GPs continue to be offered 'questionable' incentives to reduce cancer referrals
Exclusive CCGs are continuing to financially incentivise GPs to reduce urgent cancer referrals despite being told not to by NHS bosses, Pulse can reveal.
NHS Lambeth CCG has reviewed its incentives scheme, however upon finding that the number of two-week cancer referrals had increased in the first six months of 2015/16, it decided it would not make any mid-year changes.
NHS North East Lincolnshire CCG told Pulse that it has neither conducted a review nor changed its scheme.
The Lambeth referral scheme offers payments for practices moving towards the average 2014/15 CCG referral rate per 1,000 patients.
And the CCG told Pulse that urgent care and two-week cancer referrals ‘cannot be separated’ from the overall numbers.
An NHS Lambeth CCG spokesperson said: ‘In light of recent publicity, it became apparent that the objectives of our work on referral practice may have been misinterpreted. Therefore the CCG took the decision to review the scheme.
‘The outcome of this review showed that between April and September 2015, our two week pathway for cancer referrals had increased by 13% compared to the same period last year. Therefore we are not proposing any in-year changes to the scheme.’
The spokesperson added that the CCG ‘wants to, and continues to, actively promote good referral practice’.
In North East Lincolnshire, an average practice currently receives an incentive of over £6,000 for reducing outpatient referrals to the same level as the 25% of practices with lowest rates in the previous financial year. It includes two-week wait and urgent referrals but excludes a GP referring directly for an emergency admission.
The CCG said the scheme ’has not changed the scheme however it has reviewed various concerns raised following the article by Pulse about the potential for unintended adverse impacts’ and that ’concerns raised in and following the article would be taken into account when taking decisions on any future incentive schemes’.
Dr Peter Melton, CCG clinical lead, confirmed the scheme had been discussed thoroughly with clinical, lay colleagues and other stakeholders.
’The result of that review has been that we have been able to provide assurance that those concerns are not being seen in practice within North East Lincolnshire.’
An NHS England spokesperson declined to say whether they had investigated the schemes further, and repeated an earlier statement saying: ’NICE has set out evidence-based guidelines for when patients should be referred, and no CCG incentive scheme should in anyway cut across that.
’We have contacted each of the CCGs mentioned to ensure this has been clearly communicated to all practices and will continue to monitor the situation.’
Pulse’s findings, published in September last year, included at least nine CCGs which were offering practices payments to cut referrals.
Although the GPC said many of the schemes could be ‘ethically questionable’, NHS England specifically said CCGs would be told to ensure that their incentives scheme did not affect cancer referrals.
It comes as Government policy is to actively encourage patients to access early investigation to improve cancer survival rates, as these are currently lagging behind other countries.
NICE has slashed referral thresholds this year hoping to boost early diagnosis and the Government’s ‘be clear on cancer’ campaigns have been shown to significantly increase the number of patients seeking GP advice.