This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Eight out of ten GPs want CQC inspections to stop

Eight in ten GPs want CQC inspections to stop until general practice is ‘adequately funded’ and an ‘evidence-based’ system can replace the current regime, a survey has found.

The survey, carried out by GP Survival member Dr Nigel Price, a GP in Wessex, has drawn 700 responses via an online form and email.

Prompted by the announced ‘seven-fold’ hike in CQC fees to practices, the survey showed that:

  • 80% of colleagues want CQC inspections to be abandoned until general practice is adequately funded and the current regime can be replaced with a an evidence-based system that would be free of charge;
  • 2% would be willing to continue with inspections if fees only went up in line with inflation;
  • 17% would be willing to continue with inspections if the Government fronted the CQC fee;
  • No one is happy with the increased CQC fees.

The CQC proposed in November to increase the fees for GP inspection by more than 550% within two years, translating to an increase of £15,000 for some practices.

GP Survival media lead Dr Zoe Norris said: ‘This survey of frontline GPs confirms the deep concern about the CQC inspection process. It takes GPs away from seeing the patients that need them, causes a ludicrous amount of administrative work, and lacks any evidence that it directly benefits patients or helps practices who are struggling.

’Instead of effectively being fined for the badly thought out implementation of this regime, GPs need it removed immediately and to be genuinely listened to on a practical and properly funded alternative.’

Question: Regarding CQC inspections in England which of the following actions would you support?

I am happy with current proposals for rising costs of inspection and am willing to pay the increased charges to be inspected annually - 0 (0%)

I would be willing ot continue with CQC inspections and paying fees in line with the current fee structure with no more than a Retail Price Index annual adjustment - 13 (1.86%)

Inspections should be a Government expense and I would be willing to continue with inspections as long as they are free of charge for GPs - 122 (17.43%)

CQC inspections should be abandoned forthwith and any future replacement system to be introduced free of charge to practices and only when adequate funding of primary care is achieved. Such process to be evidence-based and to involve practicing GPs in its formulation - 557 (79.57%)

Other (open-ended response) - 8 (1.14%)

Source: A survey of 700 GPs by GP Survival and Resilient GP

Readers' comments (8)

  • Scrap the CQC, GMV, RCGP, QOF, appraisal & revalidation or I'm leaving after graduation.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Well said!

    The GMC also needs to be completely changed and run by doctors elected by doctors for a fixed term and completely paid for by the Government.

    Indemnity in all the NHS needs to be paid for by the government.

    Would this also help??? I am sure it would help other too....too late for me though!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I would advise the medical student to complete FY 1/2 jobs, then go. I wish you all the best.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • How would Chris Paddock get a gong then?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • For Hevens sake Scrap CQC for General Practice, QOF and annual appraisals to save the poor ,devalued,demoralised,despondent GP's in this country and Save General Practice

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • And perhaps 80% of doctors would have prefered not to sit medical finals. As much as we might resent the CQC, are people really suggesting we should have no regulation of quality at all? Our problem is that we are under-resourced so practices struggle to meet the standards of these inspections. What we should aim for is to achieve what is realistic rather than fanciful. But we should not have to fund the CQC. Shops don't pay a fee to trading standards or whatever quango has replaced it. Schools do not have to pay Ofsted and foundation trusts do not fund Monitor.
    If you don't like these inspections or paying for them ....ditch the contract comrades.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • During the past 15 years of my dealings with CQC I have found them very dictatorial to work with and felt demoralised with their bureaucracy and have wanted to change career. They do not add value to the health and social care sector!!!

    CQC should be demolished!!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dear "Anonymous | Practice Manager25 Jan 2016 0:32am"

    CQC were established in April 2009 (six years ago) and GPs regulation started in 2013 (almost 3 years now)

    Impressed tho that you have managed to hate them for 15 years! Shows the mentality of many people just criticising for the sake of it

    The problem is ignorance

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say