This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

More than half of community hospital beds to be lost under NHS plans

More than half of community hospital beds in East Devon could be closed under proposals published by NHS North, East and West Devon CCG.

A consultation proposes scrapping 54% of beds in East Devon to bring provision 'in line with the rest of NEW Devon'.

But GP leaders said this could mean 'acutely unwell' patients having to rely on already over-stretched GP services instead.

The proposals stem from the Wider Devon's sustainability and transformation plan (STP) - the blueprints for the future of the NHS currently being designed across England - which says closing community hospitals will ‘facilitate implementation of the care model and release funding to invest in more ambulatory care provision in community and home-based settings’.

The NHS NEW Devon CCG area currently has 143 beds in eight community hospitals, but under the STP proposals, only 71 beds will remain open across three hospitals.

As it stands, the CCG is currently facing a financial shortfall of £122m in 2015/16, projected to rise to £384m in 2020/21, according to the consultation document.

But the CCG said the closures would save between £2.8m and £5.6m a year, after an additional investment of £1.4m is made in community services.

As previously reported by Pulse, a similar consultation is underway in NHS South Devon and Torbay CCG, which proposes to close four community hospitals.

Dr Bruce Hughes, chair of Devon LMC, said fewer beds could mean more ‘acutely unwell’ patients will being treated in the community with the medical cover falling on GPs to deliver - ‘potentially overwhelming services which are already stretched due to high demand and a lack of investment’.

He said: ‘There needs to be greater recognition of the pressures faced by our GP practices and the impact that transforming the wider local healthcare system has on them – backed by resources.

‘This will help to ensure that local general practice is sustainable in the future so patients receive treatment, care and support relevant to their needs.’

But Dr David Jenner, a GP and chairman of the Eastern locality for the CCG, defended the proposals saying: ‘Bed-based care will always be available for people who need to be in a hospital but we need to make sure the alternative of home-based care is always considered.

‘Too many people are currently in hospitals that don’t need to be there and they could be receiving a better service at home.’

Angela Pedder, the STP lead for Wider Devon, said: ‘We recognise the changes we are proposing will prompt difficult debate but we firmly believe the options in the consultation represent a real opportunity for us to improve care.’

The NEW Devon CCG consultation will run until 6 January 2017.

What are STPs?

At the start of this year, NHS England tasked regional teams, CCGs, trusts and local authorities to write 'sustainability and transformation' plans outlining how the NHS Five Year Forward View would be put into action.

Pulse's scrutiny of the 44 STPs being worked up have previously revealed how:

  • GPs in one region of England may have to shoulder an increasing burden of patient care  following the merger of two acute care trusts in Nottinghamshire;
  • In Dorset, a plan for the sustainability of the local NHS suggests that a current 98 GP practices, operating at 135 sites, 'will over-stretch' local 'workforce and finances'. It suggests that a 'reduction in the number of sites' would lead to a better provision of services 'for more hours of the day and days of the week';
  • In Hampshire and Isle of Wight, a reduction in GP workload by almost a third is sought, while also significantly reducing patients' face-to-face contact with primary care.
  • In North London, practices with list sizes under 10,000 patients could face closure amid moves to create primary care 'hubs’ with lists of 30,000.

Pulse also revealed that GPs have been left largely in the dark throughout the first six months of the planning process but NHS England said it would not approve any plan that does not support general practice.

NHS England previously said plans will be finalised then published in full by October, but to date only a handful of STP areas have actually published theirs.

Readers' comments (20)

  • I will never understand this. Surely we need to improve and strengthen these hospitals. I do not believe that the alternatives that they fund be will equal to that of a good community hospital and will end up causing more trouble for the acute sector.I am happy to be proven wrong.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am sure this is one of Jezzas savings to get all community hospitals closed down.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "Dr David Jenner, a GP and chairman of the Eastern locality for the CCG, defended the proposals"

    So stop whingeing you Pulse readers, it is GPs that are making these cuts. Let that sink in. A CCG run by GPs is cutting the community hospitals and a named GP is defending the cuts. Dr Jenner had the option to say something like "we hate these cuts and it will be bad but what choice have we got if the money isn't there?" But instead he chose to defend the cuts.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The cuts in the NHS are can not be defended,but those with vested interests have chosen there side and its tend to be to defend government policy.CCG have always been to provide a patsy to blame when the Tories enact their agenda on the NHS,nothing more nothing less.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Same thing proposed in Derbyshire.
    Some are old but this idea that they are not needed??
    Generations of doctors and NHS managers have got it wrong about the benefits of community hospitals?
    Some new piece of research saying they are not needed?
    That fewer patients are getting old and frail and don't need rehab?
    The health service may save money as patients are inappropriately discharged Into Nursing Homes to fester rather than getting the rehab they need, or in appropriately home before they can cope but a bigger bill will be picked up by others, and GPs will pick up the workload without recompense.
    And yes, some GPs in CCGs will bizarrely support this. Shame.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We all are defending the indefensible. Daily.

    Every day we come to work and pretend that this busted flush of a public system is capable of delivering the world class care we all believe in for a price that none of us do.

    His hypocrisy is at least brash enough to be explicit. Ours is covert, implicit and relentless.

    If you want to point the finger at his foolishness, please, acknowledge that we are all in denial, deception and depravity.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Mr Hunt, the Tories, NHS England and the whole NHS Commissioning function should be consigned to the Dustbin of History. The Tories are in love with the USA model of healthcare and the Commissioning function costs the taxpayer 15-30% of the NHS budget up from the 5% it used to be before all this commissioning nonsense was introduced by the Tories in 1990. Judging by the 1974 reforms, you should never allow any politician or any private firm anywhere near the NHS because they will cost you more than you can afford.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This is based on the ideology of saving money by keeping people at home.

    It is untested and unproven and when it is realised that it does not work it will be too late to resurrect the community hospitals.

    The Tories are mad.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • When people run in circles it's a very very, Mad World.

    With apologies to Gary Jules.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • In terms of savings thins looks like ****ing in the wind. And it won't fall to GPS but to A&E and acute hospitals. This on the same day as reports of a 30% increase in bed blocking.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say