This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Read the latest issue online

Gold, incentives and meh

Department of Health denies NHS 'privatisation' claims

The Government has denied that it is ‘privatisating’ healthcare in England, in response to a unions’ campaign damning the Coalition’s NHS reforms.

In a statement, published on the Department of Health website on Thursday (24 July), ministers stated that their reforms are ‘not about privatisation, but about… putting clinicians, rather than politicians, in control of healthcare’.

The Unite union has campaigned since last year and had staged a 55,000-strong rally in Manchester during the annual Conservative Party conference, and accused the Government of outsourcing £7bn worth of NHS contracts to the private sector over the last three years at a greater cost to the taxpayer than if the contracts had been kept with NHS providers.

It comes as Andy Burnham, Labour’s shadow health secretary, was due to make a speech on Tuesday where he would call for a ‘halt’ to the NHS privatisation at least until next year’s general election.

He will say: ‘Contracts are being signed that will run for the five years of the next parliament, and beyond. This is not acceptable. Contracts like this will tie the hands of the next Government in a crucial area of public policy. But, even worse, they are being signed without a mandate from the public. The Prime Minister was not up front about these plans at the last election. He needs to be reminded that he has never been given the permission of the public to put the NHS up for sale in this way.’

However the DH has now hit back at such claims, stating that its ‘modernisation’ of the NHS is ‘necessary, in patients’ interests and is the right thing to do to secure the NHS for future generations’.

The DH said: ‘Ministers have stated that the Government’s reforms are not about privatisation, but about placing the financial power to change health services in the hands of those NHS professionals whom the public trust most, and putting clinicians, rather than politicians, in control of healthcare.’

‘The principles the NHS was founded on will remain as important in the future as they were when the NHS was created: of healthcare free at the point of use, funded from general taxation and available to all based on need rather than the ability to pay. Clinical services will continue to be available on the basis of need, as they are now.’

‘One of the main benefits of the Health and Social Care Act 2012 will be the reduction in administration costs that it delivers, and ministers expect savings to far outstrip the cost of the reforms. The department estimates that savings will total £6.5 billion by next year, all of which will have been re-invested in patient care.’

But Unite have hit back, saying: ‘Despite the Government’s denials, Unite believes that the privatisation of our NHS is increasing. The Health and Social Care Act (2012) has unleashed chaos into the health service. A full competitive market is trampling on cooperation and fragmenting service delivery, paving the way for private companies to cherry pick the most profitable treatments.’

‘In just three years £7bn of new NHS contracts have flooded the private health care market– a figure set to soar to £20bn in the next few years.’

Listing the reasons why it opposes the NHS reforms brought in 1 April last year, bringing with it the section 75 clause forcing commissioners to put services out to competitive tender, Unite said ‘it costs more, service quality decreases and patients suffer, it creates health inequalities, it fragments services [and] leads to a race to the bottom in staff terms and conditions’.

It comes as last week, DH annual accounts revealed that spend on buying healthcare services from non-NHS providers topped £10bn for the first time in 2013/14, while spending on GP services reduced 2.3%. Separately to the Unite initiative, BMA and RCGP are both running campaigns to increase spending on GP services as a total of NHS spending, and Pulse has launched an e-petition for the Government to stop GP practice closures.

Click here to sign Pulse’s petition to stop GP practice closures


Readers' comments (11)

  • Vinci Ho

    That is why it is called Ministry of Truth.
    My friend , the 'truth' for you lot to learn.....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha






    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 28 July 2014 7:57pm

    couldn't have said it better ... can primary care now hurry up and collapse.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • the road to privatisation of the NHS has truly begun. there is no going back from this shambolic state of affairs.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • If you think this is laughable, think again.

    Responding to Andy Burnham's accusation of privatization by back door
    'NHS England said most funding decisions were now being made by groups of GPs, who were given the purse-strings in the NHS reforms.'

    They are putting the blame on us, as we've all predicted. Guess what, when NHS WE will be blamed and the politicians laughing all the way too the bank

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree with 8.49am. GPs are in the minority on our CCG, most places are filled with NHSE lackeys who treat every edict from them as gospel. The GPs have no choice but to go with the flow. Investment in our locally commissioned services is reducing all the time whilst the administrative burden on each remaining one increases. Practice Managers are leaving at an alarming rate, with those still clining on demoralised and depressed. When patients can't get appointments at surgeries or hospitals, when waiting times for operations is months rather than weeks and when procedures we all had access to are no longer available, the Government will be able to wash their hands and say - "Well it was GP Commissioning that caused this".

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • When you do not value oneself and put yourself at the mercy of everyone because what would people away otherwise , when you do not promote self respect and you have a bunch of yes men and women what do you expect , when everything is up sh*ts creek then you can all reminisce about the good old days ??we are all such a bunch of goody goody lets play by the rules and understand that the world has it tough so we should understand and nit expect anything g but yes the responsibility of all the disaster that is our destiny and how safe we deny everyone the option to blame doctors off everything ...what a load of
    I heard the above in a tavern the views are not mine any resemblance or association to anyone is purely coincidental

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Totally agree with 8.49, but by numbers of us staying in commissioning we are all being dragged into the trap which has been set by politicians.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 10bn on private companies from public funds 7bn and falling on primary care,DH in cloud cuckoo land as usual don't worry they will pay for this one day

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • In answer to the headline that the DoH are denying privatisation claims, I am reminded of the wisdom of Mandy Rice-Davies: 'They would, wouldn't they!'

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

View results 10 results per page20 results per page

Have your say