This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

GP NI contract reforms could keep 100% triage and Covid centres

Exclusive The system of telephone triaging all patients, and the referral of patients to community assessment centres, may be included in the Northern Irish GP contract in the future, with the BMA and RCGP currently being consulted on plans.

The NI Government officially launched its strategy for rebuilding health services following the Covid-19 pandemic this week, including plans for telephone triage and video consultations to become 'embedded' in general practice.

But some GPs critical of the plans accused the NI Government of 'capitalising on the Covid-19 crisis' to force GMS contract changes.

The NI Goverment strategy document said: 'All patients are now subject to telephone triage for around five minutes. Whilst exact figures are not available, it is clear that this triage addresses issues for a significant number of patients, thereby reducing numbers needing a more detailed consultation.

'This consequently reduced pressures on GP surgeries. The outcome has delivered a transformational impact and there are therefore clear benefits to continuing this operating model.'

Launching the strategy, health minister Robin Swann said despite the challenges posed by the pandemic, its innovative and committed response had led to opportunities to make improvements to the NI health system which ‘was in very serious difficulties long before coronavirus reached these shores’.

He said: 'We must build on that spirit in the months and years ahead. Innovations like telephone triage and video consultations will be embedded in primary and secondary care.’

The NI Government said it will also said be building on the model of 'Covid centres' when reconfiguring Health and Social Care Northern Ireland (HSCNI) for the future.

Across Northern Ireland, 11 Covid Centres have been established, while GP practices dealt with 23,441 Covid-related queries between 9 April and 6 May.

Of the 3,702 patients who were triaged and referred to a Covid centre, 75% were provided with advice on self-management; 15% were referred to secondary care; and 10% were referred to other services. 

The strategy document said: 'Given the clear benefits of the approach, consideration will need to be given to what can be learned from the model and what elements ought to be retained to support longer term transformation of the HSC.'

'The primary care sector will now consider the continued and expanded use of telephone and video technology in delivery of GP services. The sector will also consider ways to integrate more effectively with other sectors,' it concluded.

However, some GPs have criticised the Covid centres for being costly and under-utilised.

BMA Northern Ireland's GP Committee and RCGP Northern Ireland are now being consulted on plans for changing services for the longer term, according to a NI Health and Social Care Board document leaked to Pulse.

The paper says it is a draft that will be amended following 'discussion with regional Covid centre leads and the leaders of GPC and RCGP'.

It suggests that Northern Ireland could 're-focus the GP contract and enable enhanced federation services', with pandemic changes becoming 'part of the normal operation of services in NI'.

Crucially, it suggests this should include 'rapid access assessment and treatment services' covering 'a range of clinical areas', which should 'operate 9am-6pm seven days a week'.

Other changes suggested include reviewing the 'form, function and role of [out-of-hours] unscheduled care'; and 'new models of GP support for patients in care homes including single practice models for homes with appropriate digital support'.

However, some GPs have expressed their concerns with the plans.

A rural GP who wished to remain anonymous told Pulse: ‘GPs in Northern Ireland, who have been very concerned by coerced working in Covid centres, are now very alarmed by the prospect of Covid centres continuing for the foreseeable future, merging into acute assessment centres, that our GMS contracts could be permanently changed.

‘Federations are meant to represent GPs and instead are Trojan horses for the Department of Health to enforce change. This paper is the result of discussions with the leaders of GPC and our union, which is meant to safeguard our employment rights, not be colluding in the derogation of those rights which this paper proposes.’

Another anonymous GP, from the South East of the country, said: ‘Several of my colleagues have told me of their increasingly firm plans to walk away from general practice if this is how we are going to be dealt with by the health authorities. If the seven-day service was pushed through, I imagine most partners would resign immediately to regain control of their work.

‘We fear this may represent the final nail in the coffin of general practice. We have reason to fear that the BMA and RCGPNI are planning complicity with this undemocratic unilateral destruction of GMS.’

BMA GP Committee chair Dr Alan Stout told Pulse: 'There are no definite contractual proposals or discussions yet. We have an agreement that our contract freeze will last for the foreseeable future and likely the rest of this year.

‘There will clearly be an opportunity to review all of the contractual arrangements including QOF and enhanced services as the year progresses and relating to priorities.’

Meanwhile, RCGPNI told Pulse that the Covid centres had 'worked extremely well with only a small percentage of patients seen at the Covid assessment centres moved on towards secondary care, therefore easing pressures on our health service at a time of crisis'.

But the spokesperson added: 'As the numbers presenting in the centres decreases it isn’t sustainable or right to maintain high levels of staffing and associated resources, so we do anticipate some changes to their current arrangement. Any alterations to the GMS contract and negotiations around any possible GP contract changes rests with NIGPC/BMA NI and not RCGPNI.'

Readers' comments (29)

  • There has been zero consultation from GP leaders in NI regarding any of the events of the past few months. Imposition of OOH working in these white elephant covid centres, continuing to have 7 GPs sat drinking coffee while the public hammers their colleagues left behind in practice with trivia.

    The federations who are supposed to represent us have gone off and done their own thing.

    I am in my late 30's with a mortgage etc and have real fears about what the future holds for GP.

    The goodwill of the punters has long gone- they want things sorting now pandemic or no.

    Meanwhile this airy fairy crap gets floated out from Stormont which has spent the last few years doing squat but now decide its time to tinker.

    The GP leaders have been found wanting- they clearly do not have the interests of GPs at the forefront of their minds

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Such a shame that those in “power” would capitalise on the good will of GPs during a pandemic and change contracts..... Primary Care is one of the stable pillars of the NHS and now they want to destroy it.... shame shame shame

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Yes sounds like a serious 'power grab' happening in NI by those GPs with vested interests - the main drivers usually are money, power and the desire to be paid not to see patients, but to be paid lots of money to sit around in lots of board meetings..

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Welcome to all salaried service guys!
    My mother lives in NI and hates telephone triage , as you would expect with any 85 year old.
    Just a long list of half truths to try and justify stripping you of independent contractor status, even though all the research says that is by far the best way of providing GP services

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am really concerned that general practice in Northern Ireland will be sacrificed for political capital and personal glory:
    In an ocean of nhs chaos in Northern Ireland, general practice has remained the only chink of light, now with central meddling we are to be nationalized, micro managed and destroyed!
    Obituary for (NI) gp

    RIP gp NI 11/6/20
    Put up a good fight but ultimately destroyed by those who should have known better
    Gone, but not forgotten

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Those behind the death of Primary Care in NI need names, shamed and REMOVED from their positions before any further destruction

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • All the GPs should walk away. You must stay united

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The direction of travel is clear. Remaining partners will employ increasing number of salaried doctors, while they increase managerial roles and see less patients them selves.
    It would be cheaper for the Government to move to salaried model and scrap the partnership model altogether.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • this is bollocks - time wasted talking to patients on the phone, who you can't assess properly. then more time spent when they come and see you anyway - often several days later, by which time any pathology they might have has had a chance to cook !

    recipe for things to go wrong.

    wait for the writs to start flying, though this will probably take a while.

    if you "perceive yourself to be ill" by all means come and see me - then we can have a discussion. if you don't come to see me, i think it's fair to assume you are well (obviously, follow up appointments excepted).

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @theclap..... do you work in Northern Ireland too?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say