This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

Gold, incentives and meh

GPs face new drive to cut inappropriate antibiotic use for urinary tract infections

GPs are facing a clampdown on use of trimethoprim for treatment of urinary tract infections, under new targets for commissioners set out by NHS chiefs.

The targets for CCGs - set out in a new two-year 'Quality Premium' scheme starting next April - are likely to put GPs under pressure to choose nitrofurantoin over trimethoprim in younger patients, and cutting down on overall use of trimethoprim in elderly people.

They will also see CCGs rewarded if GPs keep driving down their overall use of antibiotics.

It comes after public health chiefs pinned recent rises in E. coli bacteremia, mainly in older people, on inappropriate antibiotic use leading to repeat infections.

GP leaders warn that trimethoprim is more convenient and, as a result, this will mean a change in practice for many GPs if CCGs actively implement policies to try and receive the funding.

The new targets form part of a measure aimed at tackling a rise in risky bloodstream infections and cutting unnecessary antibiotic use in at-risk patients.

The trimethoprim targets will see CCGs awarded up to around £60,000 next year if practices can achieve at least a 10% reduction in the ratio of trimethoprim to nitrofurantoin prescribed, and at least a 10% cut in trimethoprim prescribed to patients over 70. Both thresholds will be reviewed the following year.

Another target will award CCGs around £14,000 a year if practices can keep total antibiotics prescriptions at or below the 2013/14 CCG average level.

CCGs will also be aiming for a 10% reduction in E. coli bloodstream infections and starting to report primary care data on these, in two further targets making up the measure.

NHS England said the new trimethoprim targets would ‘work to increase the appropriate use of nitrofurantoin as first-line choice for the empirical management of UTI in primary care settings, and support reduction in inappropriate prescribing of trimethoprim which is reported to have a significantly higher rate of non-susceptibility in “at-risk” groups’.

Public Health England guidance on common infections currently recommends nitrofurantoin as the first-line option for uncomplicated UTI in patients with normal kidney function, while trimethoprim or pivmecillinam are alternatives if GFR is below 45ml/min.

Dr Andrew Green, chair of the GPC clinical and prescribing subcommittee said: ‘Many GPs have preferred trimethoprim which is more convenient to take, is cheaper, and better tolerated, so this will represent a change in practice for many of us.’

He added: ‘I would like to see efforts made to reduce the unnecessary treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria in the elderly, as many courses of antibiotics for this are unnecessary.

‘Education needs to be directed not only at care home staff but also hospital doctors, as it does seem that every elderly person admitted acquires a UTI diagnosis and treatment, when in fact many simply have bacterial colonisation.’

The Quality Premium scheme is a set of incentives from NHS England to CCGs potentially worth £5 per patient.

The new measures come after GPs received praise from NHS England for cutting antibiotics prescriptions more than expected in 2015, after the introduction of Quality Premium targets to cut antibiotic use, although GP leaders have pointed out that GPs have already been taking the lead on cutting antibiotics use.

Quality Premium 2017-19 - Antibiotic prescribing targets

Reduction of inappropriate antibiotic prescribing for UTI in primary care

  • a 10% reduction (or greater) in the Trimethoprim: Nitrofurantoin prescribing ratio based on CCG baseline data (June15-May16) for 2017/18. In 2018/19 reduction thresholds will be reviewed to ensure targets reflect latest activity and maximise appropriate reduction gains
  • a 10% reduction (or greater) in the number of trimethoprim items prescribed to patients aged 70 years or greater on baseline data (June15-May16) for 2017/18. In 2018/19 reduction thresholds will be reviewed as above.

Sustained reduction of inappropriate prescribing in primary care

  • items per STAR-PU must be equal to or below England 2013/14 mean performance value of 1.161 items per STAR-PU. This threshold will remain during 2018/19.

Related images

  • Antibiotic pills  SPL

Readers' comments (14)

  • community nursing and care home staff have a "comission bias" the number of " checked the dipstick and there where -pick either nitrate , leucocyte, protein or blood- she MUST have an antibiotic for the infection" without any signs of sickness /infection in the patient

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I took a phone call from a nursing home a couple of years ago where antibiotics were requested for a patient whose dipstick was "positive" for specific gravity 😂

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Another edict that expects hindsight before the event.
    Lottery numbers anyone?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The article mentions trimethiprim is more convenient but remember nitrofurantoin comes in 100mg BD slow release form which is cheaper than standard.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How exactly does this tally with :

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Does any one think about unintended consequences of antibiotic restriction to dangerous levels?

    Rheumatic fever, Rheumatic Valvular disease and joint diseases are uncommon so far due to the advent of abx. Do we need these diseases to return?

    Even in this case, what happens if one patient develops pyelonephritis and requires a&e visit and hosp admission for a week?? What happens to the cost overall? what about GMC complaint after that and investigation? Is it worth it for the NHS and for the GP to even consider this premium. False economy all around.

    Trimethoprim works well if used for 5 to 7 days. Repeated contradicting EDICTS - 3 day courses only for several years and now this - all nonsense.

    Only solution to reduce abx resistance is to prevent abx use in farming and veterinary sector and patient education. NO MORE DOCTOR EDUCATION. Enough !!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Nitrofurantoin is ineffective in cases where the renal function is impaired. It should be used with caution in the elderly.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dear All
    Somzil 1 @ 3:48 has it, spot on. We are not the source of resistant e-coli, its the colons of the cows down which the farming trade pours thousands of tons of the stuff each year, many times more than the entire medical profession. Thats where the bugs grow up and develop resistance. the science if firmly established.

    He also right that in the elderly 5-7 days of Trimethop or Nitro is needed in the symptomatic elederly.

    I would only add do no hold back from therapeutic trials of long low dose prophylactic Trim or Nitro in the recurrently ill elderly.

    What on earth to PHE know about clinical medicine?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Qoff is dying and on the way out
    Here Come the CCG targets
    Treat patients ..not targets or statistics

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How much of the "award" will be needed to off-set increased prescribing costs of nitro over trimethoprim?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say