This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Cancelling operations in winter 'will only make things worse', says GP MP

Cancelling non-urgent NHS work because of winter pressures will do more harm than good, a GP told parliament as MPs debated the winter crisis.

Dr Paul Williams, told fellow MPs in today's debate - which comes as hospitals are cancelling thousands of non-urgent operations and appointments this month - that he worked on the NHS frontline last week.

The Labour MP, who worked shifts in the GP extended access and urgent care centre in Stockton, north east England, told health minister Philip Dunne ’cancelling non urgent work will only make things worse’.

He called for an apology to patients whose conditions could be exacerbated by longer waits for treatment, after the shadow health secretary tabled an urgent question forcing a minister to answer MPs’ questions about the winter pressures.

It was the first time since the summer Dr Williams had worked as a doctor.

Mr Dunne apologised for patients who had endured long waits in hospital corridors, including those who were sitting on floors, as highlighted by Yorkshire MP Tracy Brabin.

The minister said: ’I apologise to those patients who are not treated as quickly as we would like them to…There are seats, … but I agree with it (sleeping on the floor) is not acceptable.’

However Mr Dunne, who took questions whilst health secretary Jeremy Hunt was at Downing Street for a reshuffle meeting, stressed that there were pressures in the NHS every winter. He said the Department of Health had started its planning much earlier than ever before.

He told MPs: 'We have have some kind of crisis every winter.'

He said deferring operations and setting up a national panel to plan this was 'a routine way of dealing with pressure that has come through the front doors'.

However shadow health secretary Jonathan Ashworth said: 'This is not planning for winter, it is more like a wing and a prayer.'

He described 'blanket cancellation of operations leaving people in pain, distress and discomfort'.

MPs described long waits for care in ambulances at hospitals at constituencies throughout the country, as well as praising staff for the care they were providing.

Mr Ashworth asked if trusts would be reimbursed for the cancelled operations and Mr Dunne responded that it was too early to say if they were deferred, rather than cancelled.

He told Mr Dunne: 'Patients don’t want perfection, they just want the NHS properly funded, properly staffed.'

Mr Dunne said DH was investing in more recruitment and had put aside money for winter pressures.

Former heath secretary Kenneth Clarke said the debate was almost an annual 'ritual' but highlighted the 'emergency availability of GP services'.

Mr Dunne said: 'The number of over 80s who are presenting in our hospitals thorough A&E are presenting exponentially ….. that’s why many hospitals are introducing frail elderly units.

'He’s right to point to the integration that’s necessary.'

Huw Merriman, Conservative MP for Bexhill and Battle, asked 'isn’t it time' for the state would step in and provide cover where 'very fine GP practices’ faced pressures if other practices were not well run or GPs were retiring.

Mr Dunne suggested this was the responsibility of CCGs.

Readers' comments (6)

  • Vinci Ho

    You see
    These second tier health minister(s) lack the qualities of duplicity and perfidy in our beloved Agent Hunt who must think he would become the second-to-none , record-breaking health secretary in the history of NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • It’s third world health care in what is rapidly becoming a second world country but without the ambition to improve

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Labour's fixation with a Health Service funded entirely out of taxation and only taxation is why we are in this current mess. Despite outcomes worse than our neighbours, all of whom seem to be able to raise money through additional insurance and co-payments without the world ending, Labour persist in demanding ever more money from taxation with no upper limit.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dr Stelvio you are absolutely right. everybody knows that. Main question is who is going to bell the cat? Nobody wants to commit political suicide. That's why we are in this mess. At least Tories are doing this in long winded way. But this will resolve only when the political parties come to some sort of agreement /understanding / accepting need to have additional source of money to fund NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    That is why I stand by the argument general practice in NHS should be driven by central ground politics and ideology , which had been wiped out completely by this historic circumstance dominated by two extreme polarities of populism.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Furthermore, insisting to stay on one extreme end or the other on the political spectrum will cease to attract young , deligent and capable candidates to join and stay in NHS general practice.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say