This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Hospital trust closes 5,000-patient GP practice over recruitment issues

A hospital trust has been forced to close a 5,000-patient GP practice because of ‘significant difficulties’ recruiting GPs and an 'over-reliance' on locums.

Collingwood Medical Group, which will close from the end of November, forms part of Northumbria Primary Care, a wholly owned subsidiary of Northumbria NHS Foundation Trust.

The trust has taken over the running of seven practices since April 2015, with all GPs going salaried.

Collingwood Medical Group has around 4,700 patients in Blyth, Northumberland and notified patients in June that they should register with neighbouring practices.

Northumbria Primary Care managing director Julie Danskin told Pulse: ‘Over the past three years the practice team at Collingwood Medical Group has faced significant difficulties with regard to a number of issues, most notably in recruitment.

‘The resulting over-reliance on locums has meant we haven’t been able to guarantee patients continuity from their doctor – which a high proportion need and which we feel everyone deserves.’

She added that over the course of three years, ‘no stone has been left unturned’ in an attempt to make the practice sustainable, but she said the efforts ‘have not been successful [and] we have been forced to give notice to terminate the contract’. 

Siobhan Brown, chief operating officer at NHS Northumberland CCG, said: 'After carefully considering all available options, the CCG reluctantly decided that the practice will close permanently. All patients have been informed and asked to register with alternative practices over the coming months.

She added: 'Clearly the joint health, safety and well-being of all Northumberland residents is always our number one priority, as is the ability to access the best healthcare as close to home as possible.' 

This comes after Northumbria Primary Care claimed in 2016 that every GP who went to work for the trust was meeting patient demand more effectively than before the practices were taken over.

Dr Jane Lothian, medical secretary at Northumberland LMC, told Pulse: ‘The LMC has had a concern about the stresses placed on all of the clinicians for some time and all parties have tried very hard to solve the situation.’

She added that practice closure is ‘sometimes the only way’, adding: ‘The LMC regrets what’s happened and is trying to support all parties.’

Earlier this week, Pulse revealed Dr Arvind Madan, NHS England director of primary care, had made comments suggesting GPs should be pleased when small practices close.

However, Dr Lothian said she believes the closure of Collingwood Medical Centre, as part of a larger practice, is not evidence against working at scale.

She said: ‘The Collingwood situation is just another demonstration of the extreme pressures that primary care is under.’

But she added: ‘Northumberland as a whole is very disappointed that he [Dr Madan] takes that position because we support our practices, small and large, and believe there’s a place for them all.’

Readers' comments (5)

  • Would never ever work for a large conglomerate or a trust as salaried to be bullied by the Madans of this world.Locum all the way any hint of bullying or unfair treatment tell them where to stick it.They fail to grasp this is a market they cannot control a market.Market forces control the market supply/demand you cannot control that with sound bite and policy.This is especially true in a socialist based system that is is a country which is internationally unattractive to medical immigrant or not.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I suspect they closed as they couldn’t turn a profit. These organisations are not in it to provide a service to their community but to turn a profit so will shut it down without a second thought.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Perhaps we need to extend the article to talk about recruiting. I believe we are now 6000 under target. Until that is addressed (or rather addressing the pitiful conditions for GPs which undermines recruiting) then we are still getting nowhere... Dr Madan needs to speak out about a diagnosis and not a symptomatic intervention. OBE looming large? I think the GMC expects us to discharge our duty of candour in all of our work.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Who the hell would want to work in a practice run by and to the rules of an NHS trust?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 'Who the hell would want to work in a practice run by and to the rules of an NHS trust?'

    Lol agreed. 'Sorry did we forget to pay you again? Did we pay you less than usual? What's that - no I don't know why our mistakes only lead to you being paid less and never more - besides payroll is closed until next month now. Yes you may have to get a loan, try Dwolla....'

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say