This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Four-year training 'should be staggered' to prevent GP shortfall

Exclusive The introduction of four-year training may have to be staggered as the profession is facing a shortfall of 2,500 qualified GPs in one year, Pulse has learnt.

A Government adviser told Pulse the introduction of four-year training - which could begin as early as next year - had to be planned carefully in order to prevent a ‘workforce crisis’ that would hit already overworked practices.

The BMA said that they were fully supportive of four-year training, but had concerns that there would be a ‘lag period’ during which practices would struggle to recruit new GPs.

The warnings came as ministers considered the proposals for four-year training, following sign-off of the RCGP’s plans by Medical Education England in October.

The BMA GP Trainees Subcommittee met the RCGP and the Committee of General Practice Education Directors (COGPED) last week to discuss proposals to lengthen GP training to four years.

Dr Krishna Kasaraneni, chair of the BMA GP Trainees Subcommittee, said the move to four-year training would be a ‘positive experience’ for GPs, but they would be looking at the implications of the shortfall in trainees in future meetings.

Dr Kasaraneni said: ‘The intake will remain the same, at around 2,600. Assuming 95% pass the training, all that will happen is that the output for one year will be very minimal. It is only the ones who are out of synch. For a year there will be a lag period.

‘Without getting a huge number of CCTs in that one year, some practices may struggle to replace retired GPs. We are already hearing about increasing work in general practice in general but if you don’t then have newly qualified GPs coming out, some practices who are hoping to recruit may struggle a bit more.’

Related articles

Analysis: Practices may struggle to replace retired GPs

Professor Bill Irish, who is director of GP Education at the Severn Deanery and chairs a Government taskforce on GP recruitment and retention, said: ‘It is an issue. The bottom line is that it would need to be staggered over a period of a few years.

‘The earliest we can recruit for is 2014 so we are talking about those people supposed to be coming out in 2017. That gives us plenty of time to make sure there is not a workforce crisis. It may be that we need to stagger the recruitment to make sure it won’t happen.’

The move follows a similar warning by a Government-commissioned report last year, that said extending GP training to four years would create a ‘sudden and significant drop’ in the supply of GPs.

The proposals for four-year training, developed by the College, aim to ‘ensure that GP training keeps up with the demands of an increasingly challenging and complex environment’. The College says: ‘The extra year of dedicated general practice training will mean that the next generation of GPs is ready to meet the needs of a changing population, and the practical challenges that the NHS presents.’

Professor Mayur Lakhani, former chair of the RCGP, said there must be careful planning to prevent any ‘hiatus’ in the supply of GPs.

He said: ‘Some work needs to be done around that because there will be a year when there will be a gap. With careful planning we may be able to prepare for that.’

Readers' comments (4)

  • Now what happens?
    Recruit GPs EEA countries?
    Hey RCGP what about those who fail CSA with 6 marks of passing bar, have ace AKT scores and excellent PSQs and Work based assessment?
    Is this not fair to ask RCGP to have a slightly broadened SD for CSA.
    Prof Gerada you got a choice here ,
    a) Get the devil you don't know i,e recruit GPs from somewhere other than uk

    Or

    b) Look arround there are some good doctors who CSA has deemed not suitable. They ain't failing csa by much. You know them. They have been trained in UK General Practice.

    Tomorrow will be defined by choices we make today.
    Just hope we make the right one!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Now I wonder why there is a workforce crises?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Fact, there is a major crisis of recruitment . The storm is going to be more and more ferocious
    Fact , the government is destroying general practice , thanks to Agent Hunt and his predecessor
    Fact, morale is all time low
    Training and attracting more young GPs ( hence give them best possible educations) is slightly different from having enough GPs to work in primary care . Because the latter involves retaining existing and newly qualified GPs.
    Of course, if any problem aises with this 4 years proposal ,the DoH will find all kind excuses to blame us because we proposed this in the first place

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • That's 2600 muppets too many.Hasn't the message got out yet that KEEP AWAY FROM GENERAL PRACTICE!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say