This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

GPs ‘should become more militant’ – but not resign contracts

GP negotiators should be able to take a more militant stance in negotiations with the Government, before balloting on mass GP resignations from their NHS contracts, a Pulse Live GP panel has said.

The GP leaders, speaking at the keynote discussion at Pulse Live Liverpool today, said that the GPC is working with ‘both hands tied behind their backs’ due to BMA structures and advocated an independent GP negotiating body that would have more freedom to act in the professions’ interests.

A straw poll of delegates at the conference found that only around 20% thought GPs should resign from the NHS en masse, with 40% saying opposing it after hearing of the potential harm to patients and the political consequences of dividing the profession.

Speaking against the proposal, Family Doctor Association chair Dr Peter Swinyard said that the GPC is doing a good job, but they are limited by the wider BMA. 

He said: ‘The main reason I say no to resignation en masse is that our negotiators are working with both hands tied behind their backs. I have the highest regard for [GPC chair] Dr Chaand Nagpaul and his team, they’re brilliant. But they’re working within the BMA.

‘We need to stay with what we have, imperfect though it is. [But] we need a strong, GP-only, trade union which is not tied down by the needs of the other crafts in medicine. And we need a group of GPs prepared to take action.’

GP and media medic Dr Roger Henderson, argued that mass resignation should be a last resort.

He told delegates: ‘I do not want to have that conversation with my Mrs Trellises, saying “today I’m a GP, tomorrow I’m not. You can see me, but it’ll cost you £100… That’s not my way of doing general practice.’

Instead, he advocated a ’militant work-to-rule’, which would involve a wealth of non-GMS work being halted, including only doing palliative care visits, bouncing back secondary care work, and ‘bankrupting your CCG if need be.’

Dr Zoe Norris, spokesperson for the campaign group GP Survival, told delegates that the threat of resignation was what was required to bring the Government to negotiations, and was assured that ministers ‘would blink first’.

She added: ’The only way we’ll succeed is by standing together on this, and they will blink first if we do. The NHS cannot run without GPs, whatever they think.

Readers' comments (26)

  • I think it is utterly pathetic trying to blame the GPC's failures on BMA structures. The reality is that GPC members have a completely different agenda to the GP workforce.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ha ha ha PM 10:09: GPC share the blame with BMA as both have belied hoe and trust

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • GP's complain that they cannot survive on their current income so if they all resign, how would they survive financially?

    If they all resigned and a solution was found, there would be no guarantee that all GP's would be reemployed, the government would cherry pick suitable practices.

    GP's won't close lists because they get income from them, it is wrong that a GP can take on more patients when it cannot meet the needs of the patients it already has.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • interesting ...

    is the the same constraints that are supporting junior doctors in their ballot of strike action that are holding back the GPC?

    any concrete plans re: separation from BMA? nope so more pie in the sky.

    agree though that GPC/BMA has done a fantastic job in securing pension for over 50s and dumping on the rest of us.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • just a general thought - what would happen to the over 50's pensions if GPs walked out ?

    bit of an incentive not to rock the boat one thinks?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I like Zoe Norris;she's the only one who talks any sense

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say