This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

CAMHS won't see you now

Why I retired early

GPs speak to Pulse about why they cashed their pension before 60

dr crow 3x2

dr crow 3x2

‘I’d reached the lifetime allowance. I had high blood pressure, which was almost certainly caused by the stress… added to the fact that I didn’t think that we were able to provide a safe service to our patients.’

Dr Michael Crow, locum GP in Surrey, retired aged 55


dr sally whale 3x2

dr sally whale 3x2

‘I’d always planned to try and retire at 55, and nothing about my work made me consider changing my plans. ‘My generation of doctors worked 80-100 hour weeks, mostly for 30% of normal pay and was told it would be worth it. I did my own on-call for a few years until I had children and only took three months off each time. Having given 38 years to becoming and being a GP, I’m enjoying some me time.’

Dr Sally Whale, GP in Ipswich, retired aged 55 


dr buttar3x2

dr buttar3x2

‘The only thing that could have made me stay was having enough practice income to attract and retain sufficient doctors to reduce everybody’s stress down to a more bearable level.’

Dr Prit Buttar, GP in Scotland, retiring this year aged 59


‘I’ve just run out of steam. Everything is getting harder and I think I’ve battled through with an incredible number of stresses and strains, to keep going and work beyond the call of duty.’

Dr Richard Holman, GP in Barnstaple, retiring in October aged 58


Thinking of cashing in your pension?

dr david bailey wales press photo 3x2

dr david bailey wales press photo 3x2

My advice to anybody thinking about retiring is take individual personal financial advice. You can’t give generic advice, particularly to GPs, because it depends on their lifetime earnings, on what other investments they’ve got and to some extent on their health as well. It also depends on their actual earnings in any given year and what inflation’s doing, so any generic advice is bad advice.

Sometimes if you retire early and you want to carry on locuming, a financial advisor will look very carefully at any potential extra tax you’ll pay, compared with the extra long-term income you can put into your pension, and, again, that will depend on your individual circumstances.

Many GPs think that because they are going to go into a higher tax bracket for lifetime allowance, it’s automatically a good idea to stop. But for some people it isn’t, because the potential extra gains on their pension in the long term still outweigh the fact that they’ve got to pay extra tax and there are other penalties to consider if you take your pension early.

For a lot of older GPs it may not make sense to retire early but for some of them it undoubtedly will. Everybody’s circumstances are different, particularly in general practice because it’s not a salaried job.

Dr David Bailey is pensions lead for the BMA’s GP Committee and chair of the BMA’s Welsh Council

Rate this article  (4.88 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (4)

  • It would be interesting to know what people do after "early" retirement? A new career? Study? Fester?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I retired largely because of revalidation, and the dreadful performance of the GMC. That was 5 years ago. I now spend time with grandchildren and play the alto saxophone.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • So far got my garden back into shape, and had time to think!! Hadn't realised quite HOW exhausted I was mentally until I stopped. Plans include sailing lots, spending time in France where I have inherited a house, and lots of craft stuff. Just waiting for hubby to decompress as he has only just retired and then the world is our oyster.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I retired 9 months ago and it was a difficult decision.
    I was still enjoying parts of the job but felt it was the right time for my family since my husband had retired the year before. I have not regretted it at all. Having spent a career like Dr Sally Whale above I felt that the nhs has had its pound of flesh.

    I spend time walking up hills. Learning French (again) running, birdwatching, photography, yoga reading and travelling as much and as far as I can. I am much fitter and see my family much more.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say