This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Retired GP cleared of attempt to hire hitman to kill pensions adviser

A respected family doctor was yesterday convicted of sending his financial advisor ‘desperate’ messages during a five-year ‘vendetta’ - but was cleared of trying to hire a hitman to murder him.

Retired family GP David Crichton sent messages and made a phone call telling pensions expert Andrew Bolden that he would commit suicide if he did not reply.

A court heard Dr Crichton made a series of complaints after receiving what he believed was bad financial advice, causing him to lose £300,000 from his £1.8million NHS pension.

Prosecutors also alleged Dr Crichton, 64, attempted to solicit the murder of Mr Bolden, who works for top banking firm Brown Shipley, by entering his details on a Chechen mafia site on the dark web.

However, the doctor said he only put the details on the site, which he believed was fake, as a mental exercise to ‘clear his head’.

He was convicted of three counts of sending malicious communications and cleared of attempting to solicit murder. He denied all charges.

Fining the doctor £6,000 today for the offences, Judge Mr Justice James Dingemans said the doctor was a man 'self obssessed in the extreme'.

The judge told him: 'There were disputes between you and Brown Shipley, but there are independent reports vindicating the advice given.

'You do not accept that and that is your constitutional right, but it's apparent you became obsessed with the issue.

He added: ''Mr Bolden's victim impact statement shows that what started off as a client complaint had spiralled out of control.

'Mr Bolden said you have "laid a business dispute at my family's door". It also shows the shocking effect of finding out his name had been put on what is claimed to be a Chechen Mafia website.'

During the five-day trial at Winchester Crown Court, Hampshire, jurors heard Dr Crichton waged a ‘campaign’ of harassment against Brown Shipley and Mr Bolden after receiving what he believed to be bad money advice.

Prosecutor Simon Jones told the court: 'In around 2012, Dr Crichton contacted Andrew Bolden for advice on his NHS pension.

'Dr Crichton delayed the advice and he missed certain tax deadlines, incurring penalties. He suffered significant financial loss, which he attributed to the financial advice given.

'The defendant was blaming Andrew Bolden for ruining his life.

'Five years on from the advice, David Crichton sent Andrew Bolden a text to his work phone on February 4, 2017.

'In the message he said, "I am contacting you out of desperation. I believe you are the only person who can help save my life.

' "I have no wish to cause you problems. I am looking to help my family. I am sorry to sound dramatic I may only have a few days now".

'Then on February 16, 2017, Andrew Bolden received a call while in his company’s Edinburgh office.

'David Crichton said, "you don’t need to talk to me, just listen. You know why, because my life is at risk".

'Then there was a final text on March 3, 2017, from Dr Crichton to Andrew Bolden.

'The defendant said, "I remain desperate to speak to you. Since you know my life is at risk, I can’t believe you are obstructing me in this".

'We say that all amounted to him threatening he would commit suicide and we submit there can be no other interpretation to those messages.

'What the prosecution say was the defendant’s vendetta was getting out of control.'

The court heard Dr Crichton had accepted he had entered Mr Bolden’s details on a Chechen mafia website, but said he was ‘sure there was no risk’ to the financial advisor as he knew the site ‘was a scam’.

Prosecutors alleged he had intended for a hitman to accept the contract after Mr Bolden was placed on the website, but the doctor told jurors he had never paid the requested fee.

Opening the case, prosecutor Mr Jones said the ‘kill the bastard’ option on the website was priced at 4.25 Bitcoin, equivalent to £3,800 at the time.

Giving evidence during the trial, Dr Crichton said: 'I was looking as a medical professional, as a guinea pig for a test to see if this would clear my head.

'I do accept that I put his details in the website because it was this idea of throwing away a thought.

'I’m a research doctor and I thought it would be good to research - and actually, it made me feel better.

'I wanted to know if this was a good avenue to pursue to help people with suicidal thoughts.

'First of all I thought this was a scam and secondly I didn’t pay any money, I was sure there was no risk to Andrew, I knew he was safe. I didn’t think I had solicited his murder, it’s totally ludicrous really and unbelievable.'

The doctor, of Bournemouth, Dorset, added: 'I didn’t really think I was soliciting his murder, why would I want to murder someone I only wanted to speak to?'

Following the verdicts, prosecutor Mr Jones told the court he was applying for a restraining order to prevent Dr Crichton from continuing to contact Mr Bolden and Brown Shipley.

 

Readers' comments (10)

  • What Now?

    Great news
    Good job he is retired
    or the GMC would be most interested
    but then again he is white...
    (oooh low blow)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What Now?

    Reminds me of Bill Clinton..
    the instrument gets played
    but hes not playing it ??

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What Now?

    Do his explanations count as good insight
    in the GMC books ??? hmmmm not sure

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Last time I checked John Lithgow was in Hollywood, not a retired British GP.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Cobblers

    The doctor was a man 'self obsessed in the extreme'.

    Hmmmm obvious lack of reflection.

    AND an appraiser as well.

    Appropriate.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Whatever, was it worthwhile publicizing his details and photographs before the legal process pronounced him guilty?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Totally vindicated on the count of soliciting murder and rightly so. How could the DPP have sanctioned the go ahead on such a case?
    As to the 3 emails: read them. Do they pose any threat to the financial adviser whatsoever? No! The only person clearly at risk and vulnerable was the writer. No physical attempt was made to confront the adviser and to claim that he was harassed is ridiculous. The only anxiety that might have been caused to him was by the police notifying that his name was on a spam website.
    What a travesty that such a good, competent and caring doctor of over 35 years standing should be publicly trailed though the mud like this. The victim has been the doctor - no one else.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree with you John. This case made frontline national news. Now that he has been cleared of hiring a ‘hitman’, there is practically no national news reporting this.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • In failing to act appropriately on the emails, (even just to phone and speak to the poor doctor), the financial adviser neglected his moral and professional obligations to alert mental health professionals and protect the life of a severely depressed, maybe suicidal, man.
    Brown shipley should have been in the dock for gross rank negligence in their failure to support him. He was depressed and suicidal - in any other patient excuse to do or say anything! but not a retired mentally ill doctor??
    Even the CPS and court should have seen who was hte real patient here! and yet they failed to get him help too.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Does anyone have any idea, how could he have lost 300 K of money in penalties for not meeting deadlines ?
    I know his pot was 1.8 m but what on earth was the advice and what did he delay to incur such a massive blow from tax office.
    One has to feel for him...poor bloke..feel for him and his family.
    My judgement is neither the GP nor the financial advisor is guilty - if there is any guilty party it is HMRC !!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say