This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Locum GPs set for 'discriminatory' pensions rules from next week

Locums could face increased pensions bills from next week due to 'discriminatory' changes to the rules on contributions, the BMA has warned.

The BMA's GP Committee said they have been having 'repeated correspondence' with NHS Pensions around the 'annualisation' of pensions contributions, which would see all locums being placed at the highest tiers of pensions contributions.

Pulse understands the BMA and NHS Pensions have been meeting regularly to discuss the new rules, but the pensions body has not heeded warnings of potentially negative consequences for GPs.

From April, it is understood that GP locums in the 2015 NHS pension scheme will no longer be able to take breaks between sessions - even one day - as this will result in their pension being automatically annualised, meaning they would almost certainly be required to pay 14.5% in contributions.

Under the current scheme, locums are allowed to stop working for up to three months - against one month for salaried GPs who are part of the scheme - before they are subject to annualisation.

But following a consultation on proposals to change NHS pension scheme regulations the Government decided to remove the three-month rule so that all members of the scheme have their tiered rate calculated using the same rules.

GPC sessional pensions lead Dr Krishan Aggarwal told Pulse: 'The BMA responded to the Department of Health and Social Care consultation on NHS pensions, significant concerns were raised particularly around annualisation however, no changes were made. 

'In fact, from 1 April 2019, the annualisation rules become much worse.  We have had repeated correspondence with NHS Pensions however, it is still not clear how the new rules being introduced on 1 April will work and what the impact will be on GPs.

'It is crystal clear however, that the changes to annualisation being introduced will unfairly penalise any GP that opts to take a break within the pension scheme year as they will then have to pay pension contributions at a higher rate based on their imaginary annualised earnings, rather than their actual earnings.  We continue to believe that annualisation of GP pensions is unfair and discriminatory. 

'In the midst of a workforce crisis with worrying declines in both GP recruitment and retention rates and the ongoing delays in processing pensions payments by PCSE, this is a further pension pressure which will only exacerbate the situation by further damaging the morale of the GP workforce.'

The BMA previously warned against the removal of the three-month rule, as it will discriminate against GP locums, many of which are from groups who have legally protected characteristics (ethnic minorities, women, and those with disabilities), and who are less likely to be in the scheme for a full year.

National Association of Sessional GPs chair Dr Richard Fieldhouse agrees the move will discriminate against locums, especially pregnant women who are more likely to be off work for a longer time.

He said: ’It’s discriminatory against certain people, such as pregnant women, and outrageous to people who have to go and care for parents or children. A lot of people locuming are trying to find the right partnership or salary, using it for good reason or they are locuming because they could retire but are trying to help out struggling practices so they do extra locum work. And all these people are going to be penalised.'

Mr Fieldhouse said he believes it will also push a number of locums to leave the scheme and stop them from doing sessions.

‘I think this will backfire and this is a totally uncreative solution to the problem they have got,' he added.

The DHSC argued keeping 'such exemption would place locums in a significantly advantageous position compared to the rest of the scheme membership who would have their earnings annualised if they had a break from pensionable employment, no matter the length of the break’.

It said: 'The Department has carefully considered the suggestion that locum GPs are more likely to be from groups with legally protected characteristics.

'The research the Department has seen does not support this proposition; notwithstanding this, the Department considers that, if locum GPs were to be from such groups, removing the exemption is justified as exempting locums would place them in a significantly advantageous position.'

Pulse understands the GP locum guidance on pensions will be updated next week.

Example: How much will a locum pay for their pension?

  • A locum provides holiday cover for a local practice.They work eight sessions a week through the school holidays, each session being paid £250.
  • Their actual annual income is £26,000 but their annualised income is £182,500.
  • Instead of paying 7.1% of their income into the NHS Pension scheme, they will pay 14.5%, which amounts to £3,700 instead of £1,806.

Source: Leeds LMC chair Dr Nicola Hambridge, UK LMC Conference 2019

Related images

  • Pension - pensions - retirement - retire - RF

Readers' comments (4)

  • The whole concept of tiered pension contributions for GPs should end. All it means in reality is full time GPs pay a higher contribution (percentage) than part time GPs. That is not necessarily fair and anything which discourages working longer hours should be removed. We clearly cannot change the overall tax system, but small changes like this might make a difference in terms of increasing the total number of GP sessions available.

    The sickness system needs to evolve too. Why should a GP with 2 five session partner roles at different surgeries have better NHS sickness coverage than a GP with a 10 session role in a single surgery? Seems to just penalise working full time.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Locums are getting a massive indemnity expenses cut next week with no strings attached. Partners don’t. The system is still weighted in favour of locums.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • can't charge for pension if work through a locum agency, all it means locum won't ask for pension and go for a private one or keep the money. but as it is this scheme is just going to put locums off - certainly putting me off doing as much. all it means for the loss of pension payments and less GPs more patients end up in A&E so its paying money either way by the NHS. as for young GPs its adding more incentive to work abroad. totally bonkers and pointless. its now estimated by 2034 the uk will be short of 7000 GPs - that's over 10 million patients with no GP cover. the government are supposed to be discussing the GP crises this month - so far all that's been talked about is employing 20,000 more noctors - the end is nigh I fear

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I don't think anyones pensin should be annualised it should be based on annual earnings or whats the point of having tiers related to annual earnings if one person pays more pension than another while earing the same amount just because they did the work in one paret of the year with a break elsewhere.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say