Nurse's fate a clear lesson for would-be whistleblowers
It’s not general practice and she’s not a GP, but the decision to strike off whistleblower Margaret Haywood is a controversial one with clear implications for the rest of the medical profession.
By Steve Nowottny
It's not general practice and she's not a GP, but the decision to strike off whistleblower Margaret Haywood is a controversial one with clear implications for the rest of the medical profession.
Ms Haywood, a nurse at the Royal Sussex Hospital in Brighton, helped the BBC's Panorama programme with undercover filming to reveal the neglect of elderly patients.
Despite the BBC arguing there was an ‘overarching public interest' in producing the programme, the Nursing and Midwifery Council has this afternoon ruled that Ms Haywood should be struck off, after being a nurse for more than 20 years.
The BBC reports that the council ruled that Ms Haywood had ‘followed the behest of the filmmakers… rather than her obligations as a nurse.'
‘A patient should be able to trust a nurse with his/her physical condition and psycchologiical wellbeing without that confidential information ebeing disclosed to others,' the council ruled. ‘Although the conditions on the ward were dreadful, it was not necessary to breach confidentiality to seek to improve them by the method chosen.'
GP bloggers are already up in arms about the ruling. ‘Once again the authorities criticise the messenger, and ignore the message,' says the Jobbing Doctor.
NHS Blog Doctor puts it like this: ‘Are NHS whistle-blowers going to be shot? Of course not. We are a civilized country. We do not do things like that. Our whilstleblowers are, if possible, ignored… If they are not ignored they will likely be disciplined, sacked and humiliated.'
You might expect me, as a journalist, and the Jobbing Doctor and NHS Blog Doctor, as anonymous bloggers, to side with the whistleblower. But there does seem to be a wider concern among GPs and other NHS staff that dissent will not be tolerated.
What do you think? Was striking off Ms Haywood justified?Whistle-blowing in the NHS can be a dangerous business Whistle-blowing in the NHS can be a dangerous business Recent posts
Deja vu at the King's Fund April 16
Meldrum's perfect timing on Darzi centre bid April 15
NHS spin-doctors: 'Don't ask us for information' April 09
Patient feedback for the Youtube generation April 08
Was MPs' £70k trip to New Zealand best way to tackle binge-drinking?
Patient complaint? What would Dr Jack Bauer do... March 24
When is a missed target not a missed target? March 18
A busy 48 hours at BMA House March 18
The politics behind the minimum alcohol pricing plan March 16
Federations: policy pipe-dream or the future for GPs? March 13
'104% of practices using Choose and Book.' So how's that then? March 10
QOF and MPIG changes: what your PCT is doing March 3
GPC's exaggerated claims on QOF losers starting to pay dividends February 27
Extended hours? You must be joking... February 25
Should GMC have spent £43,000 on Cape Town junket? Feburary 20
Pay survey by next week? MPIGs might fly... February 18
Lord Darzi, GQ superstar February 13
Why GPs will no longer have a choice over Choice February 12
The strange contenders for the world's best GP job February 11