This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

Practice closures campaign presents 20,000 signatures to Downing Street

GPs, MPs and patients have handed over 20,000 signatures to Prime Minister David Cameron today, warning that removal of funding will lead to patients living with the ‘uncertainty of whether they are going to have a GP to go to’.

At a ‘Save Our Surgeries’ rally in front of 10 Downing Street, Labour MPs accompanying NHS campaigners – led by GPs from the at-risk Jubilee Street Practice in east London - demanded that NHS England reversed the ‘dreadful decision’ to withdraw the minimum practice income guarantee (MPIG) and withhold the names of the 98 GP practices most at risk as a result.

Pulse also attended the rally at 10 Downing Street today to highlight our Stop Practice Closures campaign that is calling for the Government to step in an ensure that no practice at risk of closing as a result of funding swings such as the MPIG withdrawal and the review of PMS contracts, via an online petition to the Government.

This followed an investigation that has found that over 100 practices are already teetering on the brink of collapse.

Labour MP for Bethnal Green and Bow Rushanara Ali, who gave support to the Pulse campaign, told protestors: ‘Nearly 100 GP surgeries face closures because the Government has changed the funding formula and it is taking money away from deprived areas, such as in east London where 22 GP surgeries face closure.’

‘This is completely unacceptable.’

She added that the Government must disclose the names of the GP practices most at risk as a result of the withdrawal of MPIG.

As previously reported by Pulse, NHS England has not even informed the GPC of their identity, as the Government is also withholding a secret list of potential PMS practice losses and has refused a Freedom of Information request from Pulse to release the names.

Ms Ali said: ‘To this day they have failed to announce those GP surgeries up and down the country, which means patients live with uncertainty of whether they are going to have a GP to go to, never mind having an appointment. ‘

Poplar and Limehouse MP Jim Fitzpatrick said: ‘My team and I will continue to work with Rushanara and [other Labour MPs] to support the GP surgeries, Sam Everington and his CCG, everybody who wants to make sure that the message to the Government is loud and clear. The NHS is not for sale and our GP practices are not for closing, and we will take this fight all the way.’

The Jubilee Street Practice campaign is calling for 22 at-risk practices operating in the London boroughs of Tower Hamlets and Hackney to be offered a long-term funding solution to be able to stay open and continue to deliver a high-quality service to their patients, many of which live in the most deprived conditions in England.

In a letter to Prime Minister David Cameron, which was handed in with the petition, 11 Labour MPs jointly warned that the reduced funding to practices reliant on the MPIG will have ‘serious implications for thousands of people’, not just in London but across the country.

The letter to Mr Cameron said: ‘Reduced funding resulting in the potential closure of GP surgeries not only in Tower Hamlets but nationwide will undoubtedly have serious implications for thousands of people who expect to be able to visit their local GP services they know and trust. The Government’s reforms will be damaging to people’s healthcare and will particularly harm some of the poorest communities in the country.’

‘In Tower Hamlets alone there are high levels of poverty and health inequalities with over 40% of children living in poverty and life expectancies below the national average, these changes will be devastating.’

Also speaking at the rally, GPC deputy Dr Richard Vautrey said: ‘We used to get 11%, just 11% of the NHS cake in terms of funding, now we receive 7.5%. That means we only have three-quarters of the funding that we used to have to be able to deliver the services to our growing needs for patients.’

RCGP honourary secretary Nigel Mathers, also speaking, said: ‘How can we have reached a situation where things have become so bad that GP practices, which are the lifeblood of local communities, that GP practices are at the threat of closure. Some of which is going to take place within months and where patients are at real risk of having no family doctor to turn to when they are ill.’

Dr Naomi Beer, a GP partner at the Jubilee Street Practice, said: ‘Our patients often tell us how much they appreciate the high quality, accessible service that Jubilee Street provides. We’ve already taken pay cuts to try to keep going, but we can’t absorb such a huge loss. It breaks my heart to think that our patients, some of them among the poorest in the country, are at very real risk of losing their GP practice. We are asking the Government to take action to ensure all practices receive a fair allocation of funds.’

Created with flickr slideshow.

Related images

  • Save our surgeries - online

Readers' comments (6)

  • Vinci Ho

    Good luck

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I thought he had gone on his holidays so he wasn't there

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Matthew 7:6 "Do not give what is holy to the dogs,nor cast your pearls before swine,lest they trample their under their feet and in turn tear you in pieces"

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • ha ha

    this story is in none of the papers ... people just don't care.

    however, grumpy cat has a new book out as featured in the guardian.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Una Coales

    Wrong strategy. 100,000 signatures needed for any debate in the House of Commons. Asking for more public money in the context of a national public deficit of £1.4 trillion is unreasonable. Allowing GPs to set their own prices, supplement income to sustain a viable business, and autonomy to deliver medical care without being tied to financial targets and reams of bureaucratic red tape, would be the answer and for that it requires some form of industrial action.

    It is now too late to save general practice. Which medical student with a £83k-£100k student loan, would voluntarily opt for a career in general practice which involves training for 3 years to then pay £1563 each time to sit a potentially career breaking CSA exit licencing exam?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I do not understand all this, really. A recent Times article stated that we GPs earn about 120000. So how much does Naomi Beer earn and these other practices faced with closure actually earn?
    Here, across the water in NI, average profit per patient year is £60 for about 7 consults. As others have pointed out, if you factor in 40% paperwork, this translates to less than £6 per consult and less than £3 take home pay.
    But I thought that GPs in England manage almost £ 4 per consult, which is a tiny fee and great value, but can bring in more than 100000 a year based on 40+ consults each day.
    So, how much per consult do these practices facing closure actually earn?

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say