This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

The docbot will see you now

Early Christmas closing 'may not be an option' for practices

GP practices may have to open normal hours throughout the Christmas holidays if commissioners decide out-of-hours services are unable to cope with the extra demand, NHS England has said.

As the holiday period is approaching, NHS England's official guidance says GP practices can close early on non-Bank Holidays only if they have 'prior written agreement with both the provider and the CCG commissioner of that service'.

But NHS England added that early closing 'may not be a reasonable or sustainable option' if commissioners feel out-of-hours services are under too much pressure.

This is the latest in the annual row over Christmas and New Year opening, which has seen some practices clapped with breach notices for closing early.

Christmas Eve and New Year's Eve this year fall on a Saturday, but traditionally practices have often closed early on the last working day before Christmas and New Year due to slower demand.

The current guidance released by NHS England said: 'GP out-of-hours providers have previously expressed concern about early closing of general practices at Christmas and New Year and the potential impact on them.

'Given the pressures that out-of-hours providers already face during this period, this may not be a reasonable or sustainable service option.'

It said it will be up to NHS England regional teams or CCGs commissioning general practice to decide whether practices can close early or have to remain open on these days.

The guidance said: 'The contract regulations require a practice to notify their commissioner of their proposal to sub-contract.

'Where this is the case the commissioner will need to be assured that such an arrangement will deliver essential medical services during core hours otherwise the commissioner will be unable to accept the proposal.'

NHS England warned that if practices fail to follow these steps, they are at risk of being slapped with a breach of contract notice.

The guidance said: 'In summary practices are expected to be open from 08:00 to 18:30, Monday to Friday excluding bank holidays, unless alternative arrangements are agreed in advance.

'If these arrangements are not in place, or if tested they fail, this may amount to a breach of your contract.'

GPC contracts and regulations lead Dr Robert Morley said that if practices wished to close early over the holidays, this 'would be perfectly legitimate under the regulations if it is going to be clear that demand for appointments will be low and practices are still meeting the reasonable needs of their patients'.

He said: 'It is highly unlikely that such early closing will then lead to any increase demand during the out-of-hours periods. Practices might choose to deal with this by having a practice duty doctor on call or reciprocal arrangements with another named GP.'

He added that although subcontracting to an out-of-hours provider 'would require the commissioner's consent' this 'must not be unreasonably withheld'.

The letter comes as last year GPs and staff were allowed to leave early on Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve, after NHS England revised its guidance on the long-running saga which saw practices handed breach notices for closing early and reverting to out-of-hours services.

The GPC's official advice is for practices to ensure that:

  • patients are aware of any closures in advance by using surgery notices, and including messages on repeat prescriptions;
  • arrangements are in place to ensure that repeat prescriptions are ordered and collected in a timely matter to avoid requests over the period of practice closure;
  • answer phone messages should be changed at 18:30 on the afternoons of early closure - in particular - for opted out practices where there is a change from the sub-contracted provider to NHS 111.

Readers' comments (7)

  • Given that both Christmas Eve and New year's Eve are on a Saturday this year I expect most practices will be closing at the normal time the day before?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Are there really any stories out there which show that the Government is actually helping doctors?
    At every turn they are being attacked in every way, financially, physically and emotionally.
    I know the Mayhunt beast has already dug the hole for the NHS to be buried in, however our poor docs are still on the front line and taking the brunt of the Mayhunt's venom.
    Can't we ask Eddie Redmayne to capture it and spirit it way?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Practices might choose to deal with this by having a practice duty doctor on call or reciprocal arrangements with another named GP.'
    Which poor Barsteward is going to pull the short straw?
    Or will it be a locum ?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I would think this could be resolved locally by liaison between OOH and practices - OOH says "we are four doctors short for covering the afternoon, find us four doctors and we will agree to your early closing."
    Shouldn't be impossible.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This is the usual annual nonsense, although it's partly irrelevant this year due to the way that the dates fall.

    NHS-E want us to stay open even though no patients want to attend. At the same time, try calling NHS-E offices on the same day after 2pm...answering machine only.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How about GP Surgery agree to remain open on Fridaybefore Christmas till 6.30 provided all NHSE staff is available to answer our queries till their normal opening hours I.e. till 5 PM. I bet they will not accept this.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Its a Christmas tradition, to get the 'Christmas eve is a normal working day' edict from the local NHSE lackeys. It never was and never will be.
    This year, it REALLY isn't a normal working day .
    Merry Christmas to all.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say