This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Some GPs 'come out with rubbish' around mental health, says health and care minister

GPs’ attitudes to mental health need to change in order to achieve true parity of esteem for mental and physical ill health, with some having a ‘rubbish’ attitude, health and care minister Norman Lamb claimed today.

Speaking at a conference on psychological therapies Mr Lamb said he believed all GPs needed core training in mental health, and that while some GPs ‘totally get it’ others ‘come out with rubbish’.

Mr Lamb was responding to a question during a session on ‘the mental health gap’ from a service user who asked when would all health professionals start taking mental problems seriously, after being told ‘to stop watching TV and go for a walk’.

Mr Lamb said: ‘Well I totally accept the central point that there is an enormous way to go still. And one of the things that is essential is attitudes of clinicians towards mental health…I happen to believe every GP needs to be centrally trained in mental health and we’re not there yet.

‘Attitudes in primary care are very variable, you get some great GPs who really get it and others who just come out with the rubbish you just described there.’

Mr Lamb also spoke about the Government’s new access and waiting time standards due to come into force in April, which he said would be critical to bringing mental health care in line with assessment and treatment of physical problems - and should include measurement of access to the ‘right’ form of talking therapy for the individual rather than just any treatment.

However, Labour shadow public health minister Luciana Berger said that in addition to waiting time standards for talking therapies - also enshrined in Labour’s health policy - Labour’spledge to make access to psychological therapies a right set down in the NHS constitution would also be key.

Citing a Pulse investigation which revealed over 80% of GPs had felt forced to prescribe antidepressants because patients were facing long delays for talking therapies, Ms Berger said: ‘A recent survey of GPs… showed 84% said they had been forced to treat their patients with medication instead of talking therapy because they couldn’t be helped by their local IAPT service.’

She added: ‘We must… ensure therapies enjoy the same status as other kinds of treatments on our health service. I refer again to that GP survey - we know GPs too often reach for medication as opposed to talking therapies. We’ve said we want to update the NHS constitution to ensure that patients have the same right to talking therapies as they currently have for drugs and medical treatments.

‘We will ensure that psychological therapies are given the priority they deserve and send a very strong signal to commissioners about the importance of commissioning these services.’

Speaking to Pulse, Ms Berger said: ‘At the moment there’s no right within the NHS constitution to talking therapies. That for us is absolutely key that we should change that.’

She added: ‘We’ve also talked about whole-person care - that in and of itself we think will make a massive difference, to treat the whole person rather than one symptom at a time. That’s very different to what anyone else is saying.

‘We are also seeking to invest an extra £2.5bn a year into the NHS which will create 20,000 more nurses, which will have a positive impact on mental health and GPs too, including addressing the issue of training. There are thousands of GPs already doing training in mental health but more needs to be done.’

Samsung HD TV - win - online

Take Pulse’s February survey

Want to win a Samsung Smart HD TV? Then takePulse’s multi-topic survey covering a range of areas, from recruitment to NICE guidelines, and the GP contract.

It should take just a couple of minutes to complete, and will help Pulse gain a vital insight into the views of the profession. 



Readers' comments (20)

  • Mr Lamb some goverment ministers have a rubbish attitue to the NHS and GP land in particular.they just dont get it.Dont wish you well in may liberal destruction tis way comes.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • A rubbish attitude -like norman lamb .

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I've been a GP for decades and he's right - I don't get mental health. 20% of my workload + all the hidden agenda stuff -I've just ignored all this time and put it down to stress. Mr Lamb - you are a tool

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I think they need to get the mental health services in order, before trying to blame GPs.

    I honestly would like to send my mental health patients to face to face cognitive behaviour therapy, within a few days, without having to jump through hoops - but that is just not available.

    Make it available and I will use it.

    If instead you base your 'talking therapy' on a cheaper system with limited evidence of effectiveness, I will give it the same respect as other unproven therapies.

    As far as secondary mental health services, the creation of such a fragmented service is totally idiotic. Why is it that I can pick up the phone and speak directly to a consultant in almost any physical medical speciality - but getting a specialist to take responsibility for a mental health patient is impossible?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I think Norman Lamb needs to stop watching TV and go for a walk.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Any context for ‘stop watching TV and go for a walk’ or has he just made uneducated/uninformed assumption that this was not good advice?
    I don't understand why these politicians continue to make such assertions from a position of ignorance.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Norman it's not too late to train to be a GP ... we need more GPs - so come on train up and show us how to do it ....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hazel Drury

    The way morale is at the moment most of us will "totally get it" as we end up as mental health service users ourselves.

    The fee for mental health act assessments has been the same now for 11 years - essentially another year on year pay cut. Little wonder we struggle to train GPs to take on the extra responsibility to become section 12(2) approved and take the lead locally on mental health.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This comment has been removed by the moderator.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Anyone else think that the "mental health" card has been over-played for years?
    For example, I never really "got" depression as a medical student doing my pscyh attachment, my doubts grew in my training year when there was "2 question" screening test. Now that I have grey hairs, I am a bit bolder, and I gladly subscribe to the theory that "depression-as-chemical imbalance-illness" idea is a fraudulent racket and that anti-depressant medications are one of the biggest hoaxes played on the public purse in my lifetime.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say