This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

A faulty production line

E-cigarette use 'associated with reduced smoking cessation', study claims

E-cigarettes reduce chances of quitting smoking and ‘should not be recommended as smoking cessation aids’, a study published in the Lancet has claimed.

A meta-analysis of 18 previous observational studies and two clinical trials saw researchers concluding that smokers who also use e-cigarettes are significantly less likely to quit than those who only smoke conventional cigarettes.

The team from the University of California, San Francisco, deduced that use of e-cigarettes decrease a person’s chances of quitting smoking by 28%.

The paper said: ‘E-cigarette use is increasing and, although quitting smoking is a common marketing claim and is often cited as a reason for use among cigarette smokers, the overall conclusion from the available studies is that e-cigarette use is associated with reduced smoking cessation in the real world’.

However, the study – which comes just weeks after the Government approved the first e-cigarette for prescription by GPs in England – was met by strong criticism from UK smoking cessation experts and Public Health England (PHE).

Professor Paul Aveyard, a professor in behavioural medicine at the University of Oxford, said the analysis was flawed by the sample population studied.

He said: ‘This review collates many observational studies, which have particular issues in this context. Typically, they enrol people who smoke and ask them if they have used e-cigarettes.

‘The problem with the analysis is that people who were helped by e-cigarettes have left this [sample] population because they gave up smoking and therefore you leave only those who were not helped.’

Professor Robert West, a professor of health at health at University College London, went further to suggest publication of the study was ‘a major failure of the peer review system in this journal’.

Referring to an ongoing large-scale population survey of smoking in England, he said: ‘If use of e-cigarettes caused fewer smokers to quit, the quit rate in England would have decreased as use of e-cigarettes has increased. Data from the Smoking Toolkit Study shows, if anything, the opposite.

PHE director of tobacco, alcohol and drugs Rosanna O’Connor said: ‘Evidence from practice in England shows that two out of three smokers who combined e-cigarettes with additional expert support from a local stop smoking service quit successfully and while dual use is a complex issue, many vapers report using an e-cigarette to cut down and ultimately quit.’

Readers' comments (5)

  • Why do they need a study to prove e-cigarettes are bad? Isn't it obvious. Too many 'legalise cannibis' type hipis in this country.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • No, it isn't at all "obvious", which is why studies are needed. Heard of "Evidence-based medicine" at all in your studies? Or "spelling"? And where on Earth does cannabis enter the question?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This comment has been removed by the moderator.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "many vapers report using an e-cigarette to cut down and ultimately quit."

    Isn't that what they call anecdote? Is the plural of "anecdote" now "evidence"?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • All three of my sons no longer smoke cigarettes now using just e cigs with low nicotinne content

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say