This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

GPs unable to follow guidance as just one in six has access to FeNO testing

Exclusive Just one in six GPs has access to the forced exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) testing that NICE recommends they should use to help diagnose asthma, Pulse can reveal.

In a survey of 668 GPs, a total of 16.02% said they had access to the machines used for FeNO testing.

Some 1.65% of GPs said they had these machines at their practices, with 2.18% of GPs accessing the machines via CCGs and health boards and 14.94% via a hospital.

Last year NICE updated guidelines advising GP to use FeNO testing machines, which cost upwards of £2,000, to help diagnose suspected asthma patients.

But GPs told Pulse they do not understand FeNO testing, they cannot afford the machines, and said there was no patient need. GPs called the guidelines are ‘ridiculous’ and ‘irrelevant’, with ‘no sensible basis in primary care’.

Dr Dermot Ryan, GP and president of the international Respiratory Effectiveness Group, said: ‘There are very few people who would advocate using FeNO as a point-of-care test to make an asthma diagnosis, because you need other things to answer that question.’

He added: ‘Unless you understand how to use the test, and what the tests indicate, it’s practically irresponsible to be using it at all.’

Dr Ryan said the tests are ‘never conclusive’ and should only be used by clinicians who understand them. He said: ‘It’s only a part of the asthma jigsaw. I can see that being quite fraught.’

He said the majority of GPs do not understand FeNO testing and warned that cash-strapped practices cannot afford the equipment.

Dr Duncan Keeley, GP and policy lead for the Primary Care Respiratory Society (PCRS), said the low level of uptake was ‘unsurprising’.

He said: ‘The problems around the availability of FeNO testing in primary care was one among a number of reason why the PCRS UK advised against publication of the NICE diagnosis and monitoring recommendations for asthma.

‘Peak flow monitoring should be the first line objective test to support a clinical diagnosis of asthma in primary care.’

Dr Shaun Pike, a GP partner in Redditch and Bromsgrove, said he does not currently have access to the testing and said his asthma review service is already at full stretch. He added that he has ‘no faith’ in the accuracy of tests.

He said: ‘A normal result on a given day cannot be taken as reliable ‘proof’ a patient doesn’t have the condition, and I cannot see it has a role in routine GP asthma diagnosis or management.’

Dr Farah Jameel, BMA GP committee executive team member, said: ‘As NHS England acknowledged when the NICE guidelines were published, changes on the frontline will take time to implement, not least because of a need for additional infrastructure and training in primary care.

‘These figures do however seem low and underline the present lack of infrastructure, and properly funded and commissioned pathways, to support NICE guidelines in practice.’

In November 2017, NICE published new guidelines recommending spirometry and FeNO testing by GPs where available, to be conducted alongside the usual clinical assessment of symptoms.

At the time, Professor Mark Barker, director of the centre for guidelines at NICE, acknowledged that ‘investment and training required to implement the new guidance will take time’.

The BMA and RCGP said the extra testing was ‘too complex’ and would mean increased GP appointments, referrals and costs.

Do you have access to FeNO testing?


Yes - 1.65% (11),

No - 82.04% (548),

Don’t know - 16.32% (109) 

Via CCG/health board:

Yes - 2.18% (14)

No - 67.60% (434)

Don’t know - 30.22% (194)

Via hospital:

Yes - 14.94% (98)

No - 35.98% (236)

Don’t know - 49.09% (322) 

The survey was launched on 12 April 2018, collating responses using the SurveyMonkey tool. The 28 questions asked covered a wide range of GP topics, to avoid selection bias on one issue. The survey was advertised to our readers via our website and email newsletter, with a prize draw for a Ninja Coffee Bar as an incentive to complete the survey. A total of 668 GPs responded to this question.


Readers' comments (5)

  • no surprise. A defining characteristic of UK 21st century medicine is the gulf between guidelines and reality on the ground.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    ‘investment and training required to implement the new guidance will take time’.

    This is such an irresponsible and out of touch response from somebody in NICE, given the fact the recommendations from NICE inevitably carry a medicalegal bearing ( despite what some argued against that). If there is specifically targeted investment, tell me where is it? Otherwise, it is another effort to put us on no man's land . Pathetic !

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It just shows how out of touch NICE is to the grassroot GPs. It is dangerous to do a test without training or understanding. NHSE should invest in the test and training if it want us to use it.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Nice are irrelevent to prcatice, irresponsible in thier guidelines, and treated as god by the gmc / courts. Thi sjust proves what has long been so obviously the case

    The time has come to bin them!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Just Your Average Joe

    NICE guidance - I need a Bentley to sit in when writing guidance on how to diagnose asthma.

    Thank you makers of FeNO testing devices for the payment to endorse your product and try and make thousands of GP practices go and buy one.

    I will enjoy my half a day directorship on your board for my advice and guidance - with another bucket load of cash.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say