This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

pul jul aug2020 cover 80x101px
Read the latest issue online

Independents' Day

RCGP pushes for overseas GPs to remain on UK performers list to combat recruitment crisis

Exclusive: GPs who emigrate to practise abroad could be allowed to remain on the performers list under plans to tackle the GP recruitment crisis being discussed by the RCGP and NHS England, Pulse can reveal.

The College is proposing allowing GPs to have their annual appraisal whilst in another country, possibly via Skype, in a bid to remove barriers for GPs wanting to return to practise in the UK, RCGP chair Dr Maureen Baker told Pulse.

It is also seeking funding and developing plans with Health Education England for creating in-practice, back to work schemes to help those returning after time abroad or a career break, as part of a set of principles for returners agreed on Saturday with NHS England and the GPC.

Dr Baker said that the NHS was ‘desperate’ to increase the GP workforce, so it was ‘ludicrous’ that there were so many barriers for GPs wishing to return to work. Meanwhile Dr Mike Bewick, NHS England’s deputy medical director, told Pulse Live in Manchester last week that the Government was looking to work with overseas regulators to help GPs return from abroad.

Pulse revealed last week that Government ambitions to get 50% of medical trainees into general practice had taken a serious blow, as annual training figures show 40% of training places in some areas are unfilled.

And the RCGP’s ‘Put patients first: support your GP’ campaign has been calling on politicians to redress the funding imbalance for general practice in order to recruit GPs and to alleviate some of the workload which is seeing medical students opt for careers in hospitals instead.

Dr Baker said: ‘I think it’s fair to say, that I have very much promoted the issue of returners, and how ludicrous it is that at a time when we are desperate for general practice workforce, that there are really very significant barriers to allow people to return to pick up their careers in general practice and the NHS.’

‘We’re exploring the possibility that these doctors could have their appraisal while they’re overseas. Then they would be eligible to be on the performers list, while overseas. And that would then let them be able to apply from abroad.’

‘There’s nothing stopping these doctors being able to collect their evidence and their e-portfolio of their learning, and skills that they have. Some may get good experience abroad that would be incredibly useful in the NHS, so there’s nothing to stop them collecting that information into their portfolio.’

‘If they were then able to have an appraisal by Skype, and then accept the PGP, then it seems to me, that they could then be eligible for the NHS performers list.’

‘But not all returners are the same, you can’t say that someone who’s been working out in general practice in Sydney is in the same position as someone who’s had a career break for five years and has done no clinical work in that time. They’re two very different situations.’

And Dr Baker said the College was looking at ways to streamline any retraining for GPs returning to work after a career break. More than 1,100 GPs under the age of 50 (representing 3.5% of the total) left the GP workforce between 2011 and 2012, according to the NHS Information Centre, the majority of whom were women. 

She said: ‘Not all returners are the same, you can’t say that someone who’s been working out in general practice in Sydney is in the same position as someone who’s had a career break for five years and has done no clinical work in that time. They’re two very different situations.’

‘It’s entirely possible, and may be desirable, for doctors to have time out, and they may be very keen to have a period of attachment to a practice and then undertake an assessment that seems appropriate for them.’

‘But we are looking for funded schemes to support doctors in that situation, so that they can have a safe, protected route back to practice. ‘

Dr Bewick said: ‘I would like to do a bit of work with some of the other countries’ regulators – the Australian equivalent of the GMC for instance – to try and see if we can get some cooperative agreement so that people, if they do come back it is a shorter training programme.’

HEE’s director of strategy and planning, Jo Lenaghan, said HEE had been working on getting nurses back into work which it would be applying to GPs.

She said: ‘We want to see what is it we can do while working with the RCGP that can address[ recruitment] quicker. It takes five or six years to train a GP so if we can get people back to work much quicker, it will be much better value for the tax payer, and better for staff.’

Related images

  • Dr Maureen baker - online

Readers' comments (30)

  • Vinci Ho

    It is obviously desperate as far as RCGP and NHSE are concerned , my simple question is how do these colleagues now working abroad actually think about this ? I couldn't be asked with all these loops and hoops to jump through before coming back??

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • UK trained doctors who work overseas or take a career break up to 2 years should be able to return no questions asked regardless of whether they have maintained appraisal or not. You do not lose basic clinical skills quickly and bread and butter general practice does not change very much. I have far more concerns about EU trained doctors with no UK primary care experience, language barriers and non UK equivalent training being allowed to work in the UK without any restrictions. To be honest they need the equivalent of a returner scheme to train them to manage in UK general practice. Alas EU rules will not allow this.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • At last, some common sense on this draconian ruling. It is so refreshing to hear positive comments about GP's choosing to work overseas, and it would make all the difference if we were welcomed back and supported. Dr Maureen Baker is definitely on the right track to making a difference.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree that doctors working abroad should be welcomed back, but would not accept that the demands on them re appraisal should be different from those working in the UK.
    I know GPs who come back to do sessions here in order to maintain their place on the performers list and have a yearly appraisal.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Took Early Retirement

    How odd: only a short while ago a senior DOH person was telling us there was no problem.

    How about a 25% pay rise for starters?

    No one abroad is likely to want to come back now.

    Hee Hee!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • No way that I would come back from working in Australia to general practice in the UK. Over here I'm treated with respect, have enough time to do a proper job - not superficial 10 minute appointments, and am paid much better. Also when I tried to de-register from the GMC they tried to treat me like a criminal, insisting that I prove I had no complaints against me before relinquishing my licence to practice - I was face with lots of paperwork and phone calls, so I simply decided not to send them any more cheques - problem solved!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • This is shutting the door after the horse bolted. Sadly the GMC/RCGP have taken to treating doctors like dirt on their shoes and frankly I'd be surprised if many of the escapees would want to come back. In fact you are probably going to get better quality education in the antipodes or Canada than the UK these days with it's depressing obsession with box ticking and mind numbing tedium. A better proposal would be to to ask MPs to shut down revalidation, quantify how much damage has been done to GP numbers and wasted resources, restore lost funds to medical education, repair the harm to patient care and finally investigate how this mess was allowed to happen and who should be held accountable.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • If I thought it was easier to return if i hated it, it might just give me that final push to try things abroad....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Can we blame GPs for leaving the country? Even a superficial glance over any article or headline in Pulse makes for frankly depressing reading. Worse still - it is mostly all true.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Personally I'm getting out ASAP and never coming back.

    Even if there is a 25% pay rise,revalidation is scrapped and the Daily Wail is told by their political friends to say nice things about GP's every day.

    Why? Well for starters I'm just in from work and had dinner, kids in bed long ago.

    They've had their pound of flesh from all of us. I feel sorry for younger GP's though have to admit I hadn't planned to go quite so soon.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page50 results per page

Have your say