This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Indemnity provider announces ‘price freeze’ for GPs

A ‘price freeze’ on annual indemnity renewals until ‘at least’ the summer of 2018 has been announced by one of the UK’s main medical defence organisations.

The Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland (MDDUS) has said it will not increase indemnity premiums for members this year following the Government's announcement that it will legislate to change the size of compensation claims

The group said it would apply to GPs who have faced a complaint since their last renewal.

It comes after there has been protests by GPs at the size of indemnity fee increases, including an open letter in Pulse to health secretary Jeremy Hunt demanding he take urgent action to address the issue. 

GP leaders had warned earlier this year that expected hikes in indemnity costs could make general practice ‘untenable’, following a change last February in the 'discount rate' that calculates the size of compensation claims.

This change meant victims may receive double the amount in compensation, resulting in huge increases in indemnity premiums.

Since February, there had been a stand off between the Department of Health and the medical defence organisations, with MDOs saying they will hold off increasing their fees while they wait for the Government to provide additional funding for GPs. But ministers said they are waiting until the fee rises are announced before deciding what support they will provide.

However, this month Lord Chancellor David Lidington announced the Government was putting forward changes to legislation that would stop this huge potential increase in payouts.

And now the MDDUS has become the first MDO to respond, saying that it was freezing the costs for GPs.

MDDUS Chief Executive Chris Kenny said: ‘Government made a profound misstep in reducing the rate so dramatically in February, but it is to its credit that it has responded promptly to our concerns, coming up with a scheme that is fair to claimants and defendants alike and gives the market greater certainty.

‘We had warned our members that there may have to be further rises in the cost of indemnity during the next few months but I’m delighted to say that will not now be the case.

‘We have confidence that the Government will seek to maintain this momentum and our decision to freeze rates reflects our trust in its good intentions.’

When asked whether this would apply to members who had had a complaint or sanctions in the past year, a spokesperson said: 'Yes, the freeze still applies for those.' 

NHS England last year vowed to pay the increases the costs of indemnity, but this was a flat rate of 52p per patient into the global sum, which GPs warned was being swallowed up by increasing costs in other areas.

Indemnity provider the Medical Protection Society said it had not passed on costs to its members yet, but didn't mention any plans to follow MDDUS in freezing prices.

Simon Kayll, CEO at MPS said: 'We have not made any changes to our GP subscriptions to reflect the change in the discount rate - we are continuing our discussions with the Government about how they will protect GPs from the additional costs.

'We have actively campaigned for support for GPs from the moment the Government announced that it was re-considering the discount rate. We remain focused and committed to working with Government to help to shape a long term sustainable solution.'

The MDU was approached for comment

Readers' comments (10)

  • Let's hope the other companies follow suit

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Really great news so pleased I moved to them in April when MDU without any sort of reasonable explanation sent me a renewal premium up by 40% from the previous year. MDDUS transition was smooth and they are cheaper than MDU were the previous year and cover longer sessions. MDU IMHO have either become too big and lost control of risk or are no longer competitive for other commercial reasons. Be warned !!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • End of the line?

    Hospital colleagues on crown indemnity probably could not care less if indemnity goes up ... Put all GP's on crown indemnity as well..
    Higher compensation has to be better for the poor victims point of view
    Some sort of fair system with higher premiums for those found negligent .... or lower premiums for safer doctors

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So proud that MDDUS are providing for me as well. They had the best offer from start and now made it better. However, Clue is the word freeze. It means suffer with pain but further pain will not be inflicted. Will it remain at that level? If you are a GP with vision and clarity of mind please engage with your local collaboration INT/ PSN and start planning for one of few option of MCP. Once you take ownership of this issue and get a corporate bid for indemnity you will not have to wait for Uncle Sam to help you at cost of your autonomy.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • =mafia of insurances, solicitors, lawyers...
    The more paying indemnities fees to solicitors, lawyers insurances etc... the more insurances, solicitors, lawyers get!!!
    Only one person to pay : The doctor
    So the price (exorbitant sometime), no problem. The Doctor will pay. Patient is nothing in this system...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I don't understand all the happy comments. A price freeze for less than a year means very little. Most doctors' indemnity is up for renewal every August - nothing to stop them hiking the prices for the next renewal in August 2018.
    I see it as a cynical advertising ploy by MDDUS.
    In any case MPS is still cheaper for me (if still exorbitant)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I want to be sure that my risks will be covered should I be sued. Freezing the premiums may not be the wisest action.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • When the chip are down , that once in a professional lifetime major problem you want the best insurance there is. The MDU established my innocence with great skill and care. I would never leave them.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Freeze price is not enough. price need to go down substantially .

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The use of 'price freeze' is misleading - the MDDUS are still increasing rates by 12.5% per year (I just received my renewal with an increase in cost of £1000 since last year). They just aren't yet applying an increase to account for the expected increase in costs due to the change in personal injury discount rate.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say