FORUM

« Back to

A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition

Combination View Flat View Tree View
Threads [ Previous | Next ]
toggle
A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Nigel Praities 17/11/11 14:16
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Shoukat Khan 16/11/11 12:19
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Derrin Wilkins 16/11/11 12:27
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Simon Cats 22/11/11 21:18
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition MOKSHAD Kansagra 06/12/11 11:24
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Raymond Alexander Ringland 16/11/11 13:04
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Mark Bonnes 16/11/11 19:53
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Esmat Bhimani 16/11/11 21:44
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Doddasadenahalli Mahadevaiah 16/11/11 21:53
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Lucy Marchand 16/11/11 22:00
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Hana Harvey 17/11/11 08:28
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Anonymous 17/11/11 08:52
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Vinci Ho 17/11/11 10:41
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Pamela Barcella 17/11/11 14:11
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Michele Cameron 17/11/11 14:46
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Malcolm Freeth 17/11/11 22:38
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Julian Hall 18/11/11 15:22
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Elizabeth Foster 18/11/11 15:25
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Gurmeet Singh 21/11/11 16:33
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition SHIRLEY GUMERY 21/11/11 20:43
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Veronica Pearson 22/11/11 11:33
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition David Windsor-Martin 22/11/11 12:34
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Fiona Clough 22/11/11 21:11
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Abdul Naem 23/11/11 08:39
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Paul Attwood 23/11/11 16:55
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Michael Blackmore 24/11/11 12:36
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Noel Pereira 27/11/11 14:01
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Adrian Vreede 30/11/11 12:18
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Oruj Alam 01/12/11 22:33
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Anonymous 05/12/11 18:25
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Subra Manian 05/12/11 18:39
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Frances Cryan 13/12/11 12:37
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Steven Martin 14/12/11 10:48
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Anonymous 14/12/11 12:24
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Paul Collins 07/01/12 10:55
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition Sandra Kemplen 18/01/12 14:05


We, the undersigned, demand that the following measures are put in place to ensure GPs have their right to refer restored:

1. Every referral management centre must be put to a ballot of GP practices at the clinical commissioning group, and should only continue if it has a mandate to do so.

2. The Department of Health or NHS Commissioning Board should make funding available for GP peer review of referrals, as a cost-effective, evidence-based alternative to referral management centres.

3. The secretary of state must provide a written guarantee that GPs have the ultimate right to refer a patient whenever they believe it is unequivocally in that patient¹s best interests.

4. The DH must launch an investigation into the serious incidents and patient complaints that have arisen at some referral management centres.

Click here for more information on our campaign.

CLICK 'REPLY' ABOVE AND ADD YOUR NAME AND LOCATION TO SHOW YOUR SUPPORT
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
16/11/11 12:19as a reply to Nigel Praities.
refferal right should not be scrapped
Dr S A khan
Birmingham
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
16/11/11 12:27as a reply to Shoukat Khan.
Dr D Wilkins, Eastleigh
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
referrals
Answer
16/11/11 13:04as a reply to Nigel Praities.
I think it will be proved to be best that the GP decides who is the best person for the patient to see.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
16/11/11 19:53as a reply to Nigel Praities.
We are moving into dangerous territory if we are limiting referrals based on volume/cost alone
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
16/11/11 21:44as a reply to Nigel Praities.
As a GP, I have a right to refer when appropriate and according to my medical judgment.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
16/11/11 21:53as a reply to Nigel Praities.
cost and case load should not be a criteria for obstructing referrals. It is a shame that NHS care is getting diluted more and more at the cost of the very own patients' care for which it was mooted. It seems that it has become a toy to play with by some managers sitting at the top to show that 'yes we are doing a lot of things to change the face of NHS' to keep their jobs secure.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
16/11/11 22:00as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Dr Lucy Marchand Milton Keynes
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
17/11/11 08:28as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Trying to limit referrals is neither in patient nor doctors interests. Close liaison with secondary care colleagues is vital and the various gateways and limitations interfere with this. In addition it should not be assumed that commissioning groups represent all GPs. On such matters each GP should be given an individual vote.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
17/11/11 08:52as a reply to Nigel Praities.
referrall centres should be banned. they are detrimental to patient care
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
17/11/11 10:41as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Of course , I support freedom to refer , aren't we supposed to be in a democratic society?
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
17/11/11 14:11as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Dr Pamela Barcella--Suffolk
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
17/11/11 14:46as a reply to Nigel Praities.
The right to refer is a sine qua non for GPs and as far as I am aware is a legal obligation when necessary in the opinion of the doctor.
I am completely flummoxed in trying to understand where this will go if the right to refer is removed.
It can never be safe to put the judgement of whether a patient needs to be seen in secondary care in the hands of anyone other than the doctor who is looking after the patient and who has taken a history and examined the said patient. To put any obstacle in the way of that is terrifyingly dangerous.
If this goes ahead, I hope that the government can afford the damages and legal fees which will inevitably follow.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
17/11/11 22:38as a reply to Nigel Praities.
It has to be a sine qua non that the person who has taken the appropriate history, completed the appropriate examination, and come to the decision that the patient needs to see a specialist is the person to refer the patient. Thus the right to refer must be accredited to the GP. If it is clinically necessary and no referral takes place - because a management centre has concluded that there should be no referral - then there is a clear case for legal action should there occur 'damage' to the patient.

