This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

All for one ?

  • Prime Minister hopes to recruit 5,000 extra GPs 'as soon as possible'

    All for one ?'s comment 17 May 2019 8:58pm

    I welcome 5000 to deal with Capita and bills and pensions and former staff payments and complete madness, never mind networks and CQC and revalidation and complaints and burnout.
    Come in to my parlour.
    The sad part is all those aspiring GPs have no real clue as to the Tory penance initiated by Hunt that awaits them. Poor sods.

  • A tribute to the 9ers

    All for one ?'s comment 11 May 2019 10:47am

    Prof Stephenson said that doctors need resilience training because Medicine is like soldiers going to war in Afghanistan.
    But soldiers get tours and then rest and peace from war for some time and in times of peace for long periods. In GP land it is constant and unremitting. It is running flat out everyday. There is hardly time to rest because work spills into weekends in paperwork and reading.
    Should Medicine be like going to war ? And I don't want to go to war everyday.

  • Patients must be told safety is at risk due to GP workload

    All for one ?'s comment 08 May 2019 9:39pm

    Jaimie All of this is pointless. We GPs accept a list based Contract. Consultations have almost trebled in 20 years. So, effectively a 1700 list was 3400 in 2000, is 10000 now.
    If LMC/ BMA conferences keep voting to keep the status quo, we can hardly blame the DOH or anyone else.
    If, on the other hand, we vote to provide a service based on appointments, it will soon be clear there are not enough appointments or GPs.
    But, year on year we keep list sizes. If consultation per patient rise every year, it is hardly the fault of someone else.
    I do understand that the major newspapers think we get paid millions for playing golf, so that is unlikely to change.
    Perhaps it will take a complete collapse of medical care for the BMA to act.
    Though, having done hundreds of 80 hour sleepless weekends and weeks of 1:1 cover in the past, I am not holding my breath.
    When the RCGP chair states 12 hour days and 100 contacts as a problem, but no solutions, we are in difficulty.

  • The full story of how GP workload is jeopardising patient safety

    All for one ?'s comment 08 May 2019 11:14am

    This comment has been removed

  • GPs will be required to collect annual patient feedback under GMC plans

    All for one ?'s comment 01 May 2019 9:29pm


    Lewis Carroll [ Charles Dodgson ] was a mathematician and very unlikely to be involved in this Alice's adventures with the GMC

  • After 35 years in medicine, I’m having an endarkenment

    All for one ?'s comment 24 Apr 2019 11:29pm

    I have seen one in 45 years

  • We can do more to help doctors with depression

    All for one ?'s comment 21 Apr 2019 6:11am

    I fear it is not GPs [ again] who are uniquely placed as they are part of the system and depressed themselves.
    It is the Union, the BMA, that needs to define work safety and hours. It can prevent the sort of Dr Bawa Garba situation.

  • GP workload is a matter of life and death

    All for one ?'s comment 15 Apr 2019 11:15pm

    If we vote for list size rather than activity payments, then workload is entirely our problem.
    I cannot understand the mathematical logic when consultation/ contact rates have trebled in 15 years per patient.
    We are the authors of our own misfortune.

  • Analysis: Practices facing up to larger pensions bills

    All for one ?'s comment 15 Apr 2019 11:06pm

    And you want to be a partner. And this is what the GPC and RCGP are talking about as a turning point / light at the end of the tunnel.
    Turn back if you can and run away from the oncoming missile

  • Dr Bawa-Garba allowed to return to practice from July 2019

    All for one ?'s comment 11 Apr 2019 8:58pm

    The timeline of poor Jack Adcock shows he was getting much better under Dr BG's care.
    That is why he was transferred to a general ward by someone else.
    Who authorized the transfer and why is this person not in court to explain the decision?
    My contention would be that had Jack not been transferred from Dr BG's direct care, he would got have got his ACEI [ she had not written it up], and would not have suffered the catastrophic hypotension.
    He would have continued to improve and gone home.
    It was BECAUSE he left Dr BG's care that he died and not the other way around.

  • Bawa-Garba decision is a relief - but there are no winners

    All for one ?'s comment 10 Apr 2019 9:08pm

    In any case, my opinion is this case belongs to the realms of lunacy.
    Poor Jack was UNRESPONSIVE AT ADMISSION. pH near 7. in 2 hours, his pH was 7.24.

    He had IMPROVED and was so WELL AT 7 PM, he was transferred from CAU to a general ward.
    Yet, Dr BG is condemned as GNM for negligently disregarding decline and deterioration, when Jack actually IMPROVED remarkably UNDER HER CARE. He declined AFTER he left her care.
    How the expert witness can express this opinion is beyond my logic, irrespective of all other circumstances.
    In fact, I believe had Jack remained under Dr BG's care, he would not have got the ACEI, as she did not write it up and he would have got better and gone home.
    I believe it is because he was TRANSFERRED from her care that he died!!!

