This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pulse june2020 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

GPs go forth

GP trainees to complete training with recorded assessment replacing CSA

GP trainees are going to be able to complete their training via a 'recorded assessment' that will temporarily replace the CSA exam.

The news was announced today in a joint statement from Health Education England and the health education bodies in the devolved nations, alongside the RCGP, BMA and GMC.

The statement also said AKT exams would resume at test centres 'with appropriate social distancing safeguards in place' from July.

It comes after CSA and AKT exams were cancelled in March due to the Covid-19 pandemic.

The statement said: ‘We have agreed that an alternative temporary assessment, to meet the standards of the CSA component of the MRCGP should be developed to enable you to have the opportunity to gain the full MRCGP in the time available.

‘The CSA exam will not be run during this timeframe. A "recorded assessment" is to be developed which will enable you to submit video or audio recordings of consultations, recognising that many consultations are now remote.

‘RCGP and GP training educator colleagues are rapidly working on details of this assessment, building on experience with the former MRCGP video assessment, to enable submission of this temporary solution to the GMC for consideration of approval.'

The signatory bodies said they 'believe that this temporary alternative to the CSA will enable trainees to have the opportunity to demonstrate their competence' but added that it 'will be required to be at the same standard as covered by the CSA in order to gain MRCGP and thereby the Certificate of Completion of Training (CCT)'.

Commenting on why it reached this conclusion, the bodies said it came as 'some of the solutions that have been advocated such as waiving some of the MRCGP requirements or temporary certification are not legally permissible' while some other 'possible examination solutions are not deliverable in the required time frame'.

Meanwhile, regarding the AKT, the statement said: 'The RCGP is working with Pearson Vue to enable the Applied Knowledge Test (AKT) to resume at their test centres with appropriate social distancing safeguards in place from July. We have agreed that priority should be given to ST3 candidates. The College is also investigating options for remote invigilation for those that are shielding.'

It said the 'deliverable solution' has been worked up in cooperation between the four statutory health education bodies, the RCGP, BMA, NHS England and Department of Health and Social Care, as well as trainee representatives.

And concluded: 'We recognise that no solution will please everybody but believe these changes are deliverable and will help as many colleagues as possible to complete their training on time.'

Dr Anthony James, chair of the RCGP's AiT community, told Pulse: ‘GP trainees have been understandably frustrated since the cancellation of exams back in March - the end of training is a huge milestone, with many having accepted jobs and planned moves around this important transition point.

‘Handling additional uncertainty during already difficult times has been extremely tough for many, so I hope that today’s announcement will be helpful for all those trainees affected. As an elected representative, it's been hugely inspiring to see trainees come together on this issue, supporting myself and other reps to ensure that their views are heard. 

‘In our recent survey, trainees indicated that they wanted options to enable them to progress and these will now be made available. There is a lot of work still to do to provide this new assessment, but I have been thoroughly impressed by the hard work of those at the RCGP, Statutory Education Bodies and GMC to deliver this.’ 

This comes a week after a group of trainers wrote to the RCGP to propose an alternative to MRCGP exams process, whilst the British Association of Physicians of Indian Origin (BAPIO) also called on the College to implement temporary measures for the affected trainees.

Readers' comments (19)

  • Makes you wonder if they will face further calls to scrap the CSA if this works out (and seems to be modern equivalent of the old video submission model).

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • You mean like the olden days? Blimey, whatever next? A one side of A4 appraisal? A pension worth paying into? Partnership vacancies being oversubscribed?

    Those were the days.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Una Coales. Retired NHS GP.

    Hope this temporary replacement of the MRCGP CSA exam with a video or audio recording submission becomes a permanent change for the sake of British BAMEs and IMGs. Much preferred the old video submission model, as it allowed GP registrars to show real patient consultations instead of pretend with CSA actors.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • will scrap CSA? I don’t think so, it a great money spinner for RCGP.
    There is around 3500 gp training posts in UK.
    Present CSA fee: £1352
    I’ll let you crunch the figures, ps don’t forget resits

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • As Grinding Premolars says "like the olden days"

    Not quite as far back as Spanish Flu may be Swine Flu??

    Could add no CQC and allowed to practice medicine without massive interference/dictats from micro-managers!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Funny times. "To gain the full MRCGP". Then why once you rightly gained it, does the RCGP send insulting threatening letters out saying 'you can't use your MRCGP' letters, if you don't pay them money annually. Do they want the MBBS back too? Just another arbitrary group, scandalous scam.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Simples. The RCGP want your money!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Did anyone fail the submission type assessments in the past?

    I worry it would be perceived as an easier alternative than an exam.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • They might even train the poor devils to do the job that needs doing not some ivory tower fantasy version of it. Also, has anyone realised that since medical students and juniors have started spending more time in primary care, recruitment has actually gone down?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say