This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

MPs call for expert review into medico-legal repercussions of pandemic

A group of MPs, led by Dr Philippa Whitford, has called for the Government to appoint an expert committee to set out clear medico-legal guidance relating to the Covid-19 pandemic.

Dr Whitford, SNP's shadow health spokesperson and a former doctor, is working alongside medical defence organisation MDDUS on the campaign, which she is bringing to health secretary Matt Hancock via a letter today.

Their bid comes amid fears doctors may be faced with unfair trials and regulatory proceedings resulting from the added pressures of practising in the pandemic.

Dr Whitford said independent guidance is needed on:

  • The claims, complaints and regulatory issues likely to be raised by COVID-19, both directly and indirectly
  • How these can be tackled fairly, taking into account the exceptional circumstances clinical professionals have been working in, and
  • What changes to normal processes may be necessary to minimise the stress and uncertainty on clinicians of investigations into decisions they made during Covid-19

She said: 'At the moment everyone is aware of the stress and challenge faced by NHS staff, but that memory will fade.

'It is important that the exceptional circumstances of dealing with the Covid-19 pandemic are not forgotten when using hindsight to judge medical decisions or actions.

'An advisory committee could lay out specific guidance to achieve a fair balance between protecting patients’ rights and taking into account the situation in which doctors were having to work.

'While the advanced planning for a pandemic was rather limited, we owe it to all our frontline clinicians – especially those who have had to make difficult decisions about patient treatment – to plan well for its aftermath.'

MDDUS CEO Chris Kenny said: 'I have already written to the UK’s senior law officers urging them to direct courts to take into account the unique circumstances of Covid-19 during any related criminal claim against healthcare professionals.

'I am very encouraged that MPs support the principle of an independent, expert advisory committee. I look to ministers to take forward this as a matter of urgency as they plan for the aftermath of Covid-19.'

The news comes as the GMC has moved to reassure doctors that they will take the 'challenging circumstances' into account when investigating coronavirus-related complaints.

The GMC will also only make fitness-to-practise information requests to doctors during the pandemic if there is 'an immediate patient safety concern'.

Meanwhile, NHS England said it will be supporting a 'system-wide pause' on the NHS complaints process, including the suspension of the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman complaints process for at least three months.

Readers' comments (6)

  • If complaints suspended why is CQC still going?

    Dear GP your heavy lifting training is out of date...
    Sorry..pens do weigh a lot...
    What would you like me to do with your complaint?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I think this is a very good idea. I can foresee a huge wave of claims against the medical and social care sectors along the lines of "why did my granny die" "why was my cancer not diagnosed". People will forget that doctors, carers and nurses have died and that working through this has been very difficult. Legal professionals will also need to be involved with this.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • don't beleive a word of it

    two words to say to you.............bawa garba !

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • GP: "I would have referred this patient but I was unable to due to restrictions placed on referral by my local hospital".

    Hospital: "at no point did we close our hospital to referrals or ask GPs not to refer or ask GPs to 'hold' referrals until we were ready to receive them" (fingers crossed behind back).

    Who will be believed?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • the way i've dealt with hospitals refusing referrals over the last 40 years is to send a copy of the refusal letter to the patient, and suggest they - as consumer - contact the writer of the letter on the number at the top. they then realise the problems we have getting through, and the time we waste on their behalf. i explain that they may not get anywhere, and i suggest they mumble the words "daily mail" (or other local rag) under their breath.

    occasionally the hospital will phone you to complain about such "underhand" behaviour, but i explain to them that i have been doing this job for a long time, and i have had the benefit of seeing, and examining, the patient. when they have done the same, we can have a debate about it.

    one thing that administators abolutely HATE, more than anything else, is having to deal with patients - who are a real thorn in the side for them !

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say