This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

Gold, incentives and meh

LMC agrees fee with CCG to pay practices £90 per hour for safeguarding reports

Exclusive GP leaders in South-East England have negotiated a fee for GPs to invoice CCGs for compiling safeguarding reports, according to the local LMC.

Essex LMC has been in negotiations for practices in Essex, Suffolk and Hertfordshire to invoice CCGs to fill out safeguarding reports.

Chief executive of Essex LMC Dr Brian Balmer said the LMC has agreed the fee with one unnamed CCG already - of £90 per hour - and is in discussions with six others CCGs in the area.

Safeguarding reports are a contractual requirement, but GPs have pointed out that this is a time-intensive piece of work.

In July, Dr David Geddes, NHS England primary care commissioning director, wrote a letter to STP leads asking to review their support of general practice undertaking such work.

He said practices have sought payment for the reports but as the number of requests for safeguarding reports increase, there is a ‘need to review how general practice is supported’.

Dr Geddes suggested examples to improve safeguard reporting and the quality of reports, such as direct payments to a practice by CCGs under long-standing ‘collaborative arrangements’ and introducing a safeguarding local enhanced service.

The new arrangements in Essex are thought to be first example of practices being paid for safeguarding reports.

Dr Balmer said: ‘Practices are free to set their own rates but what we’ve done is said: “We and the CCG think £90 is a sensible rate.” ’

He added that the LMC has sought legal advice, and practices can charge an hourly rate because the patient is not being charged a fee and carrying out safeguarding reports is a statutory duty.

He added: ‘We’ve told practices to continue to do the work promptly and efficiently but record your hours.'

Dr Balmer continued: ‘I am hoping that another five will commit next week....For one of our CCGs to say yes, and quickly, is a bit of a bonus for us.’

The LMC's lawyers said: ‘The CCG - having regard for the Dr Geddes letter of July 2019, and in the spirit of the new statutory guidance “Working together to Safeguard Children…” - updated February 2019, will reimburse practices/GPs the reasonable costs involved in sharing information or report writing where this is provided by the GP as part of their statutory safeguarding duty.

‘Practices are advised to invoice the CCG specifying the time involved in completing each report and the hourly rate set by the practice for this task. Practices may set their own rate and no patient can be charged for this work.

‘Practices should be aware that the CCG and LMC have agreed that a rate of £90/hour would be seen as reasonable.

'The LMC cannot normally recommend a rate for non-GMS work because of competition law, but as patients will not be charged and in this circumstance, there is no market or competitive environment, our legal advice supports this advice for safeguarding reports.’

Earlier this summer, the BMA negotiated safeguarding reports to be covered under the state-backed indemnity scheme.

Readers' comments (9)

  • £90 is a derisory rate

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Cobblers

    When I left practice in 2016 my rates were £70 per 15 minutes or part thereof IN ADVANCE.

    Whilst agreement to pay for GPs time is to be welcomed I agree that £90 is under the market rate. Try getting your solicitor or for that matter the garage mechanic to work for £90 an hour.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • GP is a vocation.

    Shocking that GPs should want to be paid for the privilege of doing such valuable work, when it presents the opportunity to intervene and alter for the better the lifepath of our most vulnerable patients.

    In fact, why don we just do EVERYTHING for free ?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This should probably be more but this is a good precedent to have set for us

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Let’s hear how much the legal advice cost per hour, then we can decide whether £90 looks right.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • it's still a loss to the practice, when you factor in staff time, overheads and expenses.
    Going rate for GP work is over £240 per hour.
    But expert GP opinion equates to Barrister rates, which is about £ 1200 per hour!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Currently getting nothing, so quit wingeing.
    This is a duty which needs to be done and done well.
    And now we will enter into a bidding war - they get £90, you are offering this or that or the other. I want that and I want more.
    One of the reasons GP is in such a mess is that GP's are always shouting about £££'s if you wanted to be rich become a barrister and get your £1200/hr
    It is the NHS, N for national, the problem now is that it has become a LHS, L for local - divide and rule wins every time, now we will be seen a squabbling, once again about £'s

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • KTMrider @5:12
    you presumably get paid your salary while you are completing safeguarding reports whether your employing practice is remunerated for the work or not? It's not about getting rich, it's making sure there is enough money coming into keep the lights on

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Who's paying £240 an hour to GPs? Private patients?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say