This site is intended for health professionals only
Wednesday 23 May 2012
Facebook Twiter Linkedin

Commissioning board chief admits 'I don't use the NHS'

By Gareth Iacobucci | 31 Oct 2011

The Government's newly-appointed chair of the NHS Commissioning Board has risked incurring the wrath of critics by admitting he does not use the NHS.

The admission from Professor Malcolm Grant came during a grilling he received at the hands of the House of Commons Health Committee last week.

When asked to demonstrate his ‘passion' for the NHS, the Univer­sity College London provost, appointed to the role earlier this month, was forced onto the defensive by MPs.

‘Come on, what do you want me to say?' he asked. ‘I find it difficult to demonstrate because I am not a patient of the NHS.'

Professor Grant - a barrister, and former environmental lawyer, was personally endorsed by health secretary Andrew Lansley as his preferred candidate to chair the NHS Commissioning Board.

But the appointment has proved controversial, with GP leaders calling for the post to be filled by a GP, and some MPs unconvinced of his suitability for the role.

Shadow health secretary Andy Burnham said the situation was ‘as ­unthinkable as Man Utd handing control of their transfer kitty to [Manchester City manager] Roberto Mancini.'

Writing in the Sunday Mirror in response to the admission, Mr Burnham said: ‘It really does say it all. The first choice to control your NHS doesn't believe in it enough to use it himself.'

READERS' COMMENTS

Anonymous, GP,
31 Oct 2011
There are lots of doctors with law degree, MBA and been charge of large organizations who can head up the NHS commisioning board. This reeks of nepotism.
I look forward to the day when the board for the Law commision is headed by a doctor/nurse or teacher.
Average (2Votes)
Top
Anonymous, Salaried GP,
31 Oct 2011
There are lots of GP's at present who have private health care. I think that this would be a good poll for pulse magazine. how many commissioners have private health care? It makes an interesting point. I would not like my referral sent off to be potentially rejected by a referral management service. I would not want my GP to say to me that I can't be referred as they have met their quota for the week. If I need a referral to a specialist, is it right that I am waiting weeks and weeks?

its really sad but are we really commissioning the kind of services that we would use for ourselves or our families? Can you blame Professor Grant for using private care? Can you blame the commissioners who have private health cover?

- anonymous salaried!
Average (3Votes)
Top
Peter Rice, GP Partner,
31 Oct 2011
I am a GP. I and my family have never had anything but excellent healthcare from the NHS. I have never gone 'private'.
Average (8Votes)
Top
Vinci Ho, GP Partner,
31 Oct 2011
Is this called self destructive or being stupid? You wonder if the guy was just dragged by Lansley to do the job and has got absolutely no conviction to do it properly . He knows what he is up against and already holding up his hands . Hence , what the hell do you want him to say ?????
Average (0Votes)
Top
Anthony Kilcoyne, Other NHS,
31 Oct 2011
Maybe only someone who doesn't use NHS services, can be objective and help the NHS truely synergise/modernise with other healthcare sectors, for the greater public good !?!
Going 'Private' or 'NHS' seems to stir political dogma more fitting of victorian times - we need both and more importantly, we need both to have high standards, recognise their limitations and actually work-well with each other.
Anything else is divisive and dilutes/harms the other - it's not NHS vs PVT, it's NHS + PVT !!!

Yours progressively,

Tony Kilcoyne - a dentist where this divisive nonsense is even worse than in medicine emoticon
Average (2Votes)
Top
Anonymous, Hospital nurse,
01 Nov 2011
How can some one who does not used the service give 100% leadership into something that they don't know or care about.
There are so many medical specialist around who is qualified and know how the NHS operated and
can do the job for the people and not the few who goes private!!
It have been proven several times that these so called appointment for the boys and girls is only for self interest and not for the user of the NHS
Average (0Votes)
Top

ADD YOUR COMMENTS

Please note You must be a registered user of PulseToday and logged in to add comments. Opinions expressed below are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect those of PulseToday. Comments are considered in the public domain and may be used in future Pulse coverage. We accept no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for the accuracy or the content of member comments.

Comment*

You must be logged in to add a comment.Clickhere to login.

SIGN UP FOR EMAIL NEWSLETTERS

Keep up-to-date with the latest changes to the NHS, CPD and clinical guidelines. Sign up below or find out more.

POLL

Is self-care the answer to the NHS efficiency drive? Read the full story here