This site is intended for health professionals only

At the heart of general practice since 1960

Analysis: What is the future for small and single-handed practices?

Dr Laurence Buckman says single-handers can reap rewards from getting involved in local decision-making

The economic squeeze that all GPs feel is even worse for single-handers. As a single-hander you can’t exercise the economies of scale as well as a medium or large practice. Either you must pay to employ more people, or more skilled people, or do more yourself.

I work as a single-handed GP as part of a corporate group. We share a lot, and if we didn’t I don’t think we could run our practices. But even so, we’re only three GPs, and an even bigger grouping would be better. True single-handers must be working really hard at the moment.

Single-handed GPs often struggle to engage with the LMC or CCG because they find it hard to find the time to do their work and go to meetings. But I would advise GPs – whether single-handed or not – to start saying yes to invitations from these groups. At the moment, nobody’s got the time for the work that’s being piled on general practice. Everyone’s working in the evenings too but that does not mean you should stay away from involvement.

If you’re not part of local decision-making, you risk feeling isolated, which makes you more vulnerable to being bullied or picked off by the local health authorities. There is safety in numbers. Showing your interest and involvement with local commissioning despite your size gives you more protection, and might also provide them or you with new perspectives on your business.

After all, small practices have their advantages. We are more resilient because we’re more independent. We can exercise greater individualism. We can react faster – if something needs changing we can do it without having to have a long practice meeting. Our openness to trying new things also means that when CCGs ask if someone will run a pilot, you can say yes.

Combining my role on the GPC with single-handed practice is hard work, but I still really enjoy it. At a small practice it feels like I and my patients have a kind of mutual ‘ownership’. The relationship is priceless - we’ve invested in each other, respect each other, and enjoy a high level of continuity of care, which brings its own benefits.

I’d recommend it to anyone looking for a challenging second role – for instance, someone with partnership experience or a spell as a locum, looking for the next step. It’s the kind of work that gets you out of bed in the morning!

Dr Laurence Buckman is a  single-handed GP in north London and chair of the GPC

Readers' comments (4)

  • Hazel Drury

    I love going to meetings but those that will pay for a locum whilst I am away from the practice are few and far between :-( Being single handed means you don't get to have any holiday as it gets so expensive to pay for locums to cover you for long periods - by that I mean longer than 3 working days. A week off costs me £2.5K so it's been a few years since I managed that.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Ellie Broughton

    Thanks for your comment, Dr Drury - as a lot of the doctors in the tips feature have said, they simply don't appoint locums as it's so expensive.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Well done Dr Buckman its about time someone recognized that single handed GPs do work hard and are responsive to change. I myself ofer services to all GPs in the town which include Vasectomies carpal tunnel and nerve conduction studies. Its about the time people recognized our worth tio the NHS.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • I agree entirly how hard single handed GP to work, and also agree with colleagues about locum costs, I was single handed for 30 yrs, now part retired,and I did not take holiday for 15 yrs, then three singles gp joint togather and went PMS, through that money we employed a partner between 3 of us and that was a great relief

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say