Malcolm Freeth
Bournemouth
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
18/11/11 15:22as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Referral managment is just one symptom of Lansley's diseased plans for NHS reform. NHS reform is focussed on saving money, not healthcare need. Traditionally, doctors have been trained to deliver care focussed completely on the clinical need for any one given patient. Now we are being told the focus of our attention is no longer the welfare for our patient, but keeping within our local NHS budget. Failure to do this brands us as a "bad practice", that could ultimatly be forced to close, only to be replaced by a corporate private haelthcare provider. This is the prognosis for the disease called "Lansley Syndrome". Lansley is the "cancer" eroding the core values of the NHS.
The "Right to Refer" can only be treated by eliminating the underlying cause of this disease,
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
18/11/11 15:25as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Elizabeth Foster, Salaried GP, Oldham
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
sign our petition
Answer
21/11/11 16:33as a reply to Nigel Praities.
If my right to refer is taken away I will be encouraging patients to take legal action against the Health Secretary - what a bunch of nincompoops!
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
21/11/11 20:43as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Referring patients is a basic right and privilege of any GP. It came when they gave us the right to practice as GP's. If this basic right is taken away from us, what is the use of becoming a GP in the first place when all the years of training is put aside because a group of people found it "cost effective" to have this Referral management centre. This is just one way of putting down GP's again, disrespecting us! It seems a lot of people who makes these decisions " know" so much about "GP work" and think they could do better. Improvement is always good, I am all for that!. But the problem is with all these cost-cutting moves,we a re not improving healthcare. in fact , patient care suffers , healthcare is thrown into the deeper end. Eventually who will absorb all the negative impact of these changes! guess who? the lowly, overworked GP again!! and more dissatisfied patients!!
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
22/11/11 11:33as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Dr V Pearson, Yorkshire
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
22/11/11 12:34as a reply to Nigel Praities.
David Windsor-Martin
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
22/11/11 21:18as a reply to Shoukat Khan.
I fully agree that General Practitioners need autonomy in referring their patients. Any interference will undermine the trust relationship between the doctor and his patient and cause unnecessary and potentially dangerous delays as well as risking the referral to become inappropriate.

Dr Simon Cats.
London
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
23/11/11 08:39as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Dr Abdul Naem
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
23/11/11 16:55as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Let me do my job and refer in my patient's interests. If you block it give your name and designation with GMC or NMC number. If my patient comes to harm then we both know what will happen. :-)

Dr Paul Attwood
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
24/11/11 12:36as a reply to Nigel Praities.
I hope you are successful. We cannot accept these restrictions.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
27/11/11 14:01as a reply to Michael Blackmore.
:We need to state that problems following on from blocking of referrals are the responsibility of the blocking organisation.
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
30/11/11 12:18as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Adrian Vreede
Practice Director
Staffordshire
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
01/12/11 22:33as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Dr O Alam
Birmingham
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
05/12/11 18:25as a reply to Nigel Praities.
It is imperative that GPs have the right to refer patients to appropriate specialists without being screened by unqualified staff or provided with a 'maximum quota' by non-qualified hospital managers
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
05/12/11 18:39as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Subbu Manian
Newcastle-u-Lyme
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
06/12/11 11:24as a reply to Shoukat Khan.
Dr Kansagra
Milton Keynes
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
13/12/11 12:37as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Frances Cryan Locum GP Derbyshire
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
14/12/11 10:48as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Steven Martin, Coventry and Warwickshire
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
14/12/11 12:24as a reply to Nigel Praities.
We are gatekeepers We must be allowed to refer based on clinical need not economics
RE: A RIGHT TO REFER: Sign our petition
Answer
18/01/12 14:05as a reply to Nigel Praities.
Dr S Nehring, Sheffield.