This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Report this comment to a moderator

Please fill in the form below if you think a comment is unsuitable. Your comments will be sent to our moderator for review.

Report comment to moderator

Required fields.


Half of GPs still critical of RCGP's handling of the CSA exam row


I am someone who failed CSA for 2 points and that thanks to an odd actress's behaviour in SCA station who was determined to destroy my station and subsequently my life, as it turned out. I appealed and spent £ 800 only to be told that I did not present sound evidence ( as it was my word against their word). How could I? Should the video recording been used I would have passed the exam with clear difference. I have successfully completed all other components of GP Training. I have been signed off as "Competent for Licensing" pending on passing CSA. All my assessors, EDs, GP Trainers, my GP colleagues think I would make a very good GP. For the peace of mind I have been assessed by independent CSA experts and they think I should not have a problem with the exam. I have had excellent feedback from my patients. I am for high standards, period. I still believe not everyone who enters GP Training should be able to get through that 's how it is in every medical specialty. My GP dream is dead for good. I am locuming hospital jobs and my life is simply ruined. Three and half years of hard work, family deprivation come to nothing. All I wanted was FAIRNESS, not favours. Video recording of the exam for purposes of proper appeal and/or two examiners in the room. Should the cost be higher I am prepare to pay for it , or let RCGP be clear: I might not like it but I would accept it and not go through that saga of torture.

Posted date

27 Apr 2014

Posted time