This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pulse june2020 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

The waiting game

Dr Alex Harding: 'Lack of space is a big issue'

Dr Alex Harding discusses what lies behind the reduction in the amount of time medical students are spending in GP placements

At present we know that about 20% of medical students want to be GPs at the end of their training. We also know that to address workforce (and public) demands Health Education England has suggested that about 50% of medical students need to become GPs, so there is a job to do. 

We also know from work in America and Australia that placements have a powerful effect on students’ future career plans. Our survey of medical schools has found that at present the national average is for 14% of student placements at medical school to be in general practice. We also have found that these GP placements have been reducing over the past ten years or so.

The big question is why this is happening? What we can say from our survey is that lack of space to teach students in is a big issue for GPs. When students come to a GP practice they really want to see patients. This means that finding extra space for the students to talk to the patients becomes an issue. In our survey we couldn’t find much evidence of funding models to support this. 

We have also documented the large increase in teaching undertaken by GPs in the last 10 years. This includes the introduction of foundation training and the increases in postgraduate training. Quite apart from this there are the increases in GP workload. So there may be a squeeze effect that is relevant.

However, there may be other factors involved. We know that teaching methods have remained the same for a long period of time – maybe these need to adapt? We also know that some of the support mechanisms for GPs have changed. For example, the survey found that the number of university departments of general practice have reduced. 

These have traditionally been a source of support for some teaching GPs. As ever, the situation is complicated, but we hope that this survey has helped the debate a little.

Dr Alex Harding, is a GP and senior lecturer at the University of Exeter

Readers' comments (1)

  • Dear Dr Harding

    Maybe the problem starts at recruitment, not in the medical school curriculum and how much time is spent in GP.

    Watch your own university's medical school recruitment video.

    It twitters about Exeter becoming a member of the Russell Group, problem-based learning, etc.

    Maybe it should actually mention 'General Practice' and seek to recruit young people who have an interest in primary care?


    A concerned patient

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say