Cookie policy notice

By continuing to use this site you agree to our cookies policy below:
Since 26 May 2011, the law now states that cookies on websites can ony be used with your specific consent. Cookies allow us to ensure that you enjoy the best browsing experience.

This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Primary care commissioning is 'a mess' admits NHS England director

NHS England is making a ‘mess’ of commissioning primary care and needs the expertise of CCGs which are much closer to practices, a top NHS manager has admitted.

NHS England medical director Dr Mike Bewick told a group of GPs yesterday that local area teams were too ‘far away’ from practices and that co-commissioning with CCGs was the way forward.

Speaking at one of NHS England’s ‘Call to Action’ events, hosted yesterday by Newham CCG and the London area team, Dr Bewick said that more sustainable models of primary care were needed.

He said: ‘The last point I want to make […] is about commissioning of primary care. It is a mess, to be prompt with you. It was a mess beforehand when there were 152 PCTs, and it is a mess now with 27 [area teams] - mainly because they are so far away from you, the area teams, so it is impossible for them. We have become yet again a contracting organisation and not a commissioning organisation.’

He added: ‘I think we can change that by utilising the expertise that we have in CCGs, who know the practices, their membership organisations. And with the health and wellbeing boards, who know your populations - or should know your populations, I should say - and looking for models that actually are sustainable across the system.’

‘So I am trying to argue for a level of co-commissioning across primary care, that will probably be for co-commissioning out-of-hospital care and working with other partners.’

The comments come after a survey found over 40% of CCG leads believe NHS England does not share their vision for primary care.

Speaking to Pulse after the meeting, Dr Bewick said that he had been trying to make the point - made by himself and other leaders at NHS England - that CCGs should commission primary care jointly with area teams.

He said: ‘The reason I said it is a mess is because I think people don’t really know where we are going to be commissioning this transformed primary care from. To try and get some semblance of that we have got to connect the commissioning across the systems, from direct commissioners along with CCGs. Because CCGs, as you know, has that responsibility, and therefore the budgets, to improve quality. So that we use some of that money more innovatively than we do today.’

Dr Bewick’s comments are the strongest yet suggesting that NHS England will act on a call from NHS Alliance chair Dr Mike Dixon for CCGs to be more involved in commissioning primary care.

But he will face opposition from the BMA, who have said that it would result in conflicts of interest and mean GPs in CCGs would have to performance-manage their own contracts.

NHS England chair Professor Malcolm Grant said in October that the obstacle of conflicts could be overcome, and Dr Bewick in September, when he said it could be solved by having more lay people on CCG boards.

Readers' comments (10)

  • Arses and elbows, laugh or cry........................

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • David Wrigley

    Astonishing admission from someone so senior. Obviously this is the situation we all knew was happening - we just never had it confirmed from the top.
    Maybe they should try using some of the £3bn NHS surplus to fund healthcare rather than diverting it back to the black hole that is the Treasury..

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    One can argue without new funding injected into the system, whoever is commissiong primary care will bump into walls time to time. Yesterday news about £5 per patient for caring elderly patients around the clock is a good example. CCGs will have to cut the secondary care budget to find this money.
    I think he would be more appreciated by saying 'the government is a mess ' instead........

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "The reason I said it is a mess is because I think people don’t really know where we are going to be commissioning this transformed primary care from"

    Hmmmmm.....not from where they currently commission primary care??????

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Anyone who came into commissioning at the advent of CCGs must wonder what the hell they have got themselves into. A dog's dinner seems like a well oiled machine in comparison. It is so so frustrating given the CCGs are making a difference but could have done a lot more if PCTs hadn't been cast to the 4 winds with disparate, ineffective organisations trying to commission in addition to CCGs. The government needs to trust CCGs to get on with the job, that includes commissioning primary care.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Area teams are full of PCT primary care contracting staff. Is the problem a lack of expertise or is it a lack of resource, compounded by area team directors being the only group not to come from a primary care background...?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • CCG's are not meant to succeed . Soon the private sector can step in and make it all better.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It was always a plan to try to divide and conquer. Brilliant MPs win again !!!.
    Patient care was never an issue.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Area teams full of PCT primary care contracting staff? Not in my local AT (north of Watford). The "transition" involved all the experienced primary care contracting staff being made redundant or "matched" into jobs they would not otherwise applied for. Not surprised that it is a mess.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It is a mess ,meant to b a mess so can privatise . Time to go to Australia

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say