This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

One third of GPs think NHS should stop funding IVF

Exclusive A third of GPs believe that the NHS should stop funding IVF treatment for patients with fertility issues, while one in five believe that bariatric surgery should not be funded for obese patients.

The survey of 521 GPs, conducted by the research division of Pulse's publishers, Cogora, also found that more than half of GPs believed people should be charged for using A&E for excessive alcohol consumption, while two-thirds felt that missed appointments should be charged.

Cogora’s Primary Concerns 2015 report - which, in total, surveyed nearly 1,000 health professionals, including commissioners and nurses - found there was little support for alternative medicines, such as homeopathy, chiropracty and osteopathy. 

It comes as the NHS faces its biggest financial problems for years, which has seen commissioners tasked with saving £22bn over the next five years by NHS England and the Government.

A Pulse investigation has already revealed that CCGs across the country are embarking on rationing drives, including targeting funding for vasectomies, hearing aids and IVF,despite NICE stepping in to reprimand CCGs.

Meanwhile, some commissioners are increasing the thresholds for bariatric surgery in defiance of NICE guidelines.

NICE’s most recent guidelines, published in 2014, recommended a lowering in the threshold for referral for bariatric surgery to a BMI of 30 kg/m2 for patients newly diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, or to appropriately lower BMIs in black or ethnic minority patients in line with separate public health guidance.

A significant number of GPs have given their support to IVF treatment being stopped on the NHS, with 34% calling for commissioners to withdraw funding, compared with 26% of the 291 nurses surveyed.

One female GP, who did not wish to be named, said: ‘It is very complex, but personally I don’t think infertility is a disease. I appreciate for some people it is and it’s very stressful. But it concerns me that people feel that having a child is a right.’

One in five GPs - 21% - said they believed that funding should be stopped for bariatric surgery for obese patients.

Dr Ahmed Nana, a GP in Leicester told Pulse: ‘In these times, where we’re basically rationing our resources you have to decide what we put money into. And the way funding is at the moment larger resources should go to areas like cancer care and heart disease, rather than bariatric surgery.

‘Clinically it has benefits as an intervention, but at present certain things we might have to stop providing because the NHS can’t afford them at present.’

But Dr Andrew Green, chair of the GPC’s prescribing committee, said: 'When there is pressure on what you might call basic services, it’s fairly understandable that people look to things that aren’t life or limb and think “well that should be cut”.

’But the evidence to improvement to individuals from bariatric of surgery is quite substantial, we do many things that are less effective than bariatric surgery.’

On the issue of IVF, he added: 'If you look at the unhappiness, distress and indeed depression that can come from having difficulty starting families, it is difficult to say they should not receive treatment.’

Read the full survey here

Readers' comments (45)

  • Survival of the fittest and take responsibility for your own actions are two principles that will surface at some point.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Secure environments GP

    Frankly appalling notion. These GPs clearly have children already then. I could rant about this but I'm not going to this time!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Devils' advocate: If you cannot afford IVF should you have children? I think that everyone has the right to become a parent by the way.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 100% with you there Dr Barrett. I have children and wouldn't want to deprive any couple of that experience which quite frankly for me (not for all) makes life truly worth living.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • You might think that everyone has a right to be a parent, but in that case they have a right to spend their own money on it. What they do not have is a right to spend MY money on their "right".

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Everybody should have a right to a foreign holiday every year paid by the state. It is quite distressing not to be able to afford one

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Unless there is an iatrogenic cause for the infertility, it should be paid for.
    In general terms one can apply the laws of nature. There is a reason for the non- fertility between couples.
    Surely this is the highest form of genetic modification!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There is no right to have children, but if there is a desire - then they should pay for the privilege themselves - and save up for it, and sacrifice other things.

    I have no flash car or exotic holidays etc, but have chosen to have children who are worth the sacrifice.

    Bariatric surgery is wrongly criticised as spending now will reap huge cost saving in reduced complications, and drug spend in the future where it works successfully - and the key here is to only choose motivated patients.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • All clinicians have a right to exercise their clinical judgement but that should not extend to an erroneous right to judge the patients they treat.

    Purely from an economic perspective smokers and drinkers enhance the coffers of the Chancellor and so should actually be given enhanced priority within the NHS, and so to the obese because of increased risk of early death.

    Considering IVF, why should it be denied upon principle and infertility as a matter of choice rather than of an underlying pathology. To the best of my knowledge I have never seen a health campaign explaining to the public, how fertility drops off line a stone from the age of 35 years of a woman.

    We as clinicians are no different from the people we treat and to forget that is a fundamental mistake.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • NHS should not pay for any infertility investigation or treatment.
    Nor should it pay for any form of gender identity problem.
    I will think of a few more in the course of my morning surgery

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say