This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Returner scheme attracts 60 new GPs - but only two in areas with worst shortages

Exclusive The new scheme to tempt GPs back to practice has attracted 60 new GPs since March, although Pulse has learnt it has only attracted a single GP to each of the two areas in England with the highest vacancy rates for GP trainees.

Figures obtained by Pulse reveal that the North East of England and East Midlands - which still have 49% and 43% of GP training places vacant for this year’s intake - have only managed to attract a single GP returner each since the scheme was set up.

In comparison, London - which has only 2% of training places vacant - has attracted 18 GPs, while the rest of the South of England attracted 23 GPs.

The scheme, launched in March this year, was designed to alleviate the GP workforce crisis as part of Health Education England’s ten-point plan.

But GP leaders in the regions said that southern areas attracting GPs is ‘no comfort to the majority of us’.

The scheme was set up after RCGP said that as many as 5,000 GPs are prevented from returning to work because of ‘red tape’.

It was designed to reduce red tape by bringing in national standards for re-entry to general practice to replace the differing standards set by education bodies across England, and included a bursary of £2,300 a month for returners to undergo supervised placements with a practice and funding for practices to take on returners.

In his new deal speech, Jeremy Hunt highlighted more than 50 GPs had ‘already taken up the offer’ to return.

Mr Hunt said: ‘By working with the profession we will improve routes back to general practice for experienced doctors. An induction and “returner” scheme for those returning to the profession from overseas or from a career break has been refreshed and now includes support with the cost of returning to general practice. Over 50 GPs have already taken up this offer.’

Health Education England figures from July show that 60 GPs have registered with the scheme, of which 55 had sat the multiple choice entry test in June, and 45 of these had passed on to further assessments.

But Dr Peter Holden, a GP in Derbyshire and a former GP negotiator, said: ‘This is just one component in the whole business of workforce. But actually, 60 GPs is a drop in the ocean. The fact that it’s all biased to London, the south west and the south coast is of no comfort to the majority of us.’

Speaking to Pulse, Dr Krishna Kasaraneni, chair of the GPC’s education, training and workforce committee, welcomed the scheme and especially the introduction of national standards, but added that it is unlikely to help attract GPs to the worst-affected areas.

He said: ‘If it’s a GP from London with a family, kids, so on and so forth, saying “do you want to come back to be a GP? Please do it in Scunthorpe” - it’s not going to happen. So you’re adding them to the total number of doctors, rather than under doctored areas.’

Where GPs are returning


East Midlands 1

East of England 7

West Midlands 3

Kent Sussex and Surrey 6

London (inc 3 areas) 18

North West 4

North of England 1

Thames Valley 5

South West 7

Wessex 5

Yorkshire and Humber 3

Readers' comments (23)

  • I'm getting confused.
    There used to be a Retainer scheme, whereby GPs could reduce their hours to a couple of sessions a week and keep up to date when taking a career break.
    This was abolished as being solely for the benefit of practices and the retainees - so something the NHS should not support.
    Now there is a replacement - but only for Returnees: are there any provisions for retaining GPs?

    btw I agree that this program appears to be more about image than reality ..

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Like someone said General Practice is the anal canal of the NHS and GPs are coprophiliacs

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Remind me how GPs many JH have promised again?

    Oh well, he's managed to fulfill 1.2% of his promise now.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • great.

    only another 9940 needed.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • need another as i am off - resignation letter done today

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am on the Jersey performers list and want to come back but can not because of the MCQ. my score after working for 33 years in the NHS means that I need to have 3 months extra training to learn how to cope with the NHS. I am appraised via Wessex, and practice exactly the same way as in uk, except the funding is different as patients pay for their tx and the states makes up half of the cost and we have 15 mins consultations. I need to learn what exactly. the I and R scheme is a bar to recruiting GP's and the bar needs to be lowered. also if you are Welsh you can not come back either, what an insult to the Welsh GP's as they are second class GP's?!!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Peter Swinyard

    I have just looked at the specification for the MCQ test. I wonder how many of us established GP principals would pass this without being told we had a development need?
    Has it been tried on the crusties (GPs age 50-65)?
    Dare you?
    We'd all have to quit!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Have you got a link for the mcq test ?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • You simply couldn't afford to pay me what I'm worth to return to the uk.
    Anyway some things are more important, such as self worth, control of your own destiny and being able to actually do the job you love. None of which are possible in England. It's lucky NHSE are actually a bunch of cheap skates because if they did have a serious budget to recruit they'd probably manage to blackmail folk with cash and continue to run a tyrannical regime.

    The mentality of these autocrats is much more of a determining factor in keeping me abroad. Not to mention the entitled behaviour of an ungrateful brainwashed public over there in the uk.

    You can keep your pennies! I'm away making a real life for myself far far far beyond your control! Good riddance

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • to be fair - i didn't think they would get anyone !

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say