This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Vaping causes similar heart damage to smoking tobacco

Vaping – inhaling nicotine from electronic cigarettes – seems to cause the same kind of damage to heart vessels as smoking tobacco cigarettes, a study has found.

The study authors said it questioned Public Health England advice that vaping is likely to be much safer than smoking tobacco cigarettes.

The team, led by Professor Charalambos Vlachopoulos from the University of Athens Medical School, studied 24 healthy adult smokers and looked at how their pulse wave velocity – a marker of aortic stiffness – changed after smoking ordinary or E-cigarettes.

After vaping for a prolonged, 30-minute period the smokers had a similar increase in aortic stiffness as they had after smoking a tobacco cigarette for five minutes.

However, vaping for just five minutes did not lead to such a big increase in vessel stiffness.

The authors concluded that ‘E-cigarettes over 30 minutes induces an unfavourable effect on aortic stiffness similar to tobacco cigarette smoking,’ although they added that the effect was ‘not as prompt and is less potent’ than tobacco cigarette smoking.

The Department of Health and PHE recently backed use of licensed E-cigarettes to help people give up smoking, as an alternative to other nicotine-replacement products. 

However, Professor Vlachopoulos told The Telegraph ‘there could be long term heart dangers’ from E-cigarettes and that he ‘wouldn’t recommend them now as a method to give up smoking’.

He added: ‘I think the UK has rushed into adopting this method.’

Professor Peter Weissberg from the British Heart Foundation said ‘much more research is needed to establish the safety of long term use of these devices’.

PHE, said in a statement: ‘Vaping carries a fraction of the risk of smoking, yet many smokers are still not aware, which could be keeping people smoking rather than switching to a much less harmful alternative.’

Readers' comments (3)

  • Another very questionable headline relating to "vaping" it should read "Vaping causes similar heart damage to smoking tobacco when done for 6 times as long".

    I recently read another headline about vaping causing "popcorn lung" again what the headline didn't mention is that it was only if you used certain solutions with particular flavourings added to them that this was a risk.

    When will journalists write headlines which reflect the validity of the scientific method behind the research and accurately reflect the findings?

    People who smoke will use these headlines they have scan read and use it as justification to keep smoking.

    Causing themselves and anyone around them damage. Whom ever writes these headlines needs to think about their accountability for the outcomes of what they tell the general public.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Patients often ask me the question' would you recommend eleckie cigarettes?'
    I always said , ' Choose the lesser evil out of the two but you still have to give it all up eventually.'
    It is smoking cessation over a confined timescale , not smoking replacement ......
    That is exactly the argument why NICE' s recommendation of give nicotine patches to merely cut down number of cigarettes , remains controversial .
    Sorry,call me lack of sympathy , I never smoke

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • this is why no doctor or noctor should ever prescribe this. Remember first do no harm....even if NICE or Public health England say so.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say