This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Practice managers to carry out GP appraisals, under new NHS scheme

Exclusive GPs could have their performance appraised by a practice manager as NHS bosses threw open recruitment to non-medical applicants, Pulse has learnt.

An advert from NHS England South for Surrey and Sussex encourages anyone who is ’a practice manager or a GP who has found your own appraisals interesting and have contemplated taking on the role previously’ to ‘respond to this article and send your CV’.

NHS England confirmed that GPs who did not wish to be appraised by non-medical professionals could demand to be appraised by a doctor, but said that it needed to ensure it had a sufficient number of trained appraisers.

The GPC said it had ‘heard of’ such schemes being piloted elsewhere in England but that GPs could and should refuse to have their appraisals led by non-clinicians.

The advert comes as some areas of the country are failing to recruit enough medical professionals into appraiser roles. NHS England introduced a new £500 flat fee for appraisals in 2013 that the GPC said may mean some GPs no longer consider it worthwhile to be appraisers and encourage some to ‘walk away’.

But this new scheme would mean GPs potentially having their revalidation decided on appraisals carried out by non-medical professionals.

GPC executive member Dr Dean Marshall said: ’I heard that the scheme had been piloted in different parts of the country [but] you do not have to agree to have non-GPs appraise you. Practice managers, nurses, or anyone else for that matter, will simply not understand what the needs of a GP are. Appraisals should have a supportive function and there has never been a more important time for GPs to have this support.’

NHS England could not confirm or deny reports that it was hiring non-medical professionals as GP appraisers for revalidation in other areas of the country at time of publication.

A spokesperson said: ’Any GP who does not wish to be appraised by a trained appraiser from a non-medical background can ask to be appraised by someone with a clinical background. We liaised in advance with the local LMC, who confirmed that this approach was acceptable. All our appraisers undergo full training in order to fulfill the requirements of their role, including completing regular training and undergoing reviews of their performance.’

But GP appraiser Stephanie di Giorgio, a GP in Kent and co-founder of Resilient GP, said that this could lead to current GP appraisers becoming even busier. She said: It means that employing [practice managers and non medical appraisers] and training them is potentially a massive waste of time and money.’

Revalidation - a longstanding bugbear of busy GPs

The revalidation process - including appraisals - has come under fire from GPs since it was introduced, with some calling it a ‘bureaucratic nightmare’ and saying it can take over 70 hours to complete. Last year, GP leaders branded revalidation as ‘a waste of time’ as official data revealed that less than 1% of all doctors actually needed remediation.

After the first year of the scheme, more than one in ten GPs have had their revalidation deferred by the regulator and critics say that the process is less about ensuring patient safety and more about enforcing tighter constraints on doctors.

But the GMC has commissioned an independent review of revalidation to ‘refine the system’ once every doctor has been through it.

Readers' comments (35)

  • A ''Poisoned Chalice'' both parties.......... for the PM and the GP

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Further demedicalisation of medicine. Stop this appraisal nonsense.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We should just start saying NO.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The GMC state that you can only appraise someone if you have a responsible officer or a suitable person.
    When I was between jobs I was told I would be unable to carry out appraisals despite having an MA in medical education, having done appraisals before with specific 'training' and having previously been a clinical tutor, educational and clinical supervisor (I'm a consultant psychiatrist).
    If this is the case are the GMC changing the rules?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I am absolutely fuming, raging and ....well words cannot say!
    I wanted to revalidate but could not as I could not find a suitable responsible officer for my highly specialised field of medicine. So I had to leave medicine.
    So now they are allowing anyone with NO clinical knowledge or worse still with a little idea of knowledge to judge doctors????? I mean ×€$&$;#&!(=*/*#......
    So why was I forced to go then?
    My goodness what a dogs dinner this all is? My human rights have been trampled all over along with many others too.
    Actually I am glad to have gone now as now revalidation is becoming a farce. You could not make it up.......

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Nice little earner, but no thanks.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • My father who was an ex bank manager spent a few years aftrer retiring from the bank, as a practice manager. He was very good at his job as it was within his sphere of competance, however for him to assess doctors?????
    He told me that it would not be a thing he would have wanted to do or be able to do as he had no knowledge of medicine and clinical medical practice.
    It has got to the point when the revalidation system has become a complete farce designed to intimidate, supress and kick out doctors from the system.
    It is an insult to expect non medics to judge medics without a whiff of any training or anything else.
    But the GMC know this as their whole structure has been debased from starting out as all doctors to judge their peers to car ticket inspectors to judge doctors. So why not go the whole way to remove all doctors from this train crash, would be their misguided thought train.
    The GMC is now not fit for purpose and there should be a government petition and debate about this too now.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Apparently Facebook is to replace the CQC in assessing Hospitals. Perhaps we should all set up professional Facebook accounts and ask patients and colleagues to "Like" us. This should make everyone happy - no?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • whosoever had this brain wave just thought that we will demean the Doctors and get the thing done on the cheap-i think i will try the next appraisal of mine by a practice manager and see the tears flowing

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment


    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say