This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

New-look CQC inspections won’t be ‘witch hunt’, Field insists

Exclusive A revamped CQC inspection regime will not be ‘punitive’, will not force practices to open seven days a week and is likely to identify only a ‘tiny’ proportion of practices who need to make major improvements, the new chief inspector of general practice has told Pulse.

In an exclusive interview on the first day of his new role, Professor Steve Field sought to allay GPs’ fears, setting out details of more targeted inspections and claiming he hoped to be an ‘advocate’ of the profession who would raise concerns about resources and workforce.

Professor Field contradicted reports based on his interview with the Guardian at the weekend in which he was quoted as claiming as many as one in ten GP practices could require major improvements. He said this estimate was based on the CQC’s first 287 inspection visits at practices which had for the most part already declared non-compliance with one or more CQC standards.

‘The message that 10% of practices have major problems is wrong,’ he said. ‘I believe that overall the proportion of practices which have big issues is very small.’

‘I honestly believe that there is only a tiny, tiny percentage of practices which are unacceptable.’

Professor Field also moved to reassure GPs over the prospect of the CQC for the first time assessing practices on access. He said that while he supported the move towards seven-day working, practices would not face action over failing to provide extended hours  - a service he admitted his own practice in Birmingham was currently unable to offer.

The CQC would only take action over access in extreme cases, he said: ‘The sort of thing which will really worry us will be if lots of patients are saying that they’re turned away from their GP. Or if we read significant events or court cases of children who’ve been abused or killed, and there’s a history of GPs turning patients away.’

‘I wouldn’t personally expect your average practice to be working longer hours and seven days without working in partnership with other practices, unless they want to,’ he added.

‘I support the move towards seven day working, but practices like ours can’t provide that at the moment, we’re not resourced for that at the moment, and we would need to work with other practices.’

Professor Field also detailed the CQC’s new inspection regime for GPs, which will come into effect next April and was first outlined in the regulator’s ‘A New Start’ consultation earlier this summer.

The new strategy will see the CQC take a more targeted approach, where only a sample of practices where no specific concerns have been raised will be inspected.

‘If you take a CCG area, from April we will come and look at a CCG and we will sample a proportion of the practices in the CCG over a week or two,’ said Professor Field. ‘On a two-year rolling programme we might be back to that CCG area a few times but not check all practices in one go because we have to inspect the whole country. This will be our routine programme, going alongside targeted inspections where we are looking at specific problems.’

‘We are going to divide all CCGs into ten regions and in all ten regions we will do the same. We will look at a proportion of the practices.’

The regulator will also look at broader cross-cutting ‘themes’, such as out-of-hours care, access to IAPT and medication in care homes. CCGs will then be expected to raise standards over the two-year inspection period based on findings.

Professor Field said under the new scheme inspections of practices were likely to last for a day, and be carried out by a team of three or four, which was likely to include a senior manager, a primary healthcare professional and a patient.

‘My plan is always to have a GP [as part of the inspections team], if we can practically get it,’ he said.

‘We are not looking for punitive stuff, we are looking at real issues. Looking at the inspections to date some of the key things we found were issues about training for safeguarding, out-of-date drugs, people who had not recorded the temperatures of fridges that hold vaccines. That is a serious issue. We have been to surgeries without doors on their consulting rooms and found surgeries that are dirty, or have carpets in treatment rooms. Things which are not acceptable.’

‘My worry is that people are concerned that we are going on a witch hunt, but we are not at all. This is really basic stuff and practices which are losing their licenses have been warned on many occasions. One [practice] going through this at the moment was warned on seven occasions.’

He further stressed that, under him, the ideal process would be led by GPs at all levels.

He added: ‘We want an inspections system that is professionally led in the new system, which it isn’t at the moment. We want a new system where we want GPs to be engaged in and leading the visits.’

‘For me the big change will be more GP involvement and we are going to resource it heavily. I want a GP in each of the regions and we want to be advocates for practices.’

Professor Field also said he hoped to use his new high-profile role to champion general practice – and even help it fight for better support and resources.

‘I think increasingly we will be an advocate, because I believe that general practice is at the centre of everything we do, and whilst the focus in this first week in the newspapers has been around standards and stopping people from work, we want the best care possible.’

‘So I think you will find us making statements about resources, about contracts, about lack of workforce and the fact that perhaps Health Education England might need to think about for example improving the nurse training in primary care so that practices can deliver and perform on long-term conditions.’

‘For me the fundamental is I want the best general practice in the world. I think we have some of the best general practice in the world and I have travelled extensively looking at general practice, but it is not universally brilliant. It isn’t anywhere - but I want us to be the best.’

Readers' comments (18)

  • Dont trust him at all. I am so pleased I jumped early with VER this year. I found cancelling both my MDU and GMC membership a most liberating experience and would strongly recommend it to others who are able to leave.

    Young doctors should keep well away from GP or get the NHS to train them and then emigrate.

    Pay off your bills downsize and retire ASAP.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • im working flat out. the last five job ads have not got me any more doctors-not one serious application.. the pay is vaishing. the paperwork regularly takes 5 hours a day.If you shut me down none of the other surgeries (which cant recruit either) will be able to cope.

    visit planet earth prof field. the system is on the edge of total collapse

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • the daggers are out, GPs the scapegoats for the failure of the NHS, well done cameron/hunt you're nearly there!

    i've been working as a GP for just two years, looked forward to it for a fair portion of my life, but i'm off to australia next year. i'm very dissappointed in how things have turned out.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    While one cannot deny the importance to have an agency to check and ensure some standards are being sustained by GP practices, it is also a matter of what kind of government(politicians) the agency is working for . As the head of a agency , what would you say or do in face of a government which is betraying moral standards and playing dirty politics?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The very different messages to the public and the profession are a little concerning.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Peter Swinyard

    I assume that with a more targeted approach to inspections the cost of remaining registered with CQC will drop???
    PS - I also believe in the tooth fairy...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    'The structures fail you and the rules aren't weapons any more ; they become shackles and let the bad guys get ahead .' Jim Gordon , Dark Knight Rises(Christopher Nolan 2012)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This comment has been deleted by the moderator

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • But Prof Field said that 10% of practices would have to make changes. He is an excellent inspector, because without inspecting anything he knows how many will fail to meet the mark. If he could tell us in advance which 10% it is, we could all save a lot of time and money!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • There are some seriously poor performing GP practices that undermine support for general practice by politicians of all parties and the media. This prevent support for increased resourcing in primary care which affects all of us. In areas where there has been consistent determination to sort this problem, morale is higher and recruitment much easier.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say