This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Leading doctors oppose calls to charge patients for GP appointments

Leading doctors have rejected calls for the BMA to consider charging patients for GP appointments in order to fund the NHS.

A motion put forward at the BMA’s Annual Representative Meeting today was rejected in all parts, with leading GPs at the conference saying that co-payments are 'a tax on sickness' and 'clearly not right'.

The issue was previously debated at last year's LMCs conference in Edinburgh, when GP leaders tasked the GP Committee with creating a list of the charging options available and their potential positives and negatives, despite warnings that passing the motion would send the wrong message. 

The motion, put forward by doctors from the BMA divison in Gloucestershire, said: 'That this meeting, in the light of the current resource and funding crisis in the NHS ... believes co-payments from patients should be considered.' 

Speaking for the motion, Dr John O’Driscoll, a GP from Worcester, said: ‘Allowing co-payments would mean there is more money in the system and will raise the standard of care available to the most vulnerable.’

He added: ‘Conference I’m only asking for consideration of co-payments, not an American system of healthcare. The time has sadly come, indeed it is long past, for such pragmatism. Help our most vulnerable, conference, and don’t let misplaced ideology and rhetoric continue to penalise them.’

A Pulse survey has previously revealed that over half of GPs are in favour of the NHS charging a small fee for routine appointments, with many believing it is the only way of managing their workload.  

Meanwhile, a YouGov poll of 2,000 UK adults in 2015 found that almost one in four British people is willing to pay for GP appointments.

But speaking against the motion, junior doctor representative Dr Cameron Spence said co-payments in dentristry have led to 'delays in patients presenting with healthcare problems, which makes their management and treatment far more complex'.

He said: ‘Charging patients will inevitable increase healthcare inequality. Haven’t patients got enough barriers to accessing healthcare without cost being one?'

Dr Spence, who was previously a dentist, said: ‘Dentistry has seen a widening in oral health inequality, certainly since the introduction of the imposed 2006 dental contract and the insidious slide towards privatisation in dentistry in inevitable. Let’s not make the same mistake here.’

BMA council chair Dr Chaand Nagpaul, a GP in London, said: ‘Co-payments are a tax, but it’s a tax on sickness. Those that are the illest end up paying more and that’s clearly not right. It strikes at the heart of everything that I stand for and most of you stand for.

‘We need to reject this whole motion.’

The delegates rejected the motion by 164 to 47 votes.

The motion in full:

Motion by THE AGENDA COMMITTEE (TO BE PROPOSED BY GLOUCESTERSHIRE DIVISION):

That this meeting, in the light of the current resource and funding crisis in the NHS:-

i) calls on the BMA to encourage the government to consider alternative means of funding the NHS;

ii) calls on the BMA to lobby for alternative funding streams for social care;

iii) believes co-payments from patients should be considered. 

Source: BMA

Readers' comments (19)

  • Leading Drs Pah!,more of the same the slow degradation of the primary care workforce.How many of our limited session wonders will step up to the plate when there is non of the front line troops there.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dear All,
    it would also become a pay for service charge willingly taken up by the affluent and worried well
    regards
    Paul C

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Protecting the altar of the NHS despite decades of abuse, burn out and broken promises. There are many other ways to fund healthcare that many other progressive countries use with excellent results for doctors, patients and tax payers. Unfortunately our profession has been brain washed that the NHS is the "best" and the only way to deliver healthcare despite it being horrific for them on a daily basis.

    The profession only has itself to blame.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Pulse should desist from using the term 'leading doctors' in the context of GP's.
    In effect it's a 'Daily Mail ism'and should not ever appear in a 'trade publication '.
    There are those who can,they 'do'',there are those who can not and sit on BMA committee 's.
    Please stop insulting the capable majority by using this perjorative term.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Council of Despair

    I thought we were learning from Babylon? i.e. charge and cherry pick?

    who are the leading doctors? I know the same ones that have led us for the last 10 years - with friends like that who needs enemies?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Does anyone seriously give a bent penny what the BMA Quislings think?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • These so called leading doctors lead in feathering their own nests.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Leading doctors my foot. Until you control demand no amount of resources will work unless it is unlimited which it is not. Charging and make it time based like the lawyers is the way forward to control demand and workload. I saw a hypochondriac teenager yesterday and sent her to psychiatry. 11 appointments in June.8 in May and 6 in April etc. Where does it stop?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Vinci Ho

    Well , it is a bit like the vote on third runway in Heathrow yesterday (with a tale to tell : Where is Boris ? He was crushed by the bulldozer! You killed Boris(instead of Kenny),you bastards!!).Strong opposition arguments but the political reality is a 164 vs 47 with a big margin to reject the motion . My belief has not changed : weekday appointments free ; all weekend GP appointments should be charged for a full fee.
    I guess this issue will never go away...........

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Dr Spence does make a good point a about dental health inequality since the 2006 contract. But he fails to add dentists have a better work life balance and pay compared to GPs. I've lost count of the amount of times I see dental problems as 'we're free', and 'can't you just give me some antibiotics, doc'.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say