This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Don’t make the same mistake I did with revalidation: start early

Dr Elliott Singer explains the challenges he faced during his own revalidation 

As someone who has been involved in GP education, as a trainer and programme director, I would have expected appraisal and revalidation to be a fairly painless process.

I am not someone who particularly buys into the process of appraisal and revalidation as I don’t believe it will ‘identify the next Shipman’ – nor do I feel it is a good differentiator of quality of practice. Some of us tend to reflect instantly and don’t find much benefit in subsequently reflecting on an action at a later date.


Despite this, I do engage in the process; ensuring that I have completed the required minimum of 50 CPD credit hours per year and including significant event analysis, PUNS/DENS, multisource feedback (MSF) and patient satisfaction questionnaires (PSQs) within the annual appraisal.

I enter evidence into my appraisal on a regular basis, including my reflections. I don’t enter every educational activity that I partake in, but I ensure that there is a variety of educational activity covering all my roles included in the appraisal.


The actual appraisal is, with the right appraiser, quite a positive experience. With two of my previous appraisers in particular, the appraisal has been a time to reflect on what I have done and to make career and educational plans for the future.

It was during one such discussion a few years ago, when I was discussing being a LMC representative and how much I enjoyed this, that I came to the decision to try to be more involved with the LMC. I now find myself as a medical director for Londonwide LMCs with the GP support team and covering north-east London.

Appraisal from this point of view can and should be a positive experience that we all enjoy, instead of a chore. The problem is that appraisal has changed from its original format. It is often viewed as a tick-box exercise to ‘pass’ on an annual basis so that we can be revalidated on a five-year cycle.


My own revalidation came around last year. I had never had any concerns raised with regard to my appraisals so did not give revalidation much thought. I was very surprised to hear my revalidation date was deferred. I contacted my responsible officer and was told I had insufficient reflection on my PSQ, which had been completed one year prior to the revalidation date and had been reviewed at a previous appraisal. After negotiation we agreed a way forward. I subsequently recorded some reflections on the PSQ, discussed this with my current appraiser and entered it onto my appraisal toolkit.


I have since learned from my experience and here is my advice:

• Record educational activities on a regular basis and save these on the toolkit. Do not leave this until the last minute; you won’t be able to complete them. Remember you need at least 50 hours per year; if claiming impact points you need to be able to justify this.

• Check you have completed the required number of significant event analyses (currently two per year) and at least one audit cycle in the five-year period.

• Don’t leave PSQ/MSF until the final year before revalidation. Aim to do this in year three or four of the cycle to give time to reflect and implement any changes identified by these feedback processes.

• Ensure that all entries have been reflected on. Make sure the reflection considers not just what has been learned, but any wider lessons and how these will affect future practice.

Dr Elliott Singer is a GP in Chingford, east London and a medical director at Londonwide LMCs

Related images

  • Dr Elliott Singer 3x2

Rate this article  (2.09 average user rating)

Click to rate

  • 1 star out of 5
  • 2 stars out of 5
  • 3 stars out of 5
  • 4 stars out of 5
  • 5 stars out of 5

0 out of 5 stars

Readers' comments (20)

  • Reflect, reflect. think hard.
    Ha. Ha !
    Time to leave GP land and this utter rubbish behind.
    Oh Joy, I am almost away.
    To those who remain, please do reflect. Is this stuff sh...te or what?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Revalidation is BS exercise!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The answer is to retire, emigrate or leave medicine for somewhere where we are not treated like naughty children by the obsessives and borderline personality disordered who administer this nonsense.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Have just been revalidated. I'm 52. I can guarantee that it'll be my one and only!!!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Once we've done revalidation do we then have to continue appraisals if we're going to retire before the next revalidaton date ? Id love to know because appraisal is such a bullshit waste of time .

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Revalidation is a load of bullshit and every sensible person knows this. My other half and I both retired early to avoid doing it. It is a pointless, demeaning process which contributes zilch

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The common theme here is that revalidation is bullshit. I would like to add that those who appraise are helping to spread the bulshit I,e, they are bullshiters.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Just reading this article has raised my blood pressure . No wonder we are in such a mess with jobsworth 'revalidation officer' police ready to execute you for not 'reflecting'
    It is a form of thought control and is stressful and irritating .maybe the author could reflect on that instead .

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Appraisal is the greatest crime that educationalists have inflicted on the profession. Don't be an apologist for it. Thousands of doctors wasting hundreds of hours = hundreds of thousands of hours of lost family time. It didnt stop Mid-Staffs and it wont stop the destruction of the health service (by the way that is scheduled for August 2016), but it has got us all fiddling while Rome burns. Reflect on that!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • What out Mr Hunt. With doctors doing all that reflection they will realise they are seriously overworked, burnt out, bullied, undervalued but also amazingly skilled and could easily move into a better paid, better appreciated job.
    The coaching on offer would only exacerbate that ( rather than trick them into staying!)

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say