This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

GPs 'can't abandon their contracts with the NHS', says Hunt

Health secretary Jeremy Hunt has said that GPs have an 'obligation to follow their contracts', following calls from local GP leaders for the BMA to support vulnerable practices to go private. 

Mr Hunt was responding to a question about the motion set for debate at next week’s England LMCs Conference, first reported by Pulse, which called for practices to be 'supported to operate within a private, alternative model' if they feel they can no longer operate within the NHS.

Speaking to MPs on the Commons Health Select Committee, the health secretary said practices' 'contract with the state' was their principal source of income, so they have a responsibility to look after NHS patients.

Responding to a question on the motion, Mr Hunt said: 'I would listen to everything that came out of any BMA conference carefully but the Government makes policy on the NHS, not the GPs, and they do have an obligation to follow the contracts that they have.

'But obviously if there is concern about the levels of workload and about the capacity of the system then that is something that I am going to listen to very carefully.''

Labour MP Ben Bradshaw - a former health minister himself - asked Mr Hunt: ‘[GPs] are private contractors aren't they and you couldn't just stop them [abandoning the NHS]. Does this not show how bad things have got to that GPs are even considering en masse abandoning the NHS?’

Mr Hunt responded by saying the Conservative Party had wanted GPs to be NHS employees when the NHS was set up in 1948.

He added: 'The point I am making is, yes they are private contractors but they also do have a contract with the state which is the source of their income, and we have a responsibility under that contract to look after all NHS patients in the area they operate.'

Explaining the pressure GPs are under, Mr Hunt said: 'I think we have to look at the underlying reason why those kind of motions are being debated, and I think it is GPs feel that their workload is too high, their job has become too stressful. Sometimes they feel that they are on some sort of hamster wheel of between 30 and 40 ten-minute appointments every day, and it is exhausting.

'The long-term solution to that is to get more capacity into the system, which is why we have our plan to recruit 5,000 more GPs which we are in the middle of trying to deliver. Some bits of that plan are going well, other bits less well, but I am absolutely determined to deliver that and I think that is the long-term solution.'

He added that he hoped GPs had taken from recent announcements he had made that this was 'an area of great concern for the Government as well and we are taking a number of measures to try and relieve the pressures on general practice'.

Explaining to the committee how he was working on resolving the GP workforce crisis, Mr Hunt mentioned both the recently unveiled state-backed indemnity scheme, and the expanded incentive scheme to get GP trainees into areas that have found it difficult to recruit.

At the same hearing, Mr Hunt said NHS was struggling financially because demand 'has grown faster' than the Department of Health 'had anticipated', linking growth in emergency services demand to ‘underinvesting’ in general practice.

Mr Hunt said: ‘We can do an enormous amount to bring down demand for emergency care. In the ambulance service we have 4,400 999 calls more every day than we had in 2010, that creates massive pressure on the emergency services.

'One of the reasons for the pressure is we have underinvested in general practice in recent decades, and have underinvested in the kind of community care, so that would mean that people would not get to the point where they have to dial 999 and additional expensive hospital care. That’s what the whole sustainability model is about.’


Readers' comments (35)

  • Vinci Ho

    Send your comments now

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • National Hopeless Service

    And the Jeremy came to the earth and spoketh of reality and truths. Hallelujah they doth shout.

    But then Mother Theresa (May) and Jeremy did b#gger all about it.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We have "an obligation to follow our contracts" but he can change them at a whim!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • All these other private companies seem to be able to hand contracts back to the NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Finally we have his attention. We can hand contracts back en mass Mr Hunt. Just like the dentists. We can go. I hope when this is debated next Friday, the LMC set a deadline and targets (NHSE will like those) which must be met before we all leave. And then, finally, I may have a career.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    The truth is the last thing a politician would want to tell only because the circumstances give him no alternative.
    For our representatives:
    Examine carefully the reasons behind this behaviour before any further negotiation.
    And remember it is only a fine line between negotiation and extortion. Question only resides on who is the extortioner and who is being extorted? There is no mercy in politics and remember how merciless the enemy has been on us .....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dear All,
    What rank hypocrisy, what contract or agreement has Mr Hunt ever stuck to? CCGs only too happy to terminate PMS contracts and how many new GMS contracts have they let in the last x years, oh that'll be a zero.
    Paul C

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Oh yes they can

    I did and it feels so good

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • AlanAlmond

    The NHS does not own me. I am not a slave. I will work for whoever I choose. If an NHS contract obligates me to sacrifice my sanity, welfare and entitles the government to parasitise me at will, I will walk away and give the finger as I do, could anyone blame me for doing so?
    The problem the government has is that it imposes it’s contracts, often without negotiation. It feels it can do this because it holds a virtual monopoly on employment through the NHS. Treating those you impose contracts on like shit is not conducive to a longer term working relationship. We (GPs) need to leave the NHS, regain our professional integrity and end this nightmare of bondage to successive parasitic governments.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Let's see if the great and good of our profession will lead us in a rousing chorus of OH YES WE CAN. I won't be holding my breath.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say