This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

11 hospitals placed under 'special measures' after mortality review

The health secretary has instigated special measures in 11 hospitals in England, after an NHS report uncovered ‘fundamental breaches of care’ such as poor governance, inadequate staffing levels and high mortality rates at weekends.

Health secretary Jeremy Hunt, speaking in the House of Commons today, said that he was determined to ‘root out’ bad care in the NHS and told MPs that problems identified in the report in out-of-hours care would be remedied with his proposed changes to the GP contract.

Sir Bruce Keogh, the NHS medical director, conducted a series of ‘deep-dive’ reviews into 14 hospitals with mortality rates which have been consistently high for two years or more.

The report listed several key failings, such as hospitals’ professional and geographic isolation, failure to act on data or information that showed cause for concern, the absence of a culture of openness, a lack of willingness to learn from mistakes and ineffectual governance and assurance processes. The review team instigated special measures in 11 of the 14 hospitals.

But it found that overall mortality in all NHS hospitals had fallen by about 30% over the past 10 years, and despite higher mortality rates in the 14 hospitals studied, their rate of improvement was similar to other NHS hospitals.

The report concluded: ‘Understanding the causes of high mortality is not usually about finding a rogue surgeon or problems in a single surgical speciality. It is more likely to be found in the combination of problems that to a differing extent are experienced by all hospitals in the NHS: busy A&E departments and wards, the treatment of the elderly in and out of hospital, and the need to recruit and retain excellent staff.

‘Such issues are complex and require a “whole system” approach to deal with them. This is why it has been so important that this review has involved all the key players the NHS system to decide what to do to address problems, and agree who is responsible for implementing agreed improvements.’

Pulse revealed last year that one GP in seven regarded a local hospital department as ‘dangerously substandard’, with evidence that in a significant minority of hospitals patients are dying because of failings in care.

Health secretary Jeremy Hunt, speaking in the House of Commons today, said he was determined to tackle bad care in the NHS ‘head on’ and that the 11 hospitals in special measures would have to improve within a year.

He said: ‘We owe it to the three million people who use the NHS every week to tackle and confront abuse, incompetence and weak leadership head on.’

He also told MPs that problems identified in the report in out-of-hours care would be remedied with his proposed changes to the GP contract.

In response to Cheryl Gillen, Conservative MP for Chesham and Amersham, who highlighted the report’s findings of delays accessing medical advice out of hours, Mr Hunt said: ‘In Buckinghamshire, there were some serious problems identified with out-of-hours care and also dementia patients.

‘These are often people who need help and support out of hours, which is why I raised the difficult issue of the GP contract because there have been some issues of out-of-hours care.

‘We need to have more joined-up care in the community. It’s also why the chancellor announced a further £2.8bn going into joint commissioning arrangements between local authorities and health care. Put those two together what I hope we will get is vastly improved out-of-hours care for her constituents.’

Mr Hunt has previously said he will look to make changes to the GP contract to give practitioners greater responsibility for the out-of-hours care for their patients. His most recent pronouncement suggested GPs will be ‘named clinicians’ for vulnerable patients, and will coordinate their out-of-hours care plans.


Readers' comments (8)

  • Is there a list?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Nigel Praities, Pulse editor

    The 11 hospitals are: North Cumbria University Hospitals NHS Trust, Northern Lincolnshire and Goole Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Tameside Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust, Basildon and Thurrock University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Burton Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust, George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust, Sherwood Forest Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Buckinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust, Medway NHS Foundation Trust. There is a link to the full reports into the trusts above.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Scroll down this page for the list:

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Tom Caldwell

    So to be clear has this been deemed the fault of the GPs yet?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Talk about narcissistic... this isn't always about you.

    These hospitals have had a very difficult time of it. Some of the criticisms may be deserved, certainly not all, and much is the fault of policy makers, cutting essential funding, squeezing more and more out of less and less, until they cracked at the seams. Sound familiar...?

    Instead we should be united in exposing this government's agenda to undermine every aspect of the NHS, presumably so that they can dismantle it completely after the next election and sell it off to their cronies in the private sector.

    Be careful we don't end up being complicit in this.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 13 million on the Francis report to say what ?
    That there was a gross shortage of staff who were depressed, demotivated and horribly demoralised.
    How can you judge such people who are working 2 to 3 times as hard as they should be, putting their own health and professional standing on the line, carrying the can for mistakes, only to be chastised for poor care. It is a case of multiple jeopardy.
    If the 13 million had been spent on proper staffing, you would not need this report.
    This is happening everywhere and can be cured instantly. Proper staff : patient ratios in everything from nursing, cleaning,ambulance,lab,doctors etc.
    You would never get a Mid - Staffs or other failures with proper funding and beds, I have worked in secondary and primary care for 35 years and 99.99% of staff work more than they are contracted or paid for. Failure has all to do with lack of simple arithmetic in the NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So GPs have to work 24 hours to sort this mess caused simply by lack of proper staffing/ beds. Germany has 80,Japan 100, UK 27 beds per 10000 patients.
    Lack of care is due to poor funding Mr. Hunt cause guess what care and compassion costs cash. If you are going to root out poor care you need proper staff ratios,
    GPs cannot solve that.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • At last SOME of Labour's NHS legacy has been exposed. There is MUCH worse to come.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say