  • Bawa-Garba decision is a relief - but there are no winners

    All for one ?'s comment 10 Apr 2019 8:54pm

    How can a doctor be left to cover 3/4 other doctors ? How can a junior doctor be expected to cover for a senior doctor's absence ? How can they be expected to function in a normal manner in such abnormal circumstances ?
    For example, Dr BG was condemned for not looking at an XR earlier.
    But, she was not sitting on her hands watching TV. She was doing lumbar punctures and attending to multiple children in multiple sites she SHOULD NOT have been covering.
    It is a shame on the British system and justice that a doctor is expected to do the impossible and be in multiple places at the same time.
    The reward in the UK for covering 4 other doctors and doing 4 times your workload is not a Thank you, but Gross Negligence Manslaughter.
    Both the BMA and GMC should define safe working, but they do not.
    The GMC is quick to condemn. Why does it not define safe parameters of work?
    I blame the BMA for not looking after its workforce.
    Does the employer [ the Trust ] not have a duty of care to its employee, Dr BG ?
    What is going on in the UK ?

  • Bawa-Garba: a journey from hell to redemption

    All for one ?'s comment 10 Apr 2019 1:06pm

    Dr BG is not free. She is wrongly convicted of manslaughter. She was convicted for :
    This is the worst case of injustice I have come across. We cannot blame the mother. She asked the ward staff. But should she have not have known, should she not have been told that ACEI are not given in dehydration when it was started? My sympathies are with the family.
    BUT, it was not Dr BG's fault that she was covering 4 other doctors. And when/ why does a junior doctor carry the can because a Consultant deems it more important to give a lecture.
    In any case, he did not worry about the bloods, did he ?


    Yet, Dr BG is convicted for missing septic shock when the pathologist could not differentiate.
    This case is utterly horrible and a stain on British justice.

  • I saw the culture of sexism at the BMA first hand

    All for one ?'s comment 04 Apr 2019 12:06pm

    Vinci I enjoy your columns but you must have voice dictation.

  • Partnership is dead, long live partnerships

    All for one ?'s comment 04 Apr 2019 12:01pm

    By the way, this is the ' penance' imposed by Mr Hunt. You must remember he and his cronies in DM think we get paid for playing golf.
    So it is better to be paid per item. That way everyone knows what we get paid for doing everything we do.

  • Partnership is dead, long live partnerships

    All for one ?'s comment 04 Apr 2019 11:56am

    Shaba this has been brought up at BMA ARM a few times. Initially, my proposal did not make the agenda. When it did, it never got to debate. When it did get to debate it got voted down.

    So really, there is no point blaming the Govt., DOH etc.
    We can change the Contract. The fact that GPs are leaving is a sure sign the current Contract is rubbish.
    We are our own masters to a degree. So, if we accept a capitation fee for increasing workload that is our problem.
    The net result is that profit per patient has fallen 25% and take home pay today per consult is 50% of 2004.
    The DOH looks after public money and they are very happy at how foolish we are.
    Maybe this issue will make the ARM in Belfast this year and we will vote Yes.

  • Preventing suicide amongst GPs needs a system-wide change

    All for one ?'s comment 01 Apr 2019 9:59pm

    The NHS is a bully. It abuses its staff, especially doctors.
    Who looks after the doctors welfare. BMA.

    So over to you. Do they?

    Easy. Define safety in hours, contacts and consultations. Patient:Hospital beds:doctor ratios.
    Time to do it BMA. Otherwise this abuse will continue. Because Medicine is such a noble vocation in itself, there will be doctors in spite of the BMA, not because if the BMA.

  • 'General practice made Richie ill'

    All for one ?'s comment 23 Mar 2019 7:53am

    So sorry Lucy I was not making fun of you at all. Quite the contrary, I agree with what you say entirely.
    But, the wider public view us in the way portrayed by DM and Mr Hunt [ remember his penance statement?] as fat cats. That view is widespread because we do not define what we do and how much we do it for.
    If we doctors cannot/ will not define safe working there is no chance the NHS will.
    I agree with you. What I would like is a definition of safety such that doctors like Richie never ever feel overwhelmed.
    Prof Stephenson said we need resilience like soldiers in Afghanistan.
    Surely, the practice of Medicine and General practice should not be war.
    So, who should define safe working such that this tragedy of Richie is not constantly repeated ?

  • GP numbers will fall 7,000 short within five years despite increasing trainees

    All for one ?'s comment 21 Mar 2019 11:58am

    This is Hunt's stated penance. He wanted 5000 more to undergo his penance. I am glad there is 7000 less for his belief that we earn half a million for frequenting undulating fairways.
    An unlimited Contract that abuses its Contractors deserves to fail.It is natural justice that unremitting and undeserved penance finally gets rid of those sinners deserving of penance. At least, the DM would have achieved its goal of getting rid of all those lazy GPs.

  • 'General practice made Richie ill'

    All for one ?'s comment 21 Mar 2019 0:03am

    Lucy, you are seen as earning 500000 for playing golf.
    So, if we are truly Independent Contractors WE [ the GPC, RCGP ] need to define safe working. No point blaming the NHS.
    Unless we define workloads, what we do and what we get paid for,[ currently take home pay of 3 pounds per consultation] we will always been seen as whingeing.
    Let us for clarity for both sides define what we do. This unremitting, undefined and limitless Contract leaves us wide open to complaint of not doing 'enough' even if we are working 14 hour days.
    My issue is this, the fault is in ourselves that we are underlings.
    But LMCs / BMA conferences without number have declined to define workloads. I know I have been there.