This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

A faulty production line

GPs have 'never been happier'?

  • Print
  • 7
  • Save

It can be hard to be really funny when you are writing humour. Some people manage it effortlessly, and others struggle. It is always a delight to read Douglas Adams, or P.G Wodehouse. They wrote about a unique world that their characters inhabited, be it Zafod Beeblebrox or Bertie Wooster, you get under their skin, and into their world.

I don’t expect humorous writing from the Government, and particularly from the Department of Health; but this week they managed it. It came in their evidence to the Pay Review Body where they stated that GPs have 'never been happier', and they have 'maintained their income'.

I had to look twice at the press release to see if I had misread the report. I hadn’t.

This is simply untrue. It is a little like the football manager who never sees a serious foul by one of his players, or Richard Nixon asserting that there will be ‘no cover up at the White House’. It actually beggars belief that anyone could make such an assertion, particularly a government department.

We have, as GPs, a background in science, and are well-used to the use of statistics in enhance an argument; pharmaceutical companies have been trying it on for years, and we are now inured to their ‘evidence’ as they use all the tricks of selective reporting and skewed statistics to bolster a feeble case.

With the pharmaceutical firms, at least the case is feeble, and the drugs may have some benefit, but with the Department of Health there is no excuse for using the same tactics so say that Black is, in fact, White.

I have been a Jobbing GP for close on a third of a century. I have done the same job in that time, and have seen a parade of different governments, different secretaries of state, and different eras and philosophy in UK primary care. There have been some good times, and some bad times, but generally the goods exceeded the bads.

Right now, however, things are as bad as I have even known them. The GPs I meet only ever talk about the stress and the workload. Those who have devoted their professional lives to their practices cannot wait to retire, and it will be rare soon to find any GP working past the age of 60.

There are many stories about people working 12-hour days, lunch taken in the car between home visits, and the increasing mountains of paperwork.

When I started in general practice it was quite apparent that Government did not have a clue about what general practice was like, why GPs worked hard at developing their practices, and the small amount of management that was needed to keep the whole process going.

British general practice then was an efficient, effective and inexpensive way to deliver primary care. The NHS was the most egalitarian health system in the world, and we had a sense that we were contributing to the moral good of society.

I’m not wishing to turn the clock back, but the reasons we have lost old-style general practice are legion, and can be summed up by a few words: ever escalating workload, increasing bureaucracy, target setting and meeting, constant and pointless change, vast sums of money being used for other things than frontline care, increasing regulation, pointless hoops to jump through, the wretched and unloved GMC, rationing, meetings, ill-thought out ‘initiatives’ and creeping deprofessionalisation.

Need I go on?

A nine-year pay freeze, proposed pensions raids, and constant denigration in the media.

Never been happier?

Absolute rubbish. Nonsense on stilts.

The Jobbing Doctor is a GP in a deprived urban area of England

Readers' comments (7)

  • Mark Struthers

    I don’t want to retire: I work behind bars and have never been happier.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am ecstatic and over the moon about being a GP .... but not in the UK. I am writing my comments at the moment in sunny Australia where GPs are being respected and appreciated.
    I feel sorry for my colleagues in the UK....
    whoever participating in revalidation.......hey have fun :)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I loved my practice - but YES - retired at 60 in October last year. "Burn out" and total disillusionment with pointless hoops to jump through. Leaving in a week for 4 months of GP locums in various country practices in Victoria, Australia - just like last winter. I recommend it! (Google RWAV - Rurual Workforce Agency Victoria)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This reminds me of Ian Smith commenting, at thge time of Rhodesian UDI, that, 'our country has the happiest blacks in the world'.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Yes but........In the same week the BMA Chair described the Governments continuing refusal to backtrack on its commitment to GP pension contributions in excess of 9.8% as a "significant milestone".

    What hope do we have when the DOH and BMA leadership seem to live in the same parallel universe?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Doctors should not be asking whether they are unhappy. They should be asking whether their patients are fitter, better-cared for, and live longer lives? I am in my eighties and my answer to all these questions is yes. The way doctors used to behave towards patients up to about twenty years ago, was arrogant, uncaring and often slapdash. That this is no longer always the case, I put down to the chivying by the DH and patient opinion, not to the basic instincts of the medical profession, which regrettably live on in some of these comments.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

  • Print
  • 7
  • Save