Cookie policy notice

By continuing to use this site you agree to our cookies policy below:
Since 26 May 2011, the law now states that cookies on websites can ony be used with your specific consent. Cookies allow us to ensure that you enjoy the best browsing experience.

This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

GP leaders call for CQC inspections and NHS Choices to be scrapped to ease extreme pressure on practices

Exclusive GP leaders have called for CQC inspections to be halted and the NHS Choices website to be scrapped amid a range of measures to ease the pressure on the profession and stop GP practices closing in the short term.

Debating at a roundtable hosted by Pulse yesterday, a group of GP leaders - including GPC chair Dr Chaand Nagpaul, former RCGP chair Dr Claire Gerada and Tower Hamlets-based ‘Save Our Surgeries’ campaigner Dr Naomi Beer - called for an emergency package to mitigate unsustainable GP workloads and to stop GP morale from plummeting further.

Also attended by NHS England head of primary care commissioning Dr David Geddes and NHS Clinical Commissioners co-chair Dr Amanda Doyle, the debate saw demands for emergency funding for GP premises and pausing of QOF work, as Professor Gerada argued that general practice was currently ‘held together by sellotape’.

The roundtable was held as part of Pulse’s campaign to Stop Practice Closures, after an investigation revealed that more than 100 practices had contacted LMCs across the UK about plans for closing.

Dr Nagpaul listed a series of emergency measures to prevent practice closures, including: short-term investment in infrastructure, including both small premises upgrades and money to add support staff; campaign to manage patient demand and expectiations on general practice and; the Government revising its communications strategy to ensure announcements do not give patients a negative picture of general practice.

Professor Gerada said that a priority should be for GPs to do less of the ‘extraenous’ work, such as preparing for CQC inspections, and called on Dr Geddes to ‘ask CQC’ to temporarily halt inspections.

She added: ‘I think it was me who suggested when I was chair of RCGP, about pausing QOF for a year or so… I think we need a very sensible look at what we can stop doing now, which will free up some time.’

Professor Gerada said a more immediate measure to stem plummeting morale she said would be to ‘scrap NHS Choices’.

She said: ‘There is this continuous ranking up of this monitoring, regulating, cruel atmosphere - juxtaposed against how we should be more compassionate… We should remove this culture of fear, so I would ask you to remove NHS Choices, to remove that website because it is the heartache every day when you get a negative comment, I don’t even look at the positive ones anymore. It is hard-wiring cruelty into our system.’

Dr Nagpaul agreed, saying: ‘The NHS Choices patient feedback is reducing us into some sort of absurd commodity. The fact is it is not even representative. It is selective and not [sufficiently] monitored. I agree with Clare that I don’t see any value in having that website with patient feedback. You do have a patient survey which gives you information because at least that gives you a representative feedback.’

Meanwhile, Dr Beer said she would like NHS England to address a ‘lack of transparency’ and for area teams to do less ‘nitpicking’.

She said: ‘I think NHS England has to take part of the rap for not actually challenging ministers about the remit that they have been given and not actually defending primary care. That is my grassroot-GP opinion.’

Responding to the lists of requests from the roundtable members, Dr Geddes said: ‘These are some good suggestions but some of them are quite costly.

‘We don’t have the infrastructure to be able to support primary care in doing things fundamentally differently at the moment so we need to work with our co-commissioning colleagues, with the GPC, looking at where those issues are which are burning general practice and need to be done differently.’

Readers' comments (7)

  • "Professor Gerada argued that general practice was currently ‘held together by sellotape’."

    I'd agree with Dr Gerada on this one. And unfortunately it's not even branded Sellotape, it's the stuff from Poundland.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Fat chance. Dr Geddes, the govt, NHS England, all see the CQC, the bureaucracy, the stupidity and the cruelty as being the important things, they don't rate the front line as being important at all. You are peeing into the wind trying to persuade them,

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    You see
    As the representative of Ministry of Plenty , he is under the directive from Agent Hunt to at least 'show' that he is listening . Listening , listening and listening .........and then?
    Still listening. Such a gentleman........

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Our Leaders are to be applauded for these useful suggestions to start to save General Practice.
    Don't blame them if Government doesn't listen.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dr Nagpaul talks sensibly, but he is dealing with a cynical and evil adversary and all UK GP's seem to struggle with that.

    Until you realize that you will constantly bash your head against a wall

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "David Brownridge | Sessional/Locum GP | 15 October 2014 11:36am
    Our Leaders are to be applauded for these useful suggestions to start to save General Practice.
    Don't blame them if Government doesn't listen."

    I do blame them, they have always shied away from any firm action against the government bullying, and by the timid lack of action of the GPC and Gerada (one day announcing GPs should become salaried, the next day bemoaning the service that would result if all GPs were salaried), the politicos know they can behave with impunity towards GPs.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This comment has been moderated.

  • the cqc is a ploy by hunt to close down all gp practices as noone will pass

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say