This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

‘GPs get a deliberately bad press’

BMA Council chair Dr Mark Porter talks to Caroline Price about defending general practice, his plans for the election and the implications of co-commissioning

Dr Mark Porter - online ^

Late and apologetic, Dr Mark Porter weaves between his press officer, lighting rig, photographer and tripod to greet me.

The anaesthetist has seen it all before in his two and a half years as chair of the BMA and is more than comfortable with meeting the media.

But Pulse meets him as he prepares to launch his biggest-ever media campaign, challenging politicians to ‘stop playing games’ with the NHS in the run-up to the general election.

Dr Porter is well aware that he has a hard sell, particularly with GPs who, he acknowledges, are likely to be sceptical, having been at the sharp end of politicking over the NHS in recent years.

But he is combative over what he sees as politically motivated attacks on the ‘failed’ GP contract.

‘It’s not a failed contract,’ he states. ‘It’s a contract negotiated in good faith by the profession and the Government at the time to address certain problems.

‘One of the reasons is the Government wants something different now, and its way of getting something different is to engage in constant criticism.’

And that criticism is jeopardising the future of the profession, says Dr Porter.

‘GPs get a bad press – at times you might say deliberately bad,’ he says. ‘When young doctors are making decisions they look at the criticism GPs get – not only in the press but also, for example, the effects of CQC inspections and the way they bear in particular on GP practices.’

And his view that many trainees view general practice unfavourably is backed by the latest figures. Pulse revealed online last month that GP trainee applications have fallen 6% this year to the lowest number for six years.

‘We’ve seen a number of plans from various bodies – whether that is Health Education England, the Labour party, or whoever, to increase the number of GPs. You think – great, somebody’s recognising there is a problem.

‘But I see a variety of problems with that,’ he explains. ‘The main one is persuading people to sign up for general practice. The training schemes are underfilled in many places. People are not choosing general practice in the same numbers we would like to see.

‘You can announce an increase in training places but the question is: will people come?’

But Dr Porter is prepared to back his words with action. Just weeks after we meet, he kicks off the BMA’s ‘No More Games’ campaign with a giant sculpture in the shape of a Jenga block at BMA house and posters all over the country.

Dr Mark Porter - online

Dr Porter is keen to emphasise the BMA’s role in addressing recruitment problems. For example, he points out, the GPC was involved in developing the 10-point plan for GP recruitment from NHS England, and the GPC ran its own ‘Your GP Cares’ campaign to engage patient support for doctors on the front line.

‘We want to see health and the health service being a really important part of the debate in the general election,’ Dr Porter says. ‘It takes up one-sixth of public expenditure so it’s a matter of concern to the entire population as well as, of course, to our members.’

He says that Labour’s policies fit most closely with the BMA’s objectives, but criticises the party’s past experiments with private providers: ‘We should remember it was the previous Labour Government that brought in the extension of the market following experiments with independent sector treatment centres.’

He expects the Conservatives to do ‘more of the same’ if elected and concedes that the Lib Dems’ plans do, in some respects, ‘cohere with what BMA members want’. But he says, with a smile, that he is ‘intrigued’ by UKIP’s proposals (the party has announced it wants to scrap the CQC and revalidation) although with the caveat that its position ‘isn’t as consistent’ as other parties’, referring to the recent difference in views over the role of private health insurance in the NHS.

He is taking nothing for granted in the current uncertain political climate: ‘I’m intrigued by what’s going to happen when we try to engage with UKIP about their policies for after the general election.’

Dr Porter is chairing the BMA at a time when the union’s power appears to be slipping. He took the helm after the ballot on industrial action in 2012, in which only a third of GPs took part.

This low turnout curtailed the union’s power and while other NHS unions have been out on the picket lines to protest against Government policy over pay, the BMA has stayed largely silent. Many GPs are disillusioned with a union that at times seems powerless to protect them.

