices

    Mary Hawking's comment 29 Jun 2019 2:57pm

    Wouldn't work in rural or remote areas where internet access is either totally lacking or very poor, and GPs deal with minor injuries & cottage hospital services.
    How do "Digital First" services amanage in areas where the nearest A&E is over an hour away?

    "Digital First" could only cover patients who could afford digital access - which rules out many in deprived areas & most in remote areas.

    GPatHand patients are mostly young, mobile & healthy - but consume more health services than those registered with regular practices.

    Does NHS England ever think things through?

  • GP pensions to be 'more flexible' to improve retention

    Mary Hawking's comment 03 Jun 2019 11:35am

    When I was in practice, after the nGMS contract, it took awhile to work out what the partners' incomes were for the preceding tax year.
    Now that you have the additional complication of Capita incompetence, and a significantly higher employers contribution being calculated back by HMRC, will it be possible for GPs & their accountants to work out pension contributions before the deadline for filing?

  • RCGP calls for a more 'robust' NHS IT system

    Mary Hawking's comment 30 Apr 2019 12:02pm

    Is this a call for NPfIT v2?
    The Tech Manifesto appears to consist of an Infograph - and a Press Release (& yes, I have tried the RCGP website).
    One of the things missing from the 'Manifesto@ is the need for GP systems to support the business of general practice - but as the assumption seems to be that independent general practice won't exist for much longer, perhaps that isn't surprising!

  • New system will allow GP prison records to be transferred to other practices

    Mary Hawking's comment 18 Feb 2019 11:30am

    Wouldn't this require repeal of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act?
    I remember the problems of continuity of care - or just care - on admission to and discharge from custody being discussed frequently when I was in practice, and the same problems came up: the GP record is a cradle to grave record (& under the new GP contract the aim is to digitise everything - & upload all or part to LHCR, one of the aims being "research"..) which means that incorporating the prison medical record into the GP record would mean a *permanent & indelible* entry of any detention - including time on remand.
    Which is why it has not been done before.

  • Babylon patients waiting weeks for travel vaccines due to rising service demands

    Mary Hawking's comment 04 Feb 2019 11:28am

    I would have thought that a service targeting the young & mobile would have considered the likely demand for travel clinic services.
    It looks as though GPatHand patients may be 'forced' to re-register with their previous practices - or change their holiday plans/preparations!
    PS the practice profile most closely resembles that of University practices: how do they manage?

  • The health secretary’s vision for general practice

    Mary Hawking's comment 29 Jan 2019 11:32am

    Sorry, Christopher.
    "Smaller state" (USA model?) simply involves transferring functions best managed on a pooled risk basis (such as healthcare - where the normal developed economies model is universal compulsory insurance or tax funded) to an individual funded model with high transaction costs - and premiums related to claims.
    Socialism is *much* better - & who in their right mind now has any trust in the Conservative understanding or management of Business or the Economy?

  • Mr Hancock, there’s a simpler solution to this IT mess

    Mary Hawking's comment 02 Jan 2019 12:07pm

    remember GPASS?
    Single systems have their own problems

  • Pulse 2018 review: The growing attraction of early retirement

    Mary Hawking's comment 31 Dec 2018 10:25am

    I had had the impression that changes in the pension system - & LTA - was a contributory factor to taking the pension early - which no longer requires retirement from work - or even change in role.
    How do taking the NHS pension am
    and leaving the workforce (including locum or non-GP work) correlate?
    DOI - retired - late - 31.3.13 - so escaped the effects of HSCA 2012

  • Grappling with GP IT inefficiencies

    Mary Hawking's comment 23 Nov 2018 2:38pm

    Every practice does things differently: my advice would be to ask you trainer - and suggest the practice should have a "Coding/EPR handbook for Trainees" - to be updated when SNOMED is fully operational!

  • Leaked NHS memo warns pensions errors may affect 'large proportion of GPs'

    Mary Hawking's comment 19 Oct 2018 12:05pm

    re David O'Hagan comment.
    If PCSE are "only data processors" they ought to be acting under instructions from the "Data Controller" - and are only allowed to process the data in accordance with the instructions they have received.
    Was that in the contract signed by NHS England?
    And who is the Data Controller in this case?

  • Practices could receive incorrect QOF payments following IT update

    Mary Hawking's comment 26 Sep 2018 3:37pm

    If the problems started with a change in the Business Rules (Change? In September?That's *half way through the year*!!), why does it only apply to EMIS practices & not S1 practices? (What about Vision?)

    Has anyone checked whether this is a mapping problem? In the 4 to 5 byte conversion in 1994, my favourite mis-map was "Whole blood transfusion" converted to "lateral rhinostomy"..

    In the "Tired all the time" patients being listed as "depression", is this a Business Rule/extraction problem (easily correctable) or a Code Conversion problem (TATT actually mapped to "Depression")? If the later, this - in addition to corrupting the EPR - could have serious, long-term repercussions for the patients including job applications and insurance.

    I really hope the problem lies with the authors of the Business Rules!

  • Growth of Babylon app threatens 'financial balance' of CCG

    Mary Hawking's comment 21 Mar 2018 8:41am

    A 2 partner practice with 20,000 patients?
    Could Pulse find out how 2 GPs - and corresponding staff and premises - manage to provide adequate services to this number of patients?
    And how - & by whom - is the underlying technology funded/supplied?

  • Government must protect GPs against new data protection legislation, say LMCs

    Mary Hawking's comment 15 Mar 2018 9:47am

    The IGA - Information Governance Alliance - is issuing guidance for Health and Social Care.
    Unfortunately the General Practice/Primary Care Suite is now scheduled for March to May (previously March to April) - so it might appear to be a bit late to allow implementation by 25th May.

    Please note that Bedfordshire is 100% TPP SystmOne - which might have some influence on the suggestion that GPs shouldn't be the Data Controllers any longer.
    Connecting for Health decided that in a single shared record, GPs - and all other users - were Data Controllers in Common - with everything that that implied under DPA and will imply under GDPR.