This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

GPs refute briefing claims that they are 'referring large numbers to A&E'

More than 450 GPs and primary care staff have signed an open letter after an emergency medicine professor suggested in last night's Government briefing that practices have 'referred large numbers of patients to the emergency department'. 

Named as 'Suzanne from Chesterfield', Professor Suzanne Mason, professor of emergency medicine at the University of Sheffield, made the comments in the live televised briefing with the Prime Minister, chief medical officer and chief scientific officer - the final of the daily updates. 

During the questions from members of the public, Professor Mason asked: ‘When will primary care and dental practices be encouraged to work normally again now that the threat level is at three? We are seeing large numbers of patients referred to the emergency department because their GP or dentist are refusing face to face consultations. How soon will they be getting back to normal?’

Professor Chris Whitty, the chief medical officer, replied: ‘GPs have of course been working throughout this and done an absolutely fantastic job if I may say so to my colleagues.

‘Inevitably, to reduce the risk of transmission – to reduce the risk that people come into contact in waiting rooms and indeed between clinical staff and patients – they have changed the way they’ve worked and many of those changes are actually things that make sense for the longer term, even if it wasn’t for coronavirus.’

The GPs' open letter - which at time of publication has been signed by 452 primary care staff - reads: ‘During the Prime Minister’s daily coronavirus briefing on 23 June, [Professor Suzanne Mason] stated that “large numbers of patients” were being referred to the emergency department in which she works because their GP or dentist had refused to see them face-to-face.

‘As general practitioners, we wish to reassure the public that NHS GP surgeries are open and available to patients who need us, and have been throughout the pandemic. In order to safeguard the public from unnecessary risk, GPs have shifted to online and telephone consulting where safe and appropriate.

‘We hope that Suzanne’s comments do not deter patients from approaching their GP if needed, and respectfully invite Suzanne to spend a day with a local GP so she can see first-hand how hard NHS GPs are working during this pandemic.’

The letter's author, Dr Heather Ryan, a GP in Warwickshire, explained: ‘I found Suzanne's comments very frustrating, as it feeds the public perception that general practice has been closed during the pandemic. In fact, GP surgeries have been open throughout. What has changed is the way in which GPs are working - to minimise the risk of coronavirus transmission, GPs have moved to other forms of consulting, such as telephone and video calls.

‘I started the open letter because I wanted to reassure the public that general practice is still very much open for business.  I don’t feel it’s helpful that a consultant colleague talked about general practice in this way on national television.'

One of the signatories, London GP Dr Thomas Round, added: ‘The comments show a total lack of understanding of primary care and the massive changes we have made almost overnight in the face of a pandemic. We have on the whole moved to a full triage system of digital/phone access to keep patients and staff safe.’

The sentiment also won the support of NHS England’s medical director of primary care, Dr Nikki Kanani, while a Facebook post from ‘Dr Rant’ has warranted almost 3,000 likes today on the topic.

Pulse has contacted Professor Mason, who declined to comment. 

Readers' comments (28)

  • Totally agree with Phil. It was a very loaded question and it implies that GPs and dentists have been wilfully refusing to see patients when that is not true. It’s really sad to see a fellow medical colleague behaving like this. I can’t stand the whole hospital vs primary care attitude; it’s nothing but destructive and serves no purpose. We should all be supporting and working with each other to deliver care as safely as possible.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I think it should also be pointed out that since so many hospital appointments and all routine surgery have (understandably) been delayed or cancelled and (certainly in my area) GP access to X-rays/scans etc are severely restricted it seems inevitable that more patients will end up being admitted as emergencies.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Not to worry Professor. Not only has your hospital trust had all its debts written off - after being supported for years by the locality CCG - meaning you will have abundant new toys and staff very soon, you will be picking up the increased demand/ waiting list initiatives from autumn. £2000 per day incentives to "meet demand" will help you get better from your sadness and disappointment..

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • National Hopeless Service

    Its a complex beast. I did a gastro referral a few days ago, cant do FCP at present, for someone who probably has colitis. Advised the patient there will be extended wait so she took it upon herself to go to A&E. The whole of the NHS isnt quite open.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • WHAT EXACTLY IS A PROFESSOR OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE?-----NEVER HAD ONE IN MY DAY

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • doctordog.

    We all know patients who have come to serious harm or died because of the triage and admitting procedures of local A+E departments.
    Is her statement just a diversionary tactic?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • You got one lonely GP caring for 2500 complex people. And he refers some in. So he might not DIE alone. Big deal NHS. You are becoming a scandalous employer.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • We should recall that A&E didn’t stop offering core services and move to video consultations and phone calls.
    If patients turned up we saw them.
    For most patients a phone call or a video consult is a poor second best to a face to face encounter.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Professor Mason looking for a senior NHSE role and a dong
    Newsflash- Professor Suzanne being mobbed by NHSE to work for them
    2 years later: Professor Suzanne is on the Honors list
    While in the real world- GPs slogging their backsides off with even further reduced numbers.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hospital colleagues act as if they are a separate 'tribe' from primary care and a lot of the time they are oblivious of the prescribing restrictions we are under, expecting us to prescribe unlicensed meds or meds not on formulary.
    There needs to be some kind of 'coordinator' so that secondary care doctors have a better understanding of what goes on in Primary care.
    The final year students i teach from Birmingham University have a greater understanding once they leave the post.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say