This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Now hear this

  • Print
  • 5
  • Save

The Daily Mail reckons that the stethoscope is under threat. Nonsense. I’ll bet you remember the day you bought your first. I still have mine. Now retired, it’s a well worn Littman with grey tubing that was my constant companion through medical school and house jobs.

Students kept theirs neatly tucked away in their white coat pockets or allowed them to hang off their necks like pendulums. Doctors adopted the American “draped around the collar” approach with diaphragm below one clavicle and earpieces below the other.

This is how I learned one of medicine’s most important lessons, that a stethoscope is a badge of office, not a diagnostic instrument. Before the weekly cardiology ward round we managed to stuff the earpieces of the professor’s stethoscope with cotton wool.

He led us up and down the ward as usual, resting the bell and diaphragm on the chest of every patient in the place. He got some of them to breathe in, breathe out and say “99” and afterwards he left the ward as though nothing untoward had happened, probably to buy some “Otex” from Boots.

A stethoscope is not a device for listening to patients’ hearts and lungs, it’s a device used to shut the bastards up. It says, “Me doctor, you numbskull.” If you have a stethoscope - a proper one, not one of those weightless diaphragm-only pieces of crap that nurses get out of Xmas crackers – then you’ve got credibility.

You might say I’ve over-reacted as I’ve somehow acquired four. A teeny weeny one for the teeny weeny baby clinic, a paediatric one for no particular reason, a standard adult version to use when I want to make standard adults think that I’ve really listened to their chest before telling them they don’t need an antibiotic and my favourite, a really big, heavy “Cardiology Special”.

This weighs in at about half a pound at the business end. I keep it on hand in case any trouble kicks off on a home visit. The impact generated by a sizeable chunk of metal swinging at the end of a three foot length of sturdy plastic tubing is enough to persuade the meanest looking crossbred yard dog – or his owner - not to have a second go when it hits between the eyes.

And that is why, Mr or Miss ‘Daily Mail Reporter’, I don’t believe that doctors’ love affair with the stethoscope is coming to an end. Who cares if you can record a patient’s heart sounds using an app on a smartphone? That’s  missing the point. If I want to know what someone’s heart really sounds like I have a bunch of request forms labelled “Echocardiogram”.

Even the CQC have stuck their oar in, complaining that our beloved tubes teem with billions of pathogens. Not satisfied with confiscating our long sleeves, college ties and wristwatches, now they want our Littmans too.

Enough is enough. They’ll get my trusty stethoscope when they prise my cold dead hand off of it and not a moment sooner.

Readers' comments (5)

  • It has got nothing to do with teeming pathogens . It is precisely because it is a badge of office that "they" want to get rid of it . Gone the white coat and soon to be gone the title Doctor unless you have a PhD . The Daily Fascist would love to give us the title scum but unfortunately they have reserved that accolade for themselves.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • it is so funny to see newly qualified GPs strutting with their Littmans - cute almost. Have noticed this new trend over the past 2 years. Substitute for white coat?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I still have my stetoscope on me, at all times (except when I goto be, obviously) in "american style".

    I often get laughed at by my fellow GPs, some reminds me that there are no patients in federation/CCG meetings (although I would argue against that). But hey, it's what I've done ever since qualifying and as I've done it for the last 14 years, it's a difficult habit to let go!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Peter Swinyard

    I always find the top-of-the-range Fisher-Price stethoscope is a great substitute on home visits when I have fogotten my Littmann.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • as usual deranged nonsense ..first we are all exposed to multiple pathogens all the time on all is also important to develop a healthy immune any case washing hands is the obvious solution..otherwise we would all have to be constantly disinfecting all computer keyboards well proven to carry more pathogens than a toilet...dear tony love your articles..unfortunately real life is becoming a parody of your articles!!!!
    of course as this comes from the daily narrow minded ignorant fascist chidrens daily toilet paper for people with a reading age of 5 we understand..........but do not sympathise.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

  • Print
  • 5
  • Save

From: Copperfield

Dr Tony Copperfield is a jobbing GP in Essex with more than a few chips on his shoulder