In a further threat to the BMA’s role, the GP contract is being quietly unpicked by CCGs, 65 of which have been given the green light by NHS England to take full delegated commissioning responsibility for GP services from April. Pulse revealed 12 already have plans to introduce an alternative to the QOF.

At last year’s LMC conference, GP leaders voted to oppose giving primary care budgets to CCGs, but Dr Porter has more of a nuanced view.

‘Co-commissioning is fairly new, and it’s something individual GPs and practices are taking different views on,’ he says. ‘We don’t have a settled view yet because of those two factors.’

But won’t it inevitably have an impact on who controls the GP contract? ‘Absolutely,’ he says. ‘It will and it is meant to.

‘That said, many GPs and CCGs face a rather stark choice – either try to take the best they can from whatever’s on offer, or try to ignore it on principle and hope things will get better.’ Dr Porter will hope that many choose the latter option.

No more games BMA jenga

Quickfire Q&A

Is there a greater role for GPs in A&E departments?

Yes, but this has to be an individual choice for GPs. GPs’ job isn’t to sort out who attends hospitals – it is to actually provide general practice services for the population.

How do you make general practice a better place to work now?

Answers to that have to revolve around people deciding they want to stop having a go at the NHS.

Is the BMA going to launch some sort of marketing campaign aimed at general practice, like the RCGP?

We don’t have any specific plans to do anything similar in parallel to what the RCGP is doing.

Will the initiative to pay GPs not to retire early be successful?

It wouldn’t, if it had been the only thing announced, but being part of a package makes it more viable.

Do you think the Government deliberately stoked patient demand in order to make the case for an alternative health system?

No, I don’t believe the people running the NHS, or indeed Government ministers, set out to deliberately cause the NHS to fail and fall over.


Rate this article  (1 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (15)

  • Tell people GP's are useless for over a decade and then look surprised when people turn up in AED instead- including the Secretary of State for health's family.
    I can't influence the hidden agenda to have an entirely nurse/pharmacy run primary care system and only pay medical wages in secondary care, but I can tell you it's a massively inflated and more costly secondary care unless we accept a "Soylent Green" behaviour from primary care.
    Perhaps that's why're post Shipman Independant certification of medical cause of death proposals are so dead in the water.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • GPs are not recognised as doctors even by FY1. FY1 speak to us as though they are speaking to school children or like a headmaster instructing a pupil.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Where is this deliberate bad press that GPs receive? I avidly read and the only negative press I see if from GPs themselves criticising what the profession has come/government etc. I rarely read of others blaming GPs. I think most highly value the job GPs do. I wonder if Dr Porter could provide some examples of this deliberate bad press, because if we are to have a proper debate around this we need to be clear on the facts first.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Mark Porter pulled the rug out from under GPs when he publicly disagreed with the GPCs desire to restore the % of NHS budget spent on general practice. I don't mind that he holds his views but some like that need to be said to the GPC in private, not undermine and betray GPs in public. That was unforgiveable for a union leader, in my opinion a resigning matter Dr Porter. Disgusting behaviour.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @Anonymous | Work for a health/commissioning consultancy company | 06 March 2015 10:01am

    Do you live on Mars? I guess you've never read the government fed spiel to the Daily Mail.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • A useful article worth reading:
    for you to inform your own thinking
    Also do join the Founders Network to share your thoughts and experiences

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I wonder if this is the same Dr Mark Porter reported in PULSE on 23rd September 2014:

    BMA chair: GPs' arguments for 11% share of funding are 'artificial'
    Exclusive A split in the BMA has emerged as the Labour party calls for more funding, with BMA chair Dr Mark Porter saying GPs should not be given a greater share of the NHS budget, Pulse can reveal.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am confident this man will affect my day to day grassroot medicine by a factor if zero.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dr Porter - please get your priorities right decide which side you are on. Enough of BMA impotency and sweet gibberish. Strange you still have members.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Took Early Retirement

    BMA= Betray my associates.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say