This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Seven in ten GPs would not take back out-of-hours 'at any price'

Exclusive Most GPs would not take back responsibility for out-of-hours care even if they were offered up to £20,000 per partner and had a guarantee they would not have to do the on-call shifts themselves, a Pulse survey reveals.

The survey of 400 GPs reveals the extent of the opposition in the profession to resuming any kind of responsibility for out-of-hours care, with 62% saying they would support the GPC in taking some form of industrial action if NHS England seeks to change the GP contract to do this.

The survey also found considerable opposition to RCGP proposals that the profession considers taking back responsibility for the out-of-hours care for the 5% of vulnerable patients on their lists – with 87% opposed to the idea.

Half of GPs said they would still reject taking back responsibility for overseeing the quality of OOH care for their patients, even if there was a guarantee they did not have to do on-call shifts themselves – 36% were in favour.

Some 69% of GPs said they would not take back responsibility for out-of-hours care ‘at any price’, although 23% said they would do so for £20,000 per partner annually and 5% said it would take £10,000 annually for them to change their minds.

The strength of the opposition is likely to prove problematic for the GPC, who have recently been hinting that they may agree to co-operatives of GPs resuming out-of-hours responsibility for patients.

The GPC recently dropped its opposition to RCGP proposals for GPs to resume responsibility for the 24/7 care of elderly patients or those with complex medical problems, after the college clarified the proposal would be for GPs working in federations or co-operatives to take collective responsibility.

The furore over out-of-hours care was sparked by health secretary Jeremy Hunt last month when he announced that he wanted GPs to be individually responsible for their patients around the clock and given a duty to ‘sign off’ out-of-hours care.

LMC leaders last month rejected the possibility of GPs taking personal responsibility for out-of-hours care at their annual conference, and grassroots GPs taking the Pulse survey went further, saying any kind of extra responsibility should be rejected.

Dr Mark Beecham, a GP in Maldon, Essex said: ‘Definitely not. It would be the thin end of the wedge.’

Another respondent Dr Thomas Bloch, a GP in Broadway, Worcestershire said this would mean practitioners getting the blame for problems: ‘This would be a recipe for disaster - we would get the blame for any shortcomings. This is the only reason the Government wants to be shot of it.”

Responding to the survey, Dr Mary Church, a GP in Blantyre, south Lanarkshire said: ‘This is an over my dead body issue.’

Dr Richard Vautrey, GPC deputy chair, said the survey showed that contractural changes were not required as CCGs now had responsibility for out-of-hours care.

He said: ‘GPs are fearful that this would place a contractual change upon their shoulders and those who say it´s the thin end of the wedge are right.

‘We need to be very careful about any attempt to increase the weight of responsibility on GPs and we don´t want to complicate commissioning arrangements via CCGs by doing so at a time when CCGs are just getting started.’

Dr Vautrey also said that ‘no-one is threatening’ industrial action. However, he added: ‘If the Government is mad enough to go down that road, industrial action would be the least of their worries. GPs would vote with their feet and leave the profession and then you´d have a crisis in in-hours care as well.’

In full: Results of GP survey on out-of-hours care 

Related images

  • out of hours september 08   3  N

Readers' comments (34)

  • One thing I learnt from last GPs strike is the fact that public would never care about GPs. They want us to work our socks off at the expense of our health and wellbeing for their convenience. And they want to squeeze us as much as they can for the price of a peanut. Nowadays, people only care about themselves and so should GPs. GPs need to look after their health and well being. Most people have not got a clue about how much time, energy and money we had to invest for so many years. They only see the pay which they think is a lot when it is not. It is high time GPs looked after themselves.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Anonymous | 17 June 2013 10:37am

    I totally agree that GPs need to look after their own health and well being (it is difficult to do a good job when you're exhausted and stressed).

    But don't forget that, in the current economic climate, patients are also working THEIR socks off at the expense of THEIR health and well being, often for a fraction of what a GP receives. Hence the reason at least some of them are turning up at the GP to begin with.

    The fact that the working public sees more and more of its money go to the government for precious little improvement in will make them more demanding of the services they DO receive - primary health care being one of them.

    That's just the way it's not the happiest of situations, and I agree that the public needs to try to be more understanding of health care providers in general, but that understanding is a two-way street, and blaming the patient doesn't do anybody any good.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • All the fuss is making my disillusionment complete after 35 years in Practice and retirement just round the corner (thank God!) So I wrote a poem!

    Even though the NHS could be more perfect
    it is not.
    So I sat and rested a while
    and wept.
    A broken physician
    in a fractured system.

    And before someone mentions the merits of Prozac it doesn't work!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • To the Dr about to embark on vocational training, I am newly qualified GP and have been a partner now for 2 yrs now. Although I love my job most of the time I just can't take much more of the daily mail bashing. I also hate the ever increasing paperwork. Looking back I did medicine for more than this and wish I had done a speciality such as genetics or dermatology. I do have GP friends that say conditions in Oz are great though. Good luck with whatever you choose.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say