This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Deborah White

  • How to use FIT in general practice

    Deborah White's comment 11 Jun 2019 3:39pm

    Helpful article. Explaining the difference between a screening and a symptomatic FIT is going to be a communication challenge; I have lost count of the number of patients who have answered "how are your bowels?" with "they're fine because I have just done that screening sample test and it was ok".

    I think the introductory vignette neatly illustrates the difference between primary care and secondary care doctors: presented with a patient with a relatively short history of loose stool very clearly associated with the initiation of metformin, I don't think I would immediately reach for any tests at all. If there were no red flags in the history, I would suggest reducing the dose and reviewing in about a month, with a view to slower titration - or investigation if symptoms continued / worsened / new features developed. Which is why GPs are relatively cost effective!

  • We need to change how we self-manage asthma and COPD

    Deborah White's comment 24 Apr 2019 11:04pm

    I feel like I must be missing something as this sounds rather like reinventing the wheel to me. I'm not saying this always happens, but asthma and COPD patients should already have this treatment to hand and know how to use it. Adding further prescriptions sounds like adding further confusion to me - "When do I use the "emergency pack" and when do I use my "normal" blue inhaler, doctor?" And I can just see some patients saying the "emergency pack" works better because it is packaged as "special"! Further, surely this pack would incur 2 prescription charges; I can't see many people who pay shelling out if they already have other equivalent prescriptions.

  • GPs being funded to target 'frequent attenders' in bid to reduce workload

    Deborah White's comment 24 Apr 2019 10:55pm

    This article leaves me wanting to know more - what did they do, what did they say to patients, what other services were provided, in the apparently amazing pilot in Bury? But I am mostly cynical - the issues behind this "problem" are often really not for general practice, or even the NHS, to solve - education, housing, social care, employment... It shouldn't be for us to be "training" to deal with all these complex background issues.

  • Health secretary given right to suspend GPs' pensions before conviction

    Deborah White's comment 17 Apr 2019 2:31pm

    It sounds like this will apply to all NHS Pension Scheme members but Pulse have headlined it to be about GPs rather than all doctors / NHS staff to get our attention.

    But this doesn't change my view that this is disgraceful - another potential "innocence tax". At least you might get Legal Aid if you had no pension income... although one might envisage the twisted system denying you Legal Aid because your income is too great, then subsequently withdrawing this income...

  • BMA reviewing policies after officials claimed expenses for trips with spouses

    Deborah White's comment 28 Mar 2019 10:34am

    To say that the “BMA previously had no formal policy on expenses” just isn’t true. There may well not be a formal policy on expenses for spouses, but I have had various involvements with the BMA over 15 years, and have always claimed expenses in line with clear organisation policy. I also recollect that there is wording in the expenses guidance for the Annual Representative Meeting that says that attendees cannot claim hotel double occupancy expenses for a partner who is not a member of the Representative Body.

    I’m not saying not to call out the BMA if questionable things have been going on, Pulse, but the quote I use above overblows the situation and weakens the criticism.

  • Capita forced to give GPs extra time to submit pension forms after website errors

    Deborah White's comment 28 Feb 2019 1:37pm

    Pension problems taking up inordinate amounts of GP time due to Capita incompetence are not really news these days... even when their website says that they have had some technical issues but these have not affected pension forms, they are emailing me saying that they have not received my... pension forms.

  • Why I’m not confident about the state indemnity scheme

    Deborah White's comment 23 Jan 2019 9:13pm

    I have been saying for months that I am less than positive about this; it seems obvious that funding it properly would cost too much for our paymasters. I am pretty stunned at all the GPs who have ridden off on the unicorn offered by the MDU.

  • The next time your heart sinks, remember those heartlifters

    Deborah White's comment 16 Jan 2019 12:04pm

    Such a good point - we don’t think about the heartlifters enough. My only criticism of this piece would be that it spent 3/4 of its length describing causes of heartsink, which I am sure many GPs will identify with to the point of rising irritation on reading... More of a counterbalance of stories of heartlift would have been balm for the worn GP.

    So, here are some types of patients who cheer me:
    The 7 year old who delights in a sticker for being a good boy and high fives you on the way out.
    The older lady who thanks you and says she came to see you as her “granddaughter said you were lovely, and she was right!”
    The person who doesn’t just not mind your late running, but says you are worth waiting for.
    And those with whom you have genuine top banter.

    I look forward to my heart being lifted at work tomorrow!

  • Time to make the term ‘noctors’ a relic of the past

    Deborah White's comment 18 Dec 2018 12:50pm

    I think "noctor" is definitely a conceptualisation rather than a way of referring to a colleague! Not a word I would use, but describes an idea I do think - perfectly described by the comment in the piece about "... practices utilising ANPs as a kind of cut-price salaried GP, seeing unfiltered patients without appropriate supervision."

    I work as a locum, so almost by definition in practices that are struggling a bit to a lot, and I regularly see nurse practitioners working in ways that leave me feeling that I would be terrified if I were the GP nominally supervising them. My experience is of nurse practitioners who look to be under pressure to cope beyond what is appropriate for them, with over-investigating and over-prescribing common. Patients end up seeing me after 3-4 appointments with the nurse practitioner, when, unsurprisingly to me, the prescription hasn't worked, and the panoply of tests, that I wouldn't have requested, are slightly squiffy. I then have to start again, which doesn't seem great use of resources.

    Don't get me wrong, in a well supported and well staffed practice, nurse practitioners seem to find their niche, and really add to the service - but this is too often not the case, and this isn't fair on them or patients, or good use of precious NHS resources.

  • New EMIS system will listen to and ‘interpret’ GP-patient conversations

    Deborah White's comment 03 Dec 2018 10:49am

    Quite aside from the need to make the "basics" work properly first, and the effect on how doctors communicate - what about the effect on how patients communicate? How would this system be explained to them? I can't begin to imagine how some patients might try to manipulate this - and equally how some patients might withhold information as they perceived "big brother" was listening. Lots of things to consider before any implementation methinks.

  • Take part in Pulse's survey of GPs to win £300 John Lewis vouchers

    Deborah White's comment 08 Nov 2018 3:09pm

    Looks like there have been a few slip-ups with setting this up; I indicated I was a locum, but still got a lot of questions about "your practice" that I had to click "don't know" to. At the end there is a question about reading Pulse in print, and even if you say you don't read in print, you have to say where you get your print copy in the next question. Further, as a locum, I indicated the CCG I am currently mostly working in, but this is not the CCG I was working in at the time of the winter pressures last year.

  • Your eight-step guide to finances as a locum

    Deborah White's comment 12 Oct 2018 8:00pm

    Northwestdoc - it's all in your T&C; mine explicitly state that the employer contribution isn't included.

    There are some useful things to think about if you are new to locum work in this article, but some of what is presented as firm advice is actually opinion e.g. "Payment terms are usually 30 days." Says who? Mine aren't!

    It is also highly questionable to suggest discussing locum fees on social media, as this might be considered to be forming a cartel. I'm surprised Pulse has published this advice.

  • Practice to cut staff after 'unexplained' reclaimed payments by Capita

    Deborah White's comment 24 Sep 2018 10:49am

    The recent “technical fault” DID affect pensions; I have had to resubmit locum pension forms. They even get it wrong about what they have got wrong!

  • Succeeding as a locum GP

    Deborah White's comment 11 Sep 2018 0:23am

    I am pretty sure the GMC would say that prospective employers should be checking the online register for the current registration status of a doctor, not certificates that were issued years ago. I frequently point this out to practice managers, and it would have been nice if this article had been helpful in this regard. Further, I have never been asked for proof I am able to work in the UK, or about my imms.

  • NHS-run GP practices 'outbid' independent contractors on locum fees

    Deborah White's comment 22 Mar 2018 9:16pm

    This comment has been removed by the moderator

  • GP partners asked to sign off locum referrals to reduce pressure on hospitals

    Deborah White's comment 28 Feb 2018 10:39am

    As a locum, I find this rather insulting. I have rather more experience as a doctor than some of the partners I work for, and I wouldn’t want to be in their shoes when they block one of my referrals without seeing the patient, and harm or perceived harm comes to the patient. This sort of scheme is money for work that has already been done. If I don’t know the local referral pathway, I ask a partner or secretary. Although only the other day, it seemed that I was the only one in the practice who knew the local pathway, from my work in other practices... after a considerable amount of searching and phone calls, the referral form I knew was needed was eventually produced!

  • Notes on a sandal: summer attire for the busy GP

    Deborah White's comment 27 Jun 2017 6:41pm

    No no no! I love shopping, and a new work outfit does cheer me up... until I call the first patient, anyway!

  • MDO warns GPs about spinal nerve condition after paying claims worth £12.5m

    Deborah White's comment 21 Mar 2017 2:13pm

    Dear Pulse
    Your lack of ability to spell the name of this condition does not give confidence in anything you might have to say about it. And any GP who needs it defining should not be working as a GP.

  • How do we solve the problem of locum GPs?

    Deborah White's comment 22 Feb 2017 11:54am

    "Ultimately of course the real problem is not locums but a political policy that has created the situation of massive underfunding of the NHS destroying morale." Quite. What a fantastically unhelpful title. I would have liked to have seen the evidence for "spiralling rates" of locum pay presented, too.