This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

GPs face increasing restrictions as NHS rations care to save money

Exclusive GPs face increasingly tighter restrictions on their ability to refer for specialist care, reveals an investigation by Pulse into plans drawn up by the most cash-strapped CCGs in the country.

The investigation reveals that CCGs are introducing policies that cap surgical referrals, require overweight patients to go a on a ‘weight loss programmes’ before an operation and deny hard-of-hearing patients hearing aids and audiological care.

The investigation comes as GPs say they are finding it harder to refer for surgical treatment of conditions like ganglions or carpal tunnel and, in one area, requests for hysterectomies are simply being ‘fobbed off with a Mirena coil’.

More than a third (36%) of GPs told Pulse they are facing new constraints on services to which they were previously able to refer.

The investigation comes as the health service prepares to implement £22bn of efficiency savings by 2020. But only two years after coming into existence, 19 CCGs have been ordered by NHS England to devise emergency plans to cut their budget deficits. A Pulse analysis of their recovery plans reveals:

  • NHS Luton CCG says, ‘when appropriate, patients must stop smoking and/or undergo a weight loss programme’ before certain elective procedures.
  • NHS North Staffordshire CCG said hearing aids will no longer be routinely provided for patient diagnosed with a mild hearing loss. Campaigners from Action on Hearing Loss labelled the decision ‘cruel’
  • NHS Great Yarmouth and Waveney CCG demands that smokers give up, and obese people lose weight prior to hip and knee replacement therapy and this could be ‘rolled out to other surgical procedures’.
  • NHS Basildon and Brentwood CCG has capped the numbers of vasectomy referrals that individual practices can make.
  • NHS North East Essex CCG has a £22m funding shortfall and has had to put in a range of restrictions on vasectomies, female sterilisation and spinal physiotherapy to save £1m.
  • NHS Mid Essex CCG has a ‘restriction policy’ for 2015/16 on services including acupuncture, facet joint injections and hip and knee operations.

NHS North East Essex CCG chair Dr Gary Sweeney explained: ‘We have no choice other than to stay within budget. If we do not implement these decisions we will have to select other services to restrict.’

Austerity NHS: What are GPs saying?

‘Women needing a hysterectomy are being fobbed off with a Mirena coil.’

GP in Hampshire

‘Referrals are downgraded regularly and we are increasingly scrutinised to ensure ‘appropriate’ referrals

GP in Neath

‘We have seen a rise in follow-up waiting times with patients being told by their consultant they’ll be seen in x months, but it’s increasingly quite unrealistic leading to patients making unnecessary appointments with GPs because they’ve not heard anything.’

Dr Richard Vautrey, GPC deputy chair

‘A grossly obese woman (BMI 60) had a request for lifesaving bariatric surgery refused, meaning further hoops, hurdles and delays.’

Dr Chris Nevill, Powys

Click here to read the full investigation

NHS Alliance chair Dr Michael Dixon, agrees: ‘CCGs are caught between a rock and a hard place. They try to meet tough budgets and get vilified in the process.’

But Dr James Kingsland, president of the National Association of Primary Care, says that such moves are ‘unacceptable’. He said: ‘The idea of rationing necessary care in a service that is free at the point of use is just unacceptable. Any health commissioning body looking at rationing services need to question whether they are fit for purpose.’

GPC deputy chair Dr Richard Vautrey says the financial pressure is often hidden. He says: ‘Where patients may have waited three months, they now wait six – this sort of thing is difficult to measure. Until we get new funding into the NHS we will continue to come under financial pressure and it will get worse.’

Rationing survey results



















Readers' comments (26)

  • A sendie debate on copayments and insurance (like everywhere else in the world) anyone? Or do we just all sit like lemins and wait for this car crash to happen in slow motion?

    Total lack of leadership from government, colleges and one eyed failing socialist mantra from the BMA. This isn't sensible. The most disadvantaged get far better healthcare in other comparible countries and haven't copied the NHS model because it doesn't work.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • @4.47

    Could not agree more. Patients are suffering because of the NHS dogma of free at the point of use with no co-payment. This HAS to change.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • One more reason to privatise health care!!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Why do we have a complete split between NHS being free and private health 100% paid for by patients?

    Having a graduation between NHS and private care would allow more patients to receive treatment that is sadly unaffordable when they have to pay 100% of the cost of private health care. Just about everywhere else in the world people can do this

    People can top up social care in the UK so why not NHS health care?

    I can see this happening in the future, perhaps Manchester maybe the first

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Allow GPs to register with HMRC like plumbers and electricians if they have full registration with GMC and let them see patients privately, do home visits if they wish to, have independent agreements with insurance etc and see the scenario change. No bureaucratic meddling of CQCs etc.
    In most European countries this works smoothly but does UK have to always have some parasitic organization squeezing NHS professionals. Plumbers and electricians don't have that sort of pressure.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It is bad now. Wait till the £22 billion cuts start to bite.

    Copayment has to come, including primary care copayment.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Once GPs receive a copayment per consultation access problems will disappear overnight.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Nothing Hunt likes more than to see Co-payment gradually gaining acceptability. You are playing into his hands.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • the NHS was never designed to be free at point of use. it was free at point of need. Patients often have too high expectations leading to inappropriate referrals, leading to them clogging up the system and delaying patients in genuine need.

    Can't really blame them though when the Government continuously stokes demand advising the UK and the world that they should be entitled to get what they want when they want it where they want it how they want it no matter the reason the want it.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I saw an Australian patient yesterday. Ended up charging him £95 for consultation and private script as it was not immediately necessary. He didn't even bat an eyelid and after I apologised for having to charge him (it felt so wrong to me), he proceeded to tell me that he was happy to pay for the diligent service I had given him and that was the price to pay for being seen by a for thought

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say