This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

GPs buried under trusts' workload dump

Patient in GP crossbow attack jailed for 20 years

A patient who blamed his GP for the death of his father and shot him with a crossbow bolt in his surgery was jailed for 20 years today (Friday 15 February).

Mark Waterfall from South Oxhey carried out the attack on Dr Gary Griffith in an attempt to murder him four days after the death of his father in hospital.

Before Mr Waterfall fired the metal tipped bolt, he told the doctor: ‘You killed my father and I am going to kill you.’

The 46 year-old then fired the bolt into the left side of the doctor’s abdomen as he sat at his desk in his consultation room at the Watford surgery writing up his notes.

Today (Friday 15 February) at St Albans crown court Judge Stephen Warner told Mr Waterfall: ‘You fired the bolt into his abdomen from a distance of about five feet. When you did you intended to kill him.’

St Albans crown court heard that the bolt, which travelled at a speed of 187 feet per second, struck Dr Griffith in the left side of his stomach.

Miraculously he survived because it was warm in the room and he had loosened his shirt around his waist that morning so that it was gathered up around his midriff.

It meant the arrow had to pass through four layers of the doctor’s shirt and didn’t penetrate deep enough to kill him.

‘It was pure good fortune that you didn’t succeed,’ the Judge said.

At Waterfall’s trial which ended last month with a jury finding him guilty of attempted murder, the GP said he was able to pull the arrow from out of his stomach wall, telling the jury: ‘Although the wound was gaping, it hadn’t gone into the colon.’

He went on: ‘I had to pull the wound apart to check if it had gone into the bowel. I was still sitting down and I removed the bolt and put it on my desk. I pulled the wound apart to see how far it had gone in.’

As he did so, he said Mr Waterfall looked down at the floor ‘dejected’ and, realising he had failed to kill him, said: ‘I can’t even get that right.’

Judge Warner sentenced Mr Waterfall to an extended 25 year jail sentence after concluding that he was a danger to the public and posed a risk of committing further offences.

The judge said the custodial element of the sentence was 20 years of which he will have to serve two thirds behind bars before the parole board will decide if he is safe to be released.

Whenever that is, Mr Waterfall from Oxhey in Hertfordshire will remain on licence until the year 2044.

The attack on the doctor took place on the morning of July 10 last year at the Suthergrey House Medical Centre in St Johns Road, Watford where the victim was a GP

Dr Griffith said since the incident he has suffered severe nightmares of being murdered and now at work he no longer feels safe.

Judge Warner praised the courage of Dr Griffith whose first thought after the incident had been to follow Mr Waterfall as he went back to his car in an attempt to try and persuade him to give himself up to the police.

Readers' comments (6)

  • I AM AMAZED THAT A JUDGE ACTUALLY TOOK THE CASE SO SERIOUSLY.

    NHS ENGLAND THINK THIS IS "WHAT WE SIGNED UP FOR" AND CALLOUSLY DISREGARD VIOLENCE TOWARDS STAFF.

    MOST OF US HAVE BEEN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE WHICH IS NOT ONLY NOT CONDEMNED BUT WE ARE ASKED TO EXPLAIN AS THE VICTIM WHAT WE MUST HAVE DONE TO "PROVOKE" THE VIOLENT PATIENT.

    THE INSANE DAILY NUTTER IS ONE OF SEVERAL WHICH INDIRECTLY INCITE VIOLENCE WITH THEIR ENDLESS STREAM OF ANTI-GP RHETORIC.

    WHEN ONE DAY A DOCTOR IS KILLED BY A PATIENT (WHICH I HOPE NEVER HAPPENS BUT SEEMS INEVITABLE)JUST MAYBE THE DAILY NUTTER WILL REALISE THE DANGEROUS AND CORROSIVE EFFECT OF ITS OBESSIONAL POLITICAL PROPAGANDA

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Surprised and gratified that a decent sentence was given.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Like the above two commentators I'm rather surprised that this (eminently sensible) sentence has been passed. "Surely it was somehow the doctor's fault".

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Took Early Retirement

    Let's hope he dies in prison.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The ombudsman will probably insist he is retained on the list and is provided with visits by said GP....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • When I was stabbed in the chest by a patient who was cross with me for apparently being unsympathetic The investigation by the CCG made it pretty clear that I was to blame for the attack. I have never worked full time since and the attacker was bound over to “keep the peace”. I made page 6 of the MEN and the front cover was of someone kicking Noel Gallagher’s dads car